ThatsSewPersonal

Fun and Unique Personalized Gifts!

Canton, Ohio

| 25,511 Sales |

ThatsSewPersonal is a Star Seller!

Smooth shipping

Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

Average review rating is 4.8 or higher

Jennifer

Contact

Following shop Follow shop

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Items

Baby Bib, Baby Gift, Embroidered Baby Bib , Baby's 1st Baseball Season , Baby Baseball Bib , My 1st Baseball Season , Baby's First Year

$12.00

Fun Plush Stuffed Heart , Smiling Heart Plush , Personalized Plush Heart , Valentine Gift , Valentine Heart , Available in 4 Sizes

$8.00

Embroidered Bunny Bracelet , Vinyl Bracelet , 7" Snap Bracelet , Child's Bracelet , Fun Gift , Easter Basket Gift , Easter Bunny Sunglasses

$8.00

Embroidered Felt Easter Basket , Personalized Easter Basket , Personalized Felt Easter Treat Basket , Personalized Gift

$25.00

Key Fob , Key Chain , Bag Tag , Embroidered Vinyl Senior 2024 Fob , Key Fob with Ring , Senior Gift

$8.00

Ornament , Embroidered Vinyl School Crayon Ornament , Photo Frame Ornament, Vinyl Christmas Ornament , Christmas Decoration

$7.50

Embroidered Cotton Quilted Mug Rug , Bunny & Lamb Set , Bunny Coaster , Lamb Coaster , Spring Easter Mug Rug , Sold Individually or as a Set

$8.00

Plush Stuffed Heart Shaped Bunny , Personalized Plush Bunny Heart , Easter Gift , Bunny Heart , Available in 4 Sizes

$5.00

Frozen Treat Holder , Icy Pop Favor , Marine Vinyl Ice Pop Holder , Treat Holder , Party Favor , Sold Individually

$5.00

Baby Bib , Personalized Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Llama Bib , Name Written in Desert Font , Personalized Llama Baby Bib

$12.00

Embroidered Cotton Quilted Mug Rug , I Love Coffee Set , Love is Brewing , Love You a Latte , Emotional Support Cup , Pour Some Sugar

$8.00

Ornament , Embroidered Felt Penguin , Penguin Christmas Ornament, Felt Christmas Ornament , Felt Penguin Decoration

$7.50

Embroidered Fleece/Felt Doll Cast & Crutch , Play Cast , Felt Crutch , Patient Costume , Christmas Doll Outfit, Pretend Play , Fits Elves

$7.50

Treat Holder , Felt Valentine , Felt Valentine Treat or Note Holder , Party Favor , Felt Envelope with Pocket , Sold Individually or as Set

$5.00

Vinyl and Felt Valentine's Day Set , Dress Up , Pretend Play , Valentine Play , Pretend Cupid , Plush Heart , Sold Individually or as a Set

$5.00

Felt Doll Christmas Kiss Booth , Holiday Elf Booth , Christmas Doll Kiss Booth Play Set , Elf Prop , Fits Christmas Elves

$17.50

Play Food , Felt Food , Cake Pops Play Set , Sprinkles , Frosted , Chocolate Swirl , Pretend Cake Pop , Felt Cake , Pretend Play

$4.00

Felt Doll Fishing Boat Set , Fishing Costume , Boat , Oars , Rod , Fish , Tote , Visor , Pretend Play Set , Fits Elves , Elf Fishing Set

$25.00

Felt Christmas Elf Sign , Elf Kisses , Elf Note , Pretend Play , Christmas Elf Pretend Play , Felt Christmas Elf Note

$5.00

Felt Christmas Elf Sign , Elf on Strike , Room Clean Up Sign , Pretend Play , Christmas Elf Pretend Play , Elf On Strike Clean Your Room

$5.00

Felt Doll Car , Pretend Felt Car , Christmas Doll Play Set , Fits Elves , Pretend Play Car for Christmas Dolls

$25.00

Felt Doll Pilgrim Costume , Pilgrim Hat , Felt Pilgrim Hat , Christmas Doll Dress Up , Pretend Play , Thanksgiving Play , Fits Elves

$4.00

Embroidered Fleece Doll Sweater , Thanksgiving Sweater , Christmas Doll Sweater, Pretend Play , Fits Elves , I'm Here For The Leftovers

$7.50

Felt Doll Christmas Door , Holiday Elf Door , Christmas Doll Door Play Set , Fits Christmas Elves

$20.00

Play Food , Felt Food , Kitchen Pantry Staples Set , Flour , Sugars , Choc Chip , Baking Soda , Rice, Pasta , Shredded Cheese , Pretend Play

$5.00

12 people have this in their cart

Embroidered Vinyl Dance Door Sign , Live Love Dance , Ballet Sign , Vinyl Door Hanger , Love Dance , Dancer Gift

$25.00

Play Food , Felt Food , Lunch Play Set , Peanut Butter Jelly Sandwich , Peanut Butter , Jelly , Banana , Marshmallow , Build Your Own PB&J

$1.50

7 people have this in their cart

Play Food , Felt Food , Pretend Pot Roast Dinner Play Set , Roast , Red Potatoes , Carrots , Onion , Dutch Oven , Sold in Pieces or as a Set

$4.00

Play Food , Felt Food , Lobster and Shrimp Play Set , Lobster , Shrimp , Potato , Broccoli , Lemon , Butter , Sold in Pieces or as a Set

$3.00

Firefly Feltie , Firefly Feltie in Felt or Marine Glitter Vinyl , Feltie Pretend Play Set , Lightning Bug Feltie , Lightning Bug Play

$2.00

Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Personalized Bib , Embroidered Bib , Name in Celeste Font , Birthday Cupcake , Baby Shower Gift , Birthday Gift

$12.00

Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Personalized Bib , Embroidered Bib , Name in Elisa Font , Swirls and Flower Frame , Baby Shower Gift

$12.00

Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Personalized Bib , Embroidered Bib , Script Name in Madeline Font , Bow and Pennant Frame , Baby Shower Gift

$12.00

Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Personalized Bib , Embroidered Bib , Script Name in Noel Font , Holiday Bib , Holiday Lights Frame , Christmas Trees

$12.00

Embroidered Felt Wedding Countdown , Chalkboard Sign , Countdown to Wedding , Shower Gift, Wedding Shower , Gift for Bride to Be

$10.00

Key Fob , Key Chain , Embroidered Vinyl Golf Tee Holder , Unique Gift , Golf Tee Key Fob , Father's Day Gift , Optional Personalization

$7.00

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Contact shop owner

Jennifer

Reviews

Average item review

(4200)

See reviews that mention:

Jennifer on Apr 17, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful and well made tooth pillow for the tooth fairy! My son loved it

Plush Stuffed Tooth Pillow , Tooth Pillow Pocket , Tooth Fairy Pillow , Optional Personalization

Plush Stuffed Tooth Pillow , Tooth Pillow Pocket , Tooth Fairy Pillow , Optional Personalization
Jennifer on Apr 9, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Did a custom order and she did it exactly like I requested. Would highly recommend.

Play Food , Felt Food , Pet Treats Play Set , Cat Treats , Dog Food , Bones , Pretend Play Collar and Tags , Sold Individually or as a Set

Play Food , Felt Food , Pet Treats Play Set , Cat Treats , Dog Food , Bones , Pretend Play Collar and Tags , Sold Individually or as a Set
mary quin on Apr 8, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

i love this tooth pillow for my son. it’s almost perfect. the color is bright and my son lives it. only complaint is that the pocket for the teeth has some small parts (the roots) and when i tried to remove my son’s first tooth, it kind of got stuck in the end of one of those. i had to use tweezers to get them out. i wish the pocket didn’t continue down the root part. plan to buy another one when my 2nd kid is older!

Plush Stuffed Tooth Pillow , Tooth Pillow Pocket , Tooth Fairy Pillow , Optional Personalization

Plush Stuffed Tooth Pillow , Tooth Pillow Pocket , Tooth Fairy Pillow , Optional Personalization
Melanie on Mar 23, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

My grandchildren play veterinarian often and will enjoy having these as a part of the set.

Play Food , Felt Food , Pet Treats Play Set , Cat Treats , Dog Food , Bones , Pretend Play Collar and Tags , Sold Individually or as a Set

Play Food , Felt Food , Pet Treats Play Set , Cat Treats , Dog Food , Bones , Pretend Play Collar and Tags , Sold Individually or as a Set
Diane on Apr 16, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful bibs. Well-made and they look better than the pictures.

Baby Bib, Baby Gift, Embroidered Baby Bib , Baby's 1st Football Season , Baby Football Bib , Baby's First Year

Baby Bib, Baby Gift, Embroidered Baby Bib , Baby's 1st Football Season , Baby Football Bib , Baby's First Year
nlenfert on Apr 10, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Arrived in a timely manner and turned out great!

Plush Tooth Fairy Pillow , Tooth Pocket , Tooth Fairy Door Hanger, Plush Stuffed Tooth Pocket , For Boy or Girl

Plush Tooth Fairy Pillow , Tooth Pocket , Tooth Fairy Door Hanger, Plush Stuffed Tooth Pocket , For Boy or Girl
Gayle on Apr 9, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

These are so cute for baby. I love the designs and how vibrant they are.

Handmade Baby Bib Set , Baby's First Handmade Bib Set , Baby's First Year , 11 Holiday Bibs

Handmade Baby Bib Set , Baby's First Handmade Bib Set , Baby's First Year , 11 Holiday Bibs
R. on Apr 7, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

Adorable chocolate colored stuffed bunnies. I ordered the small size. Good quality, met my expectations.

Plush Stuffed Chocolate Easter Bunny , Available in 3 Sizes , Milk or White Chocolate

Plush Stuffed Chocolate Easter Bunny , Available in 3 Sizes , Milk or White Chocolate
emsin22 on Apr 4, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

The pillow is of great quality and it shipped quickly!

Plush Stuffed Tooth Pillow , Tooth Pillow Pocket , Tooth Fairy Pillow , Optional Personalization

Plush Stuffed Tooth Pillow , Tooth Pillow Pocket , Tooth Fairy Pillow , Optional Personalization
Mara on Apr 3, 2024

5 out of 5 stars

This was perfect. It’s well made, cute, and exactly what I was expecting.

Plush Stuffed Tooth Pillow , Tooth Pillow Pocket , Tooth Fairy Pillow , Optional Personalization

Plush Stuffed Tooth Pillow , Tooth Pillow Pocket , Tooth Fairy Pillow , Optional Personalization

About ThatsSewPersonal

Sales 25,511

On Etsy since 2013

Personalizing Has Never Been Sew Easy

I started sewing in junior high with my first home economics class. I made my grandma a butterfly pillow with felt embroidery. After she passed away well into my adult years, my aunt gave that pillow back to me! It meant so much to my grandma, and shows me just how much handmade gifts mean to others. In my second home ec class, I made a set of stuffed animals - a momma pig and her 3 babies. My kids play with these now - and they're over 20 years old!

My parents bought me my first sewing machine from the Mini Merchant. I wish I still had it today, but I put it to good use making handmade gifts for my friends and family.

My love of sewing led into many years of cross-stitch, yarn work, and other crafts. I rediscovered my love for my machine though after the birth of my oldest daughter. Now I love to make things for both of my daughters, and love the challenge of finding things to construct for my two sons. I even help teach "home economics" to a group of homeschooling kids, hoping to spark a love of creating in their young hearts.

Shop members

Jennifer Neely

Owner, Seamstress

I'm a wife and homeschooling mom to 4 of my biggest inspirations! Sewing and creating are my passions. I especially love to personalize gifts to make them extra special.

Shop policies

Last updated on February 16, 2023

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

ThatsSewPersonal

Fun and Unique Personalized Gifts!

Featured items

Items

All Items

Baby Bib, Baby Gift, Embroidered Baby Bib , Baby's 1st Baseball Season , Baby Baseball Bib , My 1st Baseball Season , Baby's First Year

Fun Plush Stuffed Heart , Smiling Heart Plush , Personalized Plush Heart , Valentine Gift , Valentine Heart , Available in 4 Sizes

Embroidered Bunny Bracelet , Vinyl Bracelet , 7" Snap Bracelet , Child's Bracelet , Fun Gift , Easter Basket Gift , Easter Bunny Sunglasses

Embroidered Felt Easter Basket , Personalized Easter Basket , Personalized Felt Easter Treat Basket , Personalized Gift

Key Fob , Key Chain , Bag Tag , Embroidered Vinyl Senior 2024 Fob , Key Fob with Ring , Senior Gift

Ornament , Embroidered Vinyl School Crayon Ornament , Photo Frame Ornament, Vinyl Christmas Ornament , Christmas Decoration

Embroidered Cotton Quilted Mug Rug , Bunny & Lamb Set , Bunny Coaster , Lamb Coaster , Spring Easter Mug Rug , Sold Individually or as a Set

Plush Stuffed Heart Shaped Bunny , Personalized Plush Bunny Heart , Easter Gift , Bunny Heart , Available in 4 Sizes

Frozen Treat Holder , Icy Pop Favor , Marine Vinyl Ice Pop Holder , Treat Holder , Party Favor , Sold Individually

Baby Bib , Personalized Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Llama Bib , Name Written in Desert Font , Personalized Llama Baby Bib

Embroidered Cotton Quilted Mug Rug , I Love Coffee Set , Love is Brewing , Love You a Latte , Emotional Support Cup , Pour Some Sugar

Ornament , Embroidered Felt Penguin , Penguin Christmas Ornament, Felt Christmas Ornament , Felt Penguin Decoration

Embroidered Fleece/Felt Doll Cast & Crutch , Play Cast , Felt Crutch , Patient Costume , Christmas Doll Outfit, Pretend Play , Fits Elves

Treat Holder , Felt Valentine , Felt Valentine Treat or Note Holder , Party Favor , Felt Envelope with Pocket , Sold Individually or as Set

Vinyl and Felt Valentine's Day Set , Dress Up , Pretend Play , Valentine Play , Pretend Cupid , Plush Heart , Sold Individually or as a Set

Felt Doll Christmas Kiss Booth , Holiday Elf Booth , Christmas Doll Kiss Booth Play Set , Elf Prop , Fits Christmas Elves

Play Food , Felt Food , Cake Pops Play Set , Sprinkles , Frosted , Chocolate Swirl , Pretend Cake Pop , Felt Cake , Pretend Play

Felt Doll Fishing Boat Set , Fishing Costume , Boat , Oars , Rod , Fish , Tote , Visor , Pretend Play Set , Fits Elves , Elf Fishing Set

Felt Christmas Elf Sign , Elf Kisses , Elf Note , Pretend Play , Christmas Elf Pretend Play , Felt Christmas Elf Note

Felt Christmas Elf Sign , Elf on Strike , Room Clean Up Sign , Pretend Play , Christmas Elf Pretend Play , Elf On Strike Clean Your Room

Felt Doll Car , Pretend Felt Car , Christmas Doll Play Set , Fits Elves , Pretend Play Car for Christmas Dolls

Felt Doll Pilgrim Costume , Pilgrim Hat , Felt Pilgrim Hat , Christmas Doll Dress Up , Pretend Play , Thanksgiving Play , Fits Elves

Embroidered Fleece Doll Sweater , Thanksgiving Sweater , Christmas Doll Sweater, Pretend Play , Fits Elves , I'm Here For The Leftovers

Felt Doll Christmas Door , Holiday Elf Door , Christmas Doll Door Play Set , Fits Christmas Elves

Play Food , Felt Food , Kitchen Pantry Staples Set , Flour , Sugars , Choc Chip , Baking Soda , Rice, Pasta , Shredded Cheese , Pretend Play

Embroidered Vinyl Dance Door Sign , Live Love Dance , Ballet Sign , Vinyl Door Hanger , Love Dance , Dancer Gift

Play Food , Felt Food , Lunch Play Set , Peanut Butter Jelly Sandwich , Peanut Butter , Jelly , Banana , Marshmallow , Build Your Own PB&J

Play Food , Felt Food , Pretend Pot Roast Dinner Play Set , Roast , Red Potatoes , Carrots , Onion , Dutch Oven , Sold in Pieces or as a Set

Play Food , Felt Food , Lobster and Shrimp Play Set , Lobster , Shrimp , Potato , Broccoli , Lemon , Butter , Sold in Pieces or as a Set

Firefly Feltie , Firefly Feltie in Felt or Marine Glitter Vinyl , Feltie Pretend Play Set , Lightning Bug Feltie , Lightning Bug Play

Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Personalized Bib , Embroidered Bib , Name in Celeste Font , Birthday Cupcake , Baby Shower Gift , Birthday Gift

Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Personalized Bib , Embroidered Bib , Name in Elisa Font , Swirls and Flower Frame , Baby Shower Gift

Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Personalized Bib , Embroidered Bib , Script Name in Madeline Font , Bow and Pennant Frame , Baby Shower Gift

Baby Bib , Baby Gift , Personalized Bib , Embroidered Bib , Script Name in Noel Font , Holiday Bib , Holiday Lights Frame , Christmas Trees

Embroidered Felt Wedding Countdown , Chalkboard Sign , Countdown to Wedding , Shower Gift, Wedding Shower , Gift for Bride to Be

Key Fob , Key Chain , Embroidered Vinyl Golf Tee Holder , Unique Gift , Golf Tee Key Fob , Father's Day Gift , Optional Personalization

Reviews

About ThatsSewPersonal

Shop members

Jennifer Neely

Shop policies

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations