



Announcement
The Idol's Eye now has a website at www.theidolseye.com! We still add all of our newest finds to our Etsy shop and fulfill all Etsy orders immediately. Also follow us on www.instagram.com/theidolseye/ for sneak previews of our latest finds and other jewelry adventures!
Items
Featured items
All Items
Reviews
-
brooke on Sep 27, 2023
5 out of 5 starsSuch a beautiful ring :) Shipped out fast and was exactly what I was looking for!
-
T on Sep 25, 2023
5 out of 5 starsExceeded my expectations- the ring was stunning in person and I can’t wait to wear it everyday. Such a unique ring that I know I’ll treasure forever. Great communication from the seller and answered all my questions. I was nervous about shipping something so valuable but it shipped quickly and easily with tracking & signature required. I’d definitely buy from this seller again.
-
Trevor on Jun 20, 2023
5 out of 5 starsTara was helpful through the whole process of the purchase and shipping. She sent a wonderful note along with the order that made the entire experience of purchasing the ring seem thoughtful. My partner loves it!
The Idol's responded on Sep 5, 2023
Thank you so much Trevor for your kind review, and I'm delighted that your partner loves the ring! Very best wishes to both of you for a joyful life ahead!
-
Jared on Sep 5, 2023
5 out of 5 starsAmazing communication and delivery of the ring. If you're on the hunt for amazing vintage jewelry definitely checkout this shop.
The Idol's responded on Sep 5, 2023
Thank you so much Jared for recommending us! I'm so glad I could help you find that special ring!
-
Danuta on Jun 14, 2023
5 out of 5 starsA dream of a ring, more soulful and beautiful than hoped for, totally trustworthy seller, perfect easy transaction, so blessed and grateful, a true 5 star seller! A thousand ways to say thank you!
The Idol's responded on Sep 5, 2023
Thank you so much Danuta for your kind review, and we're so glad we were able to connect you with this very special ring! We hope to have the pleasure of crossing paths again!
-
dannyjack99 on May 18, 2023
5 out of 5 starsA beautiful item and great seller. Arrived well packed and very quickly.
-
Allison on May 13, 2023
5 out of 5 starsThis ring is so pretty! Beautiful quality of workmanship, and the description was perfect. I love it even more in person!
-
Andrew on Apr 26, 2023
5 out of 5 starsVery happy with my purchase! The ring is beautiful and was exactly as described in the listing. I can't recommend The Idol's Eye highly enough to those looking for lovely antique engagement rings.
-
Emily on Apr 2, 2023
5 out of 5 starsAbsolutely stunning ring dated exactly 200 years before I was born. Very high quality item, perfectly match the description and the seller was very helpful giving me more information! The ring exceeded my expectations and it boils not hesitant to order from this seller again.
-
DINA on Mar 31, 2023
5 out of 5 starsVery pleased...great texts with seller..sent nice note too..going to My jeweler today to get it sized ! Much prettier in person..!
Updates


About TheIdolsEye
Fine Antique and Vintage Jewelry and Engagement Rings from the Storied Past
Shop members
-
Tara
Owner, Curator
Tara has an Art History degree from Columbia University and a degree in Fashion Design from Parsons School of Design. She is a scholar, a designer, and a skilled maker of things. Her love of antique jewelry is a natural culmination of her love for art history, fashion, and the design process from concept to execution. Over the years she's acquired an extensive knowledge of antique jewelry periods and values, gemstones and minerals, and historical jewelry-making techniques, and she's thrilled to share her knowledge and passions with others through her shop.
Shop policies
Shipping
Customs and import taxes
Payment options
Returns & exchanges
Cancellations
Cancellations: accepted
Request a cancellation: before item has shipped
More information
Frequently asked questions
Do you offer layaway plans?
We're happy to create a custom layaway plan for you on certain items. Please convo us for details.
Do you accept returns?
Yes, we accept returns. We want you to be completely happy with your item. If you're not, we'll gladly accept a return, provided the item is in undamaged and unaltered condition (see next FAQ regarding alterations). To return an item, please contact us within 7 days of receipt to receive instructions for your return. We ask that we receive the item back within 14 days of your receipt of the item. Buyer is responsible for paying return shipping cost, including insurance for the full value of the item in case of loss or damage in transit. Upon receipt of the item in undamaged and unaltered condition, we will issue a refund in the original form of payment for the full amount. We cannot provide a refund on items lost during return transit.
Can I return an item that has been altered?
Please note that items must be returned to us in "as received" condition in order to be eligible for refund. We do not accept returns on items that have been polished, resized, or altered in any way, so please be sure your item is "the one" before making any alterations.
Do you offer resizing?
We prefer not to offer resizing on online orders, as we cannot measure your ring size in person for the best accuracy. However, if you urgently need resizing for your purchase, please convo us for resizing pricing. Please note that items that have been resized are considered custom orders, and are no longer eligible for return, so please be sure your item is "the one" before resizing.
Gift wrapping and packaging
All of our items ship in a velvet-lined jewelry box, packaged inside an outer box for added protection.
**Please note that the "This order includes a gift" option at checkout indicates that you do not want an invoice showing the price to be inlcuded in your package. It is not an option for gift wrapping. As none of our items ship with an invoice out of discretion, please help us avoid confusion by not checking this box.
Gift wrapping can be arranged for an additional fee. If you would like gift wrapping for your order, please convo me for details.
Gift notes are offered free of charge. If you would like to add a gift note, please include the text of the message in the "note to seller" area.