Fine Antique and Vintage Engagement Rings and Treasures

Manhattan, New York
| 290 Sales | 5 out of 5 stars 5 out of 5 stars

TheIdolsEye is a Star Seller!

Smooth shipping

Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

Average review rating is 4.8 or higher


Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language


All Items

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

The Idol's Eye

Contact shop owner

The Idol's Eye


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:

About TheIdolsEye

Sales 290
On Etsy since 2015

Fine Antique and Vintage Jewelry and Engagement Rings from the Storied Past

Historically, the deity in sculpted form was the focus of humans’ worship of the divine. No wonder then, that ancient cultures everywhere adorned their idols with the most precious of gems, for gemstones have always exerted a sort of mystical pull in the human psyche. And it is also no accident that jewelry has long cherished the principle of anonymous creation, with countless unknown jewelers toiling to best display the wonders of nature for the pleasure of gods and royalty.

We hope to reconnect you with the history of mankind's fascination with gemstones, as well as with past ideals of beauty and the craftsmanship that developed to express them. All of our pieces are chosen with an understanding of history and of good design and craftsmanship, and a firm belief that good design of any era is just as relevant today as it was in its own day. Its associations have only expanded and deepened. We also choose our pieces with a belief that the wear and imperfections of time are all part of the deeper meanings of antique and vintage pieces. Each slightly mismatched stone or artfully worn enamel tells a story and adds a layer of uniqueness that simply cannot be found in a new piece of jewelry. In these pieces, the past comes to life.

But the kind of pieces we love the most are the ones whose creators' awe at the natural beauty of gemstones clearly shines through even centuries later to mirror our own, the kind of pieces whose creators have tried to pay homage to natural beauty rather than make it conform to an unnatural ideal. To us these pieces are rare and timeless. They go straight to the core of our never-ending fascination with gemstones' mystical power. They tell us a story not of a brief moment in history, but of the eternal.

We hope that our shop can become a destination for lovers of stories from the past, as well as lovers of that which transcends time and place. We carefully select all of our pieces to try to bring you both in good measure, and we try to share a little bit of our knowledge and passion in every item description. Our knowledge of design history and period jewelry-making techniques ensures authenticity, as does our testing of all metals and gemstones. So all you have to do is choose the pieces that speak to you, and wear them or gift them with love!

The Idol’s Eye, New York City

*All shop images are copyrighted.

Shop members

  • Tara

    Owner, Curator

    Tara has an Art History degree from Columbia University and a degree in Fashion Design from Parsons School of Design. She is a scholar, a designer, and a skilled maker of things. Her love of antique jewelry is a natural culmination of her love for art history, fashion, and the design process from concept to execution. Over the years she's acquired an extensive knowledge of antique jewelry periods and values, gemstones and minerals, and historical jewelry-making techniques, and she's thrilled to share her knowledge and passions with others through her shop.

Shop policies

Last updated on Nov 25, 2022


See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment options

Secure options
Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.


Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: before item has shipped

More information

Last updated on Nov 26, 2022

Frequently asked questions

Custom and personalized orders

We're happy to create a custom layaway plan for you on certain items. Please convo us for details.

Sizing details

We prefer not to offer resizing, as we cannot size you in person. However, if you urgently need resizing for your purchase, please convo us for resizing pricing. Please note that items that have been resized, either by your local jeweler, or by us, are no longer eligible for return, so please be sure your item is "the one" before resizing.

Gift wrapping and packaging

All of our items ship in a velvet-lined jewelry box, packaged inside an outer box for added protection.

**Please note that the "This order includes a gift" option at checkout indicates that you do not want an invoice showing the price to be inlcuded in your package. It is not an option for gift wrapping. As none of our items ship with an invoice out of discretion, please help us avoid confusion by not checking this box.

Gift wrapping is offered for an additional fee. If you would like gift wrapping for your order, please convo me for details.

Gift notes are offered free of charge. If you would like to add a gift note, please include the text of the message in the "note to seller" area.