Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript.

TheToastTale

United States

203
 Sales

5 months
on Etsy

203
 sales

5 months
on Etsy

Following Follow

203
 Sales

5 months
on Etsy

203
 sales

5 months
on Etsy

Contact shop owner

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Featured items

Personalized Handwritten Love Note Napkin, Custom Wedding Cocktail Napkins, Couple Text Napkins, Gift for Her, Love Note Gift

Personalized Handwritten Love Note Napkin, Custom Wedding Cocktail Napkins, Couple Text Napkins, Gift for Her, Love Note Gift

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Dog Wedding Napkins, Watercolor Dog & Cat Striped Cocktail Napkins, Beverage Paper

Personalized Dog Wedding Napkins, Watercolor Dog & Cat Striped Cocktail Napkins, Beverage Paper

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Wedding Frosted Plastic Cups, Bridal Shower Favors, 12/16oz Cups

Personalized Wedding Frosted Plastic Cups, Bridal Shower Favors, 12/16oz Cups

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Wedding Coasters, Bar Paper Coasters, Wedding, Bridal Shower Favors, Thank You Favors

Personalized Wedding Coasters, Bar Paper Coasters, Wedding, Bridal Shower Favors, Thank You Favors

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

All items

Make up the difference

Make up the difference

Sale Price AU$27.29

Original Price AU$38.98 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Wedding Coasters, Bar Paper Coasters, Wedding, Bridal Shower Favors, Thank You Favors

Personalized Wedding Coasters, Bar Paper Coasters, Wedding, Bridal Shower Favors, Thank You Favors

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Handwritten Love Note Napkin, Custom Wedding Cocktail Napkins, Couple Text Napkins, Gift for Her, Love Note Gift

Personalized Handwritten Love Note Napkin, Custom Wedding Cocktail Napkins, Couple Text Napkins, Gift for Her, Love Note Gift

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Fun Fact Cocktail Napkins, Custom Wedding Engagement Party Napkins, Printed Couple Funny Events Napkins

Personalized Fun Fact Cocktail Napkins, Custom Wedding Engagement Party Napkins, Printed Couple Funny Events Napkins

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Pet Wedding Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Dog Cat Portrait Napkins

Personalized Pet Wedding Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Dog Cat Portrait Napkins

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Wedding Coasters, Bar Paper Coasters, Wedding, Bridal Shower Favors, Thank You Favors

Personalized Wedding Coasters, Bar Paper Coasters, Wedding, Bridal Shower Favors, Thank You Favors

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Striped Cocktail Napkins, Personalized Wedding Party Decor, Wedding Reception, Bridal Shower Engagement Gift

Custom Striped Cocktail Napkins, Personalized Wedding Party Decor, Wedding Reception, Bridal Shower Engagement Gift

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Pet Frosted Plastic Cups, Dog Wedding Favors, 12/16oz Cups

Personalized Pet Frosted Plastic Cups, Dog Wedding Favors, 12/16oz Cups

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Wedding Frosted Plastic Cups, Bridal Shower Favors, 12/16oz Cups

Personalized Wedding Frosted Plastic Cups, Bridal Shower Favors, 12/16oz Cups

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Frosted Wedding Cups, Custom Champagne Tower, Rehearsal Dinner, Wedding Table Decor

Personalized Frosted Wedding Cups, Custom Champagne Tower, Rehearsal Dinner, Wedding Table Decor

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Fast Shipping

Sale Price AU$42.47

Original Price AU$60.67 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Fun Facts Napkin, Custom Wedding Cocktail, Engagement Party Napkins, Couple Trivia, Gift for Her

Personalized Fun Facts Napkin, Custom Wedding Cocktail, Engagement Party Napkins, Couple Trivia, Gift for Her

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Frosted Wedding Cup, Custom Party Favor, 12oz / 16oz Cup

Personalized Frosted Wedding Cup, Custom Party Favor, 12oz / 16oz Cup

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Stripes Birthday Napkins, Photo Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party Decor, Bridal Shower Favors, Engagement Party

Custom Stripes Birthday Napkins, Photo Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party Decor, Bridal Shower Favors, Engagement Party

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Kids Portrait Frosted Plastic Cup, Birthday Gift for Boy Girl, Party Favor, 12oz / 16oz Cup

Personalized Kids Portrait Frosted Plastic Cup, Birthday Gift for Boy Girl, Party Favor, 12oz / 16oz Cup

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Pet Wedding Coasters, Cat Dog Portrait Coasters, Custom Bridal Shower Gift

Personalized Pet Wedding Coasters, Cat Dog Portrait Coasters, Custom Bridal Shower Gift

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Pet Wedding Coasters, Bridal Shower Bar Favors, Cat Dog Watercolor Coasters

Personalized Pet Wedding Coasters, Bridal Shower Bar Favors, Cat Dog Watercolor Coasters

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Wedding Napkins, Anniversary Napkins, Ribbon Coupe Glasses Cocktail Napkins, Cocktail Napkins, Drink Napkins

Custom Wedding Napkins, Anniversary Napkins, Ribbon Coupe Glasses Cocktail Napkins, Cocktail Napkins, Drink Napkins

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Pet Wedding Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Custom Cat Dog Portrait

Personalized Pet Wedding Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Custom Cat Dog Portrait

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins, Cheers Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins, Cheers Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Graduation Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Class of 2026 Party Favors

Personalized Graduation Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Class of 2026 Party Favors

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins with Cup, Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins with Cup, Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Striped Cocktail Wedding Napkins, Personalized Party Decor, Wedding Reception, Bridal Shower Engagement Gift

Custom Striped Cocktail Wedding Napkins, Personalized Party Decor, Wedding Reception, Bridal Shower Engagement Gift

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Birthday Napkins, Personalized Party Decor, 30th Birthday Napkins

Custom Birthday Napkins, Personalized Party Decor, 30th Birthday Napkins

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Fun Fact Cocktail Napkins, Custom Wedding Engagement Party Napkins

Personalized Fun Fact Cocktail Napkins, Custom Wedding Engagement Party Napkins

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Handwritten Love Note Napkins, Wedding Anniversary Cocktail Napkins

Personalized Handwritten Love Note Napkins, Wedding Anniversary Cocktail Napkins

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Cat Dog Portrait Napkins, Cheers Cocktail Napkins, Wedding Engagement Party Favor

Personalized Cat Dog Portrait Napkins, Cheers Cocktail Napkins, Wedding Engagement Party Favor

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Dog Wedding Frosted Cups, Pet Portrait Party Favors (12/16 oz)

Personalized Dog Wedding Frosted Cups, Pet Portrait Party Favors (12/16 oz)

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Pet Frosted Plastic Cups, Engagement, Rehearsal, Wedding, Birthday Favors, 12/16 oz Cups

Personalized Pet Frosted Plastic Cups, Engagement, Rehearsal, Wedding, Birthday Favors, 12/16 oz Cups

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Dog Wedding Napkins, Watercolor Pet Cocktail Napkins, Striped Beverage Paper

Personalized Dog Wedding Napkins, Watercolor Pet Cocktail Napkins, Striped Beverage Paper

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Dog Wedding Napkins, Watercolor Dog & Cat Striped Cocktail Napkins, Beverage Paper

Personalized Dog Wedding Napkins, Watercolor Dog & Cat Striped Cocktail Napkins, Beverage Paper

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Wedding Cocktail Napkins, Monogram Napkins, Rehearsal Dinner, Bridal Shower Engagement Gift

Custom Wedding Cocktail Napkins, Monogram Napkins, Rehearsal Dinner, Bridal Shower Engagement Gift

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Striped Cocktail Wedding Napkins, Personalized Party Decor, Reception, Bridal Shower Engagement Gift

Custom Striped Cocktail Wedding Napkins, Personalized Party Decor, Reception, Bridal Shower Engagement Gift

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Personalized Graduation Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Class of 2026 Graduation Party Favors

Personalized Graduation Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Class of 2026 Graduation Party Favors

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Custom Striped Cocktail Wedding Napkins With Cup, Personalized Party Decor, Reception, Bridal Shower Engagement Favor

Custom Striped Cocktail Wedding Napkins With Cup, Personalized Party Decor, Reception, Bridal Shower Engagement Favor

Sale Price AU$7.01

Original Price AU$10.01 (30% off)

FREE delivery

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Heather Russell

Contact shop owner

Heather Russell

Reviews

5.0 (31)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Loading

L on 09 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Cannot recommend TheToastTale more! Extremely fast, creative, and executed my vision perfectly. Forever grateful.

Heather Russell responded on 09 Jun, 2026

Thank you!

Fast Shipping

Fast Shipping
Lisa on 08 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I ordered personalized cups with our pictures on them, and I couldn’t be happier! They arrived quickly and look absolutely terrific—the print quality is clear and vibrant, and the cups feel sturdy and well-made. Such a fun and special way to capture memories. Highly recommend!

Heather Russell responded on 08 Jun, 2026

Thank you!

Personalized Wedding Frosted Plastic Cups, Bridal Shower Favors, 12/16oz Cups

Personalized Wedding Frosted Plastic Cups, Bridal Shower Favors, 12/16oz Cups
Alyssa on 02 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Am very excited to use these for my wedding! Multiple proofs were sent in a very timely manner to make sure everything was correct. Made, shipped, and received quickly. Would highly recommend!

Heather Russell responded on 02 Jun, 2026

Thank you!

Personalized Fun Fact Cocktail Napkins, Custom Wedding Engagement Party Napkins, Printed Couple Funny Events Napkins

Personalized Fun Fact Cocktail Napkins, Custom Wedding Engagement Party Napkins, Printed Couple Funny Events Napkins
Hayley on 01 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

These are so much fun! What a unique way to start conversations at your next event. I plan to use these during our cocktail hour. The seller worked with me several times to modify and tweak things throughout the ordering process without hesitation. Great color choices. Shipped with care!

Heather Russell responded on 01 Jun, 2026

Thank you!

Personalized Fun Fact Cocktail Napkins, Custom Wedding Engagement Party Napkins, Printed Couple Funny Events Napkins

Personalized Fun Fact Cocktail Napkins, Custom Wedding Engagement Party Napkins, Printed Couple Funny Events Napkins
Danise on 24 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Absolutely wonderful napkins. Everyone thought they were beautiful even had to give the link to the shop to several people.! Easy transaction- would purchase again!

Heather Russell responded on 24 Jun, 2026

Thank you!

Custom Stripes Birthday Napkins, Photo Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party Decor, Bridal Shower Favors, Engagement Party

Custom Stripes Birthday Napkins, Photo Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party Decor, Bridal Shower Favors, Engagement Party
Abby on 24 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Turned out perfect! Great personal touch to our wedding cocktail napkins!

Heather Russell responded on 24 Jun, 2026

Thank you!

Personalized Handwritten Love Note Napkin, Custom Wedding Cocktail Napkins, Couple Text Napkins, Gift for Her, Love Note Gift

Personalized Handwritten Love Note Napkin, Custom Wedding Cocktail Napkins, Couple Text Napkins, Gift for Her, Love Note Gift
Alina on 12 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Item was just as described. Perfect!

Heather Russell responded on 12 Jun, 2026

Thank you!

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement
Nicole on 12 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Love! The love letter napkins were sooo good, was able to customize the color as well.

Heather Russell responded on 12 Jun, 2026

Thank you!!

Make up the difference

Make up the difference
Nicole on 12 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Soo good! Love our custom napkins, fast replies.. very well done. SO happy with Heather!

Heather Russell responded on 12 Jun, 2026

Thank you!

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement

Custom Striped Wedding Napkins with Text, Cocktail Napkins for Party, Reception, Bridal Shower, Engagement
Lydia on 09 Jun, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

These came out better than I could have imagined and customer service was excellent! Worked with me to get it just right and arrived on time!

Heather Russell responded on 09 Jun, 2026

Thank you!

Personalized Pet Wedding Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Custom Cat Dog Portrait

Personalized Pet Wedding Napkins, Striped Cocktail Napkins, Custom Cat Dog Portrait

About TheToastTale

Sales 203

On Etsy since 2026

Shop members

Heather Russell

Owner

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.