Chicago, Illinois

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

TwoGirlsGems is taking a short break


Note from shop owner We are taking a short break and will be back shortly.

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Dec 6, 2022

We are taking a short break and will be back shortly.


Contact shop owner



Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:

About TwoGirlsGems

Sales 1,134
On Etsy since 2011

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Every piece has a story

The quality and craftsmanship of antique pieces, along with their place in history, fuels our love for salvaging antique jewelry. In a world of mass produced and disposable products we believe we have something special, each piece is One of A Kind.

Shop members

  • Elizabeth McNeill

    Creator, Owner

    The quality & craftsmanship of vintage pieces, along with their place in history, fuels my love for salvaging antique jewelry. In a world of mass produced and disposable products I believe I have something special. Each piece is One of A Kind.

  • Isabel


    My daughter, my muse and my part time model.

Production partners

  • CAD Studio

    Chicago, IL

    Fabrication studio with CAD, master craftman

Shop policies

Last updated on May 9, 2022
Welcome to Two Girls Gems where you can find authentic antique jewelry. We hand select objects of the past and then restyle, reinvent or sometimes just polish them up. We strive to find unique quality pieces and turn them into new heirlooms for the next generation. Every piece is one of a kind.

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.


Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.


Payment is to be made through pay pal or direct credit card.


Two Girls Gems ships within 1 or 2 days of purchase. Purchases made over holidays or weekends may take extra time. Items are shipped by USPS first class mail, insured with tracking.

✈ Shipping in U.S.; First class mail, insured with tracking.

Outside of U.S. - ships First class mail, NOT INSURED, no gift box (unless requested, extra fees will incur) -
For international sales we STRONGLY suggest for you to purchase the additional *Registered Mail fee. This fee is featured as a separate listing. Registered mail is an additional shipping fee of $20.00. This service will not be added unless the buyer purchases this service. To add this service see "Shipping Upgrades". With Registered Mail the package travels under lock and key with signatures required for each postal person handling the package, 50,00 insurance included. It is only trackable by the postal system. A signiture will be required by the buyer as well. We have found this to be the least expensive, safest way.

International Buyers: Even though items are promptly shipped, delivery can take up to 6 weeks depending on the country. Buyer is responsible for all taxes, import fees , VATS and tariff fees that may be charged.

Additional policies and FAQs

All pieces in Two Girls Gems collection are comprised of reclaimed and vintage pieces and therefore may contain minor imperfections. If we see imperfections we try to point them out in our descriptions, so please read carefully, but also please look at each picture, zoom in and don't hesitate to ask a question.

Every piece that we make has an authentic antique component. New chains, ear wires, clasps, jump rings etc. are added when needed. We only use Sterling Silver, 14k gold fill or 14k gold depending on each piece. Most of the pieces in our collection are HANDMADE by US - so any adjustments are always welcomed, just ask. We are happy to also offer custom made pieces. If you have an heirloom that you would like restyled- just contact us and we will discuss your design. We have examples and references to share.

RESERVED ITEMS: We are happy to reserve/hold items for 48 hours. Please contact us.

We ask that you put down 1/3 of the asking price for layaway. Please contact us with the item that you're interested in and we'll create special listings for your layaway plan. Payments toward the full price must be made every 30 days and it is the buyer's responsibility to remember you have payments due. The final balance must be made within 6 months or less. PLEASE NOTE: If you are unresponsive to convos or emails pertaining to your balance payments due, you will forfeit your deposit and payments made, no exceptions, and the item will be returned back into the shop.

*Layaway items can be returned but with a 20% restocking fee. Item must be returned within 7 days after receipt.
*If an item is less than 70.00 we do not offer layaway plans.

More information

Last updated on May 10, 2022

Frequently asked questions


Yes we offer Layaway. 1/3 deposit down and payments made every month. Please see our policies for more details.