46 Sales


46 Sales On Etsy since 2011

5 out of 5 stars

Announcement   Look for Fresh BOGOs throughout! ~♦~ Live in the Ogden/Salt Lake City area? Enter "LOCALSHIP" at checkout for free pickup! ~♦~ For budget-friendly jewelry supplies visit!

Check out my awesome friend's PoshMark shop for all things fashion to go with your jewelry!

Last updated on Jul 27, 2016

Look for Fresh BOGOs throughout! ~♦~ Live in the Ogden/Salt Lake City area? Enter "LOCALSHIP" at checkout for free pickup! ~♦~ For budget-friendly jewelry supplies visit!

Check out my awesome friend's PoshMark shop for all things fashion to go with your jewelry!

Andrea McCrady

Contact shop owner

Andrea McCrady

Vintage Citrine Jewel Cocktail Statement Ring
Vintage Mustard Seed Ring
Electric Blue Faux Druzy Ring
View all 138 items


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
Stephanie Luther

Stephanie Luther on Jul 15, 2016

5 out of 5 stars

I really love the pastel yellow jade and copper together. These are elegant or casual and definitely beautiful earrings.

View all 22 reviews

Shop policies

Last updated on April 15, 2016
Welcome & Thank You for your interest in Two Of A Kind Jewelry & Supply.

Two Of A Kind is a mother-daughter team made up of myself, Andrea, and my daughter, Lilly. Together we share a passion for creating.

I, Andrea (the mom), work full time in my family's real estate office. I'm the "mother hen" of the office - I do the books (and a little of everything else) while my father and my brother run the town wheeling & dealing. I love to camp, and throughout most of the spring, summer, & fall, that's what we end up spending our weekends doing. I am inspired by nature, pop culture, music, & my cats. I specialize in gemstones, chain-work, beading, and vintage "upcycling".

Lilly (at time of writing) is a wonderfully brilliant & vivacious 14 year old 9th grader. She is a 4.0 student with a flair for fiction writing. Lilly likes to spend time with her friends, listen to music, and shop. She is inspired by her cats, friends, nature, and (of course) pop culture. Lilly enjoys working with Duck Tape, chain-work, and beading.

We use all the supplies we stock in our own jewelry & craft projects. I, Andrea, am especially proud of all our great items. I love to talk about the items we stock, how we use them, and what we think about them. Don't hesitate to ask questions, I will give you honest, accurate assessments of my products.

You found us here:

You can also find us here:

Accepted payment methods

  • Accepts Etsy gift cards
I accept Paypal or credit card through Etsy direct checkout.

If you don't have a PayPal account and would prefer this method, you can still pay by credit card securely through the PayPal site.

State sales tax will be applied for buyers in Utah.

Kindly remit your payment within 48 hours. If, for some reason, you decide against your purchase before paying, please let me know. If an order has gone unpaid for more than 48 hours, it will be cancelled.
If you live along the Wasatch Front & would like to arrange pick-up of your items, please message me. Use coupon code "LOCALSHIP" at checkout for local pick-up.

I ship twice per week - Tuesday & Friday.

Your order will ship to your Etsy shipping address. If you wish to have something shipped to a different address, please let me know in the notes to seller.

I do not refund shipping overages. The shipping charge covers not only the actual shipping, but the packaging, product labels, Etsy fees, and my time to create, pack, & send your order. Please consider this at time of purchase.


Orders within the US will be shipped via USPS First Class Mail with delivery confirmation. Tracking numbers will be emailed to you on the day of shipment. Orders typically arrive within 2-5 business days, but may take as long as 2 weeks.


International orders are shipped via USPS First Class Mail International, with limited tracking. Orders typically arrive within 2-8 weeks, dependent on destination and time spent in customs. If you would like to track your package, priority shipping can be purchased for an extra cost.

Customs forms will reflect the actual retail value of the items shipped. The buyer is responsible for any taxes and/or duty fees. Taxes and duty fees are non-refundable. Please contact your local customs office for more information about fees.
Refunds and Exchanges
I want you to be completely happy with your purchase. If you are unhappy for any reason, you may initiate a return within 7 days of receipt and receive a full refund of the purchase price less the original shipping costs. Return authorization via Etsy Convo is required (so I know to watch for your return). Delivery confirmation and postal insurance is strongly recommended for any items posted for return. Refunds will be made in the same method as the original purchase within 2 business days of receipt. All returns must be in original, unused condition unless there is a defect. Custom orders will be refunded 50% of the original purchase price.

Buyer is responsible for shipping fees both ways for returned or exchanged items unless otherwise negotiated and agreed upon in writing.

All orders are shipped through Etsy & include domestic US tracking. If you suspect your package has been lost in transit, please send me a Convo. I will do what I can to rectify the situation. Full refund (including shipping) or replacement of item(s) will be made in documented cases of loss or damage during shipment. This may require filing official paperwork with the USPS.

Please contact me before leaving neutral or negative feedback - there is a solution to every problem.
Additional policies and FAQs
Custom orders welcome!

Full Payment is required up-front for all custom orders. Most custom orders will be completed within 5-7 days unless a different time frame is worked out in advance.

Custom order returns:
Returns on custom orders will be considered on a case-by-case basis, and will only be refunded at 50% of the original price. All other return/refund requirements apply.

If you have any questions or concerns about any of these policies, please convo me or email ammccrady [at]

All items come from a smoke-free, pet-friendly home.