Craft Goods, Baked Goods, and Bath Goods

Buyers are raving!

This shop got multiple 5-star reviews in the past 7 days.



All Items

Hana Khalyleh

Contact shop owner

Hana Khalyleh


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
Quality 117 Shipping 73 Customer service 34

About WhatWouldMothmanDo

Sales 4,764
On Etsy since 2019

We're here, we're queer, and we love Mothman!

Hello! Welcome to our shop! We are selling cookies, pins, stickers and bath products themed around well known cryptids and the supernatural as a way to raise funds for a trip for us and all our friends to visit the Mothman Festival in Point Pleasant, WV! (And also to meet Mothman. We love Mothman.) This was originally going to happen in September of 2020, but, well, you know - so the trip will be in 2021 instead!

We hope you enjoy our products. All of us, including the friends we have inspiring us, have a passion for the supernatural and paranormal.

Please contact us on our Instagram or Tumblr if you have any concerns or questions!
IG: WhatWouldMothmanDo
Tumblr: whatwouldmothmando.tumblr.com

And if you would like to donate to our trip funds directly, here is our PayPal!
PP: https://www.paypal.com/pools/c/8rifKqLRpx

Shop members

  • Hana

    Owner, Maker, Artist, Shipper

    Created the store, makes and ships the bath bombs, cookies, bumper stickers, pins, charms and keychains! Also makes art for some products, like stickers and pins.

  • Lily

    Maker, Shipper

    Makes and ships out the bookmarks!

  • Fex, Rev, Nour, Lee, Krav


    This is our team of Artists! We have a big range of queer artists working on this store!

Production partners

  • PureButton

    Medina, OH

    This company is a button-printer manufacturer

  • Redbubble

    Melbourne, VIC

    Redbubble is a global online marketplace for print-on-demand products based on user-submitted artwork.

  • SignsOnTheCheap

    Austin, TX

    We use SignsOnTheCheap to get signs printed and sent our way.

Shop policies