Fatty's Soap Co.

Appleton, Wisconsin
| 24,452 Sales | 5 out of 5 stars 5 out of 5 stars

FattysSoapCo is a Star Seller!

Smooth shipping

Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

Average review rating is 4.8 or higher

Announcement    <<< Shop My Sections for Easy Navigation

Thanks for stopping by! I'm now offering 7.5 ml mini versions of my polish in most shades. These are made to order, and may take an extra day or two.


Last updated on Sep 5, 2022

<<< Shop My Sections for Easy Navigation

Thanks for stopping by! I'm now offering 7.5 ml mini versions of my polish in most shades. These are made to order, and may take an extra day or two.


Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language


All Items

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Heather Rai

Contact shop owner

Heather Rai


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:

About FattysSoapCo

Sales 24,452
On Etsy since 2008

Welcome to Fatty's Soap Co!


Thanks for stopping by. I hope you enjoy my shop and please feel free to message me regarding anything you'd like to see.

All the best,

Shop members

  • Heather

    Owner, Maker, Designer, Curator, Photographer

    Hello and welcome to Fatty's Soap Co! I enjoy beading, sewing, cooking, soap making, candle making, perfumery, DIY projects and so much more! Hope you enjoy browsing and thanks for stopping! Heather

Shop policies

Last updated on April 29, 2022
Welcome to Fatty's Soap Co.

I create handmade soap, candles, butters, balms and other homemade crafted sensations.

I use organic, sustainable palm oil. When available, I also use as many organic oils as possible. My butters are unrefined, just the way nature intended. My tallow is hand rendered (by me) from non-gmo, grass fed cows.

A well draining soap dish will preserve the life of your handmade soap. Store your handmade soaps in a cool dry place letting them breathe. I cut mine in quarters to make them last longer, this way I can use a different soap everyday.

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.


Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 12 hours of purchase



All shipping overages over 1.00 will be refunded as soon as I see them.

I am NOT responsible for lost, or stolen packages. I provide tracking through USPS and delivery confirmation. If you feel that your package may be stolen, or lost. Please provide a safe, alternate address where it can be shipped to. Or, I can have it shipped to your local post office with a signature confirmation, for an additional charge.

Please double check your shipping address. I am not responsible for packages shipped to wrong addresses. Refunds will not be given for packages addressed wrong or lost through the USPS. Packages addressed wrongly, then returned to me, will be happily shipped out again. I will invoice you for the postage price. Please contact me if you have any questions.

Packages sent via Priority Mail have delivery confirmation and are automatically insured through the USPS themselves. Should you have any problems with non-delivery. You can open a dispute through the www.USPS.com with your tracking number. I will gladly add insurance or signature confirmation to any package before shipment - just ask. Price will depend on the contents of your order and weight of your package.

America: I try to ship within 1-3 business days, Monday - Friday via USPS first class/priority mail. Orders placed on Fridays will be shipped the following week. Arrival time is dependent on the USPS postal schedule. I do not ship overnight. Shipping is as close to the actual charge as possible. Anything over $1.00 shipment cost will be happily refunded to you. Please contact me if I forget and I'll take care of it right away - sometimes I do forget. You will receive a shipping notification with tracking information when your package leaves.

International customers, yes of course, I'll ship to you! It's hard to estimate a true shipping cost. So it's best to work together and I can quote you an exact ship price. Message me. I try to ship within 3 business days of orders. Please be aware, once my products leave the US I have no control over how fast your package will arrive or if it will be held up by customs. Packages over 2 pounds will be broken up in lesser increments. No refunds will be given for lost international packages. I would love your business, but please consider these things before placing an order, or feel free to message me for more details.

I try to re-use/recycle materials for packing whenever possible and still ship an elegant product. My philosophy is that the joy is in the product, not the packaging.

Additional policies and FAQs

● SOAP ●
My soap "may" contain:
Oils of: Olive, Coconut, Palm or Tallow, Apricot, Argan, Avocado, Sesame, Sweet Almond, and Sunflower, Jojoba, Macadamia Nut, Hemp Seed
Butters of: Unrefined Shea, Unrefined Cocoa and Mango Seed
Raw WI Beeswax and Honey
Aloe Vera
Clay Mica Oxides and Botanicals (color)
Essential Oils or Fragrance Oils
Tussah Silk
Sodium Lactate
Sodium Hydroxide

Please see individual listings to verify. All soap comes packaged with full ingredient listing as well, suitable for gift giving.

I am currently not accepting wholesale orders.

Maybe you are wondering if essential oils are right for you. Along with skin loving goodness my soap may also contain therapeutic grade essential oils. Although they are all natural and used in low dilutions they are not recommended for pregnant women, children, or anyone with existing medical conditions. Please use your best, wise judgment and research essential oils, their properties, effects, benefits and cautions when using them. There's a great wealth of information online and it's just a click away. Enjoy!