Personalized Tooth Fairy Pillows & Tooth Fairy Gifts

Temecula, California · 2049 Sales


Personalized Tooth Fairy Pillows & Tooth Fairy Gifts

Temecula, California 2049 Sales On Etsy since 2010

5 out of 5 stars

ToothFairyPillowShop is taking a short break

Tooth Fairy Pillow Shop

Contact shop owner

Tooth Fairy Pillow Shop


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
Magdalena Budasz

Magdalena Budasz on Apr 18, 2017

1 out of 5 stars

The item literally fell apart in my hands. The cork is too fragile and it's impossible to get it out or put it back on as it crumbles. Cute idea but huge disappointment.

Tooth Fairy Pillow Shop

Tooth Fairy Pillow Shop responded on Apr 23, 2017

After reaching out to this customer, I learned that she hadn't read the item description stating "Each vial is sealed..." and was a finished necklace. I discovered that she was looking for a necklace she could put a lost tooth in, so I happily shipped her a second necklace with an unsealed cork. She messaged me that she was very pleased with this gesture and would be happy to remove the negative feedback, saying it was entirely due to her misunderstanding. Because the feedback has not been removed, I wanted to share how this issue was resolved. I will always work with my customers to resolve any issues that may arise, as customer satisfaction truly is my #1 goal! Thanks so much for your business, Magdalena -I truly hope you are happy with the second necklace and that it is exactly what you were hoping for!

View all 346 reviews


I don't know about your family, but mine is crazy about FOOTBALL!! football This little guy is perfect for your little quarterback heart_eyes
Enjoy FREE SHIPPING on all of our Tooth Fairy Pillows in celebration of our 6 years on Etsy! two_hearts. Thank you to each and every one of our customers!
New to the shop! Tooth Fairy "Dust" Charm Necklaces!

Tagged in this photo

View all 4 updates


Tooth Fairy Pillow Shop™

Tooth Fairy Pillow Shop™ makes the Tooth Fairy's job easier! With our tooth shaped pocket, and a ribbon strap to allow you to hang our pillows on door knobs, bedposts, dresser drawers, hangers or hooks, our tooth fairy pillows make collecting the goods a piece of cake.

We offer 3 dozen fabric choices and machine embroidered personalization on each of our pillows.

✂ The original Tooth Fairy Pillow Shop™, hanging tooth fairy pillow since 2010.
✂ Your happiness is our greatest concern. If you're not happy, we're not happy!
✂ 20 years of providing excellent customer service, both online & our retail store.
✂ Quality, care, attention to detail and happiness in every stitch!

★★★★ visit us at
★★★ like us on
★★ follow us on instagram @toothfairyps


Shop members

  • Jen

    Owner, Maker, Customer Service / Shipping

    The hands behind my 100% handmade products!

  • Miss G.

    Post Office Door Holder Opener

    Our best customer and muse ♥

Shop policies