handcrafted color-infused jewelry

New York, United States

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

carollai is taking a short break


Contact shop owner



No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:

Shop policies

Last updated on May 9, 2022

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

welcome to MustardSeed by.carollai where handcrafted and unique fine jewelry is created with lots of love and detailed care. all materials are of the highest quality.

check out my previously sold designs as pieces can be recreated (if i still have the materials). message me if interested. if you have an idea, request a custom-made item by clicking the link to the right.

items are added on an ongoing basis so check back frequently. buy something for yourself or for a dear friend! :)




Accepted payment methods

Returns and exchanges
MustardSeed by.carollai items are handcrafted with high quality materials and inspected with care before shipping. However, if you are unhappy with your purchase, I will gladly accept it for return or exchange in its original, unused condition, less the cost of shipping. Returns may be made within 7 days of receipt of the item, and exchanges may be made within 30 days.

Custom-made orders are not refundable or exchangeable.

Returns or exchanges on damaged items will only be accepted if you insured the item. If you receive an insured item that was damaged in transit, contact me within 2 days of receiving the item.
I accept Paypal.

Please note that you do not need a Paypal account: just click the Paypal button when checking out and follow the link to pay with your credit card.

Verify that your PayPal address matches your Etsy mailing address. The order will be shipped to your PayPal address. Payment via PayPal must be made within 2 days of the purchase time. If unable to do so, the sale will be canceled and the item will be relisted.
Items typically ship 1-3 days upon receipt of payment. All domestic and international orders will ship in a padded mailer or with sufficient padding via USPS.

Domestic orders are shipped via USPS First Class Mail with delivery confirmation. If you wish to purchase insurance, please request this at the time of purchase so the shipping cost can be revised.

International orders are shipped via USPS Air Mail. For insurance or tracking, please request an upgrade to Priority Mail International at the time of purchase so the shipping cost can be revised.

Once items have shipped, MustardSeed by.carollai is not held responsible for lost or damaged items not insured.
Additional policies and FAQs
Cleaning for Gold Filled and Sterling Silver fine jewelry:

Frequent cleaning is recommended to maintain its true beauty. Salt water, chlorine in swimming pools, soap and perspiration take their toll on all fine jewelry. Wipe your jewelry carefully with a soft cloth to keep it clean and free of these elements which oxidizes.

The best way to clean in places that a polishing cloth will not reach is very simple. Take a small bowl that will hold about a quart of water and line it with aluminum foil. Add hot water and a tablespoon of Tide washing powder (not liquid or bleach) and stir. Place your jewelry in the solution for about 1 minute and rinse with clean water and air dry.

If you have a build-up of dirt in hard to reach places, simply place a little dish-washing liquid in a bowl of water and soak over night.