CriticalHitShop

Handmade Nerdy Gifts and Home Decor, Video Game Jewelry

Kalamazoo, Michigan

3,222 Sales |

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

Silverclaw

Contact

Follow shop

Announcement Handmade geekery for men and women! Home decor and wearables from video games and other nerdy things. Home of the Personalized Life Bar Pin! Wear Your Fandom With Pride!

Follow us on Facebook and Instagram for updates! (@criticalhitshop)

Announcement

Last updated on Jan 15, 2022

Handmade geekery for men and women! Home decor and wearables from video games and other nerdy things. Home of the Personalized Life Bar Pin! Wear Your Fandom With Pride!

Follow us on Facebook and Instagram for updates! (@criticalhitshop)

Items

Contact shop owner

3222 Sales

2610 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Featured items

Eat the Rich - Nerdy Gifts - Gamestonks - Laptop Stickers - Anti Capitalism - Adulting Stickers

$6.00

GAMER SET 01: Hardwood Magnet Set- Hexagons - Gamer Decor - Nerdy Gifts

$25.00

GAMER SET 03: Hardwood Magnet Set- Hexagons - Gamer Decor - Nerdy Gifts

$25.00

PANDA & PETALS : Stim Toy - Nerdy Gifts - Hardwood Magnet Set- Red Panda Decor

$25.00

All Items

Moving RPG Action Selector Pins - video game jewelry accessories nerdy gifts

$15.00

Guess We're Renting Forever - Nerdy Gifts - General Strike - Laptop Stickers - Anti Capitalism - Adulting Stickers

$6.00

Trash Only Signs - Nerdy Gifts - Anime Lovers - Funny Home Decor - Party Signs

$35.00 FREE shipping

Eat the Rich T-Shirts - Cyberpunk Apparel - Wallstreetbets - Eat the Rich - Nerdy Gifts - Faux Modern - Corporate Parody

$29.00

Friends May Be Foes Sticker - Nerdy Gifts - Horror - Laptop Stickers - Alien Paranoia - Pop Culture Stickers

$6.00

Holographic Circuit Honeycomb Sticker - Nerdy Gifts - Science - Laptop Stickers - Cyberpunk - Adulting Stickers

$6.00

3 people have this in their cart

LAST BLOSSOM: Wenge and Resin Hardwood Magnet Set- Hexagons - Japan Decor - Nerdy Gifts

$40.00 FREE shipping

America Runs on Wage Slaves T-Shirts- Cyberpunk Apparel - Wallstreetbets - Eat the Rich - Nerdy Gifts - Faux Modern - Corporate Parody

$29.00

America Runs On Wage Slaves - Nerdy Gifts - General Strike - Laptop Stickers - Anti Capitalism - Adulting Stickers

$6.00

Cutethulu Sticker - Cthulhu Decals Nerdy Spooky Monsters Laptop Stickers Decals

$6.00

Limit Break Sticker - Nerdy Gifts - RPG -DND dungeon master Laptop Stickers - Fantasy Stickers

$6.00

SHARP SWIRLS: Hardwood Magnet Set- Nerdy Gifts - Hexagons - Geometric Decor

$25.00

GAMER SET 02: Hardwood Magnet Set- Hexagons - Gamer Decor - Nerdy Gifts

$25.00

GAMER SET 03: Hardwood Magnet Set- Hexagons - Gamer Decor - Nerdy Gifts

$25.00

OOPS! ALL VOIDS: Hardwood Magnet Set- Hexagons - Gamer Decor - Nerdy Gifts

$25.00

Friends May Be Foes - Alien Horror Decor Signs - Nerdy Gifts - Classic Horror - Home Decor - Monster Fucker - Monster Lover

$45.00 FREE shipping

Organics - Intergalactic Bathroom Signs - Nerdy Gifts - Cyberpunk Home Decor - SciFi Signs- Gender Neutral Restroom

$45.00 FREE shipping

4 people have this in their cart

Cute-thulu - Stainless Steel Cthulhu Necklace - Eldritch Horror - Halloween Jewelry

$25.00

Gaming Love Necklace - video game jewelry geek pendant 8bit statement zelda scott pilgrim

$25.00

Mr. Chippy Choppy T-Shirts- Cyberpunk Apparel - Wallstreetbets - Eat the Rich - Nerdy Gifts - Faux Vintage - 1930's Tribute

$29.00

Mr. Chippy Choppy - 12" x 18" Print - Eat the Rich - Gamestonks - Protest Art - Wallstreetbets - 1930s Vintage Cartoon Art

$20.00

Espionage 98 - 12 x 18 Print - Nerdy Gifts - Art Living Room - Gamer Art

$20.00

Caffeine/Sleep Meter Pins - Funny Video Game Pins - Dungeon Master Nerdy Gifts

$15.00

Only 1 left

Color Shifting Limit Break Pin - video game jewelry accessories nerd gifts

$15.00

Mothman Decor - Creepy Cute Cryptozoology - Macabre Art - Halloween Living Room

$90.00 FREE shipping

LVL UP! Video Game Decor - Geek Decor- Dungeon Master Gifts - Arcade Signs

$80.00 FREE shipping

EAT - Zombie Kitchen Decor- Horror Gifts - Macabre Art - Kitchen Decor

$60.00 FREE shipping

Colorful Gaming Love - Gaming Decor- Geek Decor - Personalized Wooden Bar Sign

$70.00 FREE shipping

Village Notice: Griffins - Carved Maple home decor medieval gaming

$90.00 FREE shipping

I Bombed Megaton - Video Game Decor- Gaming Decor - Post Apocalyptic Home Decor - Nerdy Gifts

$60.00 FREE shipping

Eat the Rich - Wooden Home Decor - Nerdy Gifts - Wallstreetbets - Gaming Home Decor - Anti Capitalism

$155.00 FREE shipping

Eat the Rich - Nerdy Gifts - Gamestonks - Laptop Stickers - Anti Capitalism - Adulting Stickers

$6.00

3 people have this in their cart

Game Over - Eat the Rich - Gamestonks - Video Game Decals - Laptop Stickers - Anti Capitalism - Adulting Stickers

$6.00

SWIRL - Hardwood Magnets - Nerdy Gifts - Synthwave Magnets - Video Game Gifts - Cyberpunk Fidget Toy

$6.00

GP 007 - Exotic Hardwood Magnets- hexagon classic gaming kitchen decor geeky refrigerator magnets exotic woods

$6.00

GP 006 - Exotic Hardwood Magnets- hexagon classic gaming kitchen decor geeky refrigerator magnets exotic woods

$6.00

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Contact shop owner

Silverclaw

Contact shop owner

Reviews

Average item review

(449)

See reviews that mention:

brenden42 on Jun 14, 2022

5 out of 5 stars

Took, a while, but was worth the wait, thank you

Glowing Life Bar Pin - Nerdy Pins - Cyberpunk Gifts - Video Game Jewelry - Glow in the Dark Health Bar

Glowing Life Bar Pin - Nerdy Pins - Cyberpunk Gifts - Video Game Jewelry - Glow in the Dark Health Bar
craig on May 25, 2022

4 out of 5 stars

Order took over a month from time of payment. Needed to glue a letter back on as it fell off. Cool sign once it was fixed

Organics - Intergalactic Bathroom Signs - Nerdy Gifts - Cyberpunk Home Decor - SciFi Signs- Gender Neutral Restroom

Organics - Intergalactic Bathroom Signs - Nerdy Gifts - Cyberpunk Home Decor - SciFi Signs- Gender Neutral Restroom
ナマケ on May 20, 2022

4 out of 5 stars

One month has passed.It hasn't been delivered yet.

Glowing Life Bar Pin - Nerdy Pins - Cyberpunk Gifts - Video Game Jewelry - Glow in the Dark Health Bar

Glowing Life Bar Pin - Nerdy Pins - Cyberpunk Gifts - Video Game Jewelry - Glow in the Dark Health Bar
Denis on Mar 24, 2022

5 out of 5 stars

Delivery time is fast and quality looks great

Holographic Circuit Honeycomb Sticker - Nerdy Gifts - Science - Laptop Stickers - Cyberpunk - Adulting Stickers

Holographic Circuit Honeycomb Sticker - Nerdy Gifts - Science - Laptop Stickers - Cyberpunk - Adulting Stickers
Andrew on Jun 15, 2022

5 out of 5 stars

Kevin was great to work with, prompt in replying, flexible with custom name tags and life bar lengths, and address change. The pins are good quality and just as ordered. Can't wait to gift them!

Custom Listing - Customized Life Bar Pins

Custom Listing - Customized Life Bar Pins
craig on May 25, 2022

4 out of 5 stars

Long time to ship. Pin not as high contrast as photos indicated. Maybe some light sealant to make it pop.

Fucks Given Meter Pin - Video Game Pins - Cyberpunk Accessories - Nerdy Gifts

Fucks Given Meter Pin - Video Game Pins - Cyberpunk Accessories - Nerdy Gifts
Joe on Mar 13, 2022

4 out of 5 stars

Item came as desired. Happy with the tag overall. Ordering my 2nd with better username choice

Personalized Glowing Life Bar Pin - Cyberpunk Gifts - Glow in the Dark Pin - Great for Gamertags - Fursona Pins - Nerdy Pins

Personalized Glowing Life Bar Pin - Cyberpunk Gifts - Glow in the Dark Pin - Great for Gamertags - Fursona Pins - Nerdy Pins
Jasiel on Jan 7, 2022

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful in person with all the colors. Definitely recommend it!

Eat the Rich - Nerdy Gifts - Gamestonks - Laptop Stickers - Anti Capitalism - Adulting Stickers

Eat the Rich - Nerdy Gifts - Gamestonks - Laptop Stickers - Anti Capitalism - Adulting Stickers
Jasiel on Jan 7, 2022

5 out of 5 stars

Love the play on the Dunkin logo to make this important message a bit more light hearted, yet still clear!

America Runs On Wage Slaves - Nerdy Gifts - General Strike - Laptop Stickers - Anti Capitalism - Adulting Stickers

America Runs On Wage Slaves - Nerdy Gifts - General Strike - Laptop Stickers - Anti Capitalism - Adulting Stickers
TheLastManlyMAN on Aug 8, 2022

3 out of 5 stars

Unfortunately... Im kinda upset with the pin... Main reason being how long it took to get here, over 2 Months! AND I UNDERSTAND being a one man army, but a heads up would have been nice... And at least contact me first, not the other way around. Another thing was that even though he said it was all caps he did ask if I wanted any lower case letters which made me assume ok, so he CAN do lower case. So when I saw the pin had all caps I was disappointed. Theres small blotches of glow on it and small blotches where it seems like theres not enough... and the resin seems more like glue covering the pin. For the price and how long it took? Im fairly disappointed with the results. I can't seem to take a picture of it since it's not the shop anymore. So you'll have to take my word on it.

Personalized Glowing Life Bar Pin - Cyberpunk Gifts - Glow in the Dark Pin - Great for Gamertags - Fursona Pins - Nerdy Pins

Personalized Glowing Life Bar Pin - Cyberpunk Gifts - Glow in the Dark Pin - Great for Gamertags - Fursona Pins - Nerdy Pins

Shop policies

Last updated on May 10, 2022

Hello! Welcome to Critical Hit Collectibles. I strive to provide high-quality indie merchandise for an increasing variety of fandoms; covering anime, video games, comic books and television shows. Currently, our operation is small, but there is a lot of potential for AGGRESSIVE expansion...

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Payment

We accept Paypal and Credit Card payments but also accept money orders, but only from the United States Postal Service.

If payment for your order is in excess of two weeks late, your shipment may contain live scorpions or anthrax.

Shipping

We generally ship via USPS First Class Mail. If you need an item for a specific date/event, please let me know and I'll try and work something out.

Additional policies and FAQs

NOTE: We respect the rights of all copyright holders. Since we are a shop that caters to gaming and geek culture, many of our items reference or have images from specific games and tv shows. Depending on the company, official views on fan-made products range from joy and encouragement at the strengthening of a fan base to the unleashing of assassins. With so many properties and companies, there is really no way to predict sentiment. However, if you represent the owners of a show/game/film and wish for us not to sell merch based on such a thing, let us know through a private email and we will be happy to remove the item(s), without delay or question.

CONTACT: bullet_time03 [!at] hotmail.com