Custom Candy Creations ~ Lollipops for Every Occasion

Carthage, Missouri
8,947 Sales | 5 out of 5 stars

Buyers are raving!

This shop got multiple 5-star reviews in the past 7 days.

Announcement    Availability through September will be extremely limited, as we have a new baby girl! Thank you for supporting small business!
Find my facebook page at


Last updated on Aug 25, 2021

Availability through September will be extremely limited, as we have a new baby girl! Thank you for supporting small business!
Find my facebook page at


8947 Sales

All Items


Contact shop owner



Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
Quality 55 Shipping 397 Customer service 273

About CustomCandyCreations

Sales 8,947
On Etsy since 2007

From Shoestring to Showstopping!

Custom Candy Creations was initially a hobby. The very first time I made a batch of lollipops it was because I had tried a sample of some candy a friend had made and I was convinced that I could do better. Bwahaha! The first batch was far less than stellar but over time the recipe was perfected and I started making lollipops for friends and family. Pretty soon every time someone had a birthday or wedding they wanted a new shape or flavor - an idea started to grow! In 2004, while pregnant with my 3rd child, Custom Candy Creations was launched. It's been growing & evolving ever since!

Shop members

  • Summer


Shop policies

Last updated on December 30, 2019
Welcome Etsy'ians!! I take pride in offering the best confections and customer service that I possibly can. Custom Candy Creations launched in October 2004 and has been growing and evolving ever since.

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept cancellations
Request a cancellation within: 2 days of purchase
I don't accept returns or exchanges
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
Returns and exchange details
Refunds are given on a case by case basis only. I generally do not refund for breakage. I take every precaution on this end to protect your lollipops, but I can't control what happens once the post office is in possession of them. Shipping is NOT refundable.

Because I use no preservatives, the shelf life of all hard candy is between 3 and 4 weeks. Please plan your order accordingly.
I will also accept postal & Wal-mart money orders. Well concealed cash is accepted at your own risk.

Custom creations for shapes/molds not currently on hand have the following requirements 1) I split the cost of the new molds with the customer (usually between 5-$10) 2) A 50% deposit (non-refundable once mold order is placed with my supplier)is required.
Shipping generally occurs Mon-Thursday each week to avoid having packages sitting in a post office on Sundays. Most packages are sent via Priority mail.

Every lollipop is carefully wrapped in bubble wrap (sometimes individually, but not always, it depends on the shape) and shipped in a sturdy box to avoid breakage. Unfortunately one or two may still be broken upon arrival, depending on several factors. Please plan your order to include a couple extra pieces just in case. Shipping is as close to actual as I can estimate. I'm happy to offer more accurate quotes based on zip code - just shoot me a message! Delivery confirmation is always included in the shipping total.

I am happy to ship internationally most of the time. Shipping prices in each listing are estimates. If you'd prefer a more accurate cost please send me an email. Only international priority shipping is available.