Firehouse Antiques, Jeff & Cindy Smotherman, owners

New Harmony, Indiana On Etsy since 2011

Buyers are raving!

This shop got multiple 5-star reviews in the past 7 days.


Firehouse Antiques, Jeff & Cindy Smotherman, owners

New Harmony, Indiana | 1,164 Sales

Announcement    Located in an 1899 Firehouse in the Midwest since 2003, and on Etsy since 2011. We buy directly from local estates in our area. If you don't see it here, follow us on Instagram or Facebook at Firehouse Antiques to see our brick & mortar shop!


Last updated on Feb 7, 2020

Located in an 1899 Firehouse in the Midwest since 2003, and on Etsy since 2011. We buy directly from local estates in our area. If you don't see it here, follow us on Instagram or Facebook at Firehouse Antiques to see our brick & mortar shop!



All Items

Cindy Smotherman

Contact shop owner

Cindy Smotherman


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
quality 44 shipping 105 customer service 55

About FirehouseAntiques

Sales 1,164
On Etsy since 2011

Sharing our fresh Farm Finds with you!

In 2003 my husband and I purchased an old Firehouse in a quaint historic town with a lot of interesting history, New Harmony, Indiana. We fully restored the circa 1899 Firehouse and opened our first Brick & Mortar Shop, Firehouse Antiques the same year. We have been here 17 years now and are going strong. We also promote our business associations annual New Harmony Antiques Show the second weekend of June each year and are looking to add local Etsy dealers if you are interested, contact us.

I am excited to offer what is in my antique shop here on Etsy. We are a husband and wife team that loves what we do. We specialize is finding authentic antique farmhouse decor, like old advertising and signs, unusual furniture and small items that will add a touch of your personality to your home. We are always on the lookout for the unusual, items you don't see often in antique shops. Follow us on social media to see what we bring in our antique shop daily. Our favorite places to pick are local farms, barns & sheds.

I am very excited to have my shop on Etsy. I love shopping Etsy and believe that Etsy has some of the most interesting and creative people as shop owners, in the world.

If you feel we have something in common or think I would like what you have, please feel free to add me to your circle or favorite my shop. You can also follow us ~ Firehouse Antiques on all social media, even Pinterest. Like and follow our Facebook page Firehouse Antiques or see more of our inventory and small Main Street town on Instagram. Let me know who you are and I will do the same. Happy Shopping!

Shop members

  • Cindy Smotherman


    I own and operate Firehouse Antiques in an 1899 Firehouse located on Main Street in New Harmony, Indiana. If you are ever in Southwest Indiana, come see us!

  • Jeff Smotherman

    Owner, Picker

    Jeff grew up riding with his arm around his mother’s neck in the front seat as she traveled the back roads of TN in the 1960s & 70s. Rex and Millie Smotherman were some of the first antiques dealers at The Heart of Country Show in Nashville, TN.

Shop policies

Last updated on June 18, 2020
Welcome to Firehouse Antiques on Etsy! We have had an open antique shop in New Harmony, Indiana for 17 yrs now and now we have an online store here on Etsy! We find our antiques & vintage items in local estates! Sharing the Vintage Past is our motto! Enjoy....

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
  • Money Order
  • Check
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept returns and exchanges
Contact me within: 3 days of delivery
Ship items back within: 14 days of delivery
I don't accept cancellations
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
The following items can't be returned or exchanged
Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:
  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Perishable products (like food or flowers)
  • Digital downloads
  • Intimate items (for health/hygiene reasons)
  • Items on sale
Returns and exchange details
I will refund your purchase price if you are unhappy upon receipt of your item/items. Contact me within 3 days of when you receive your item. Item must be packed and returned in the same condition as when it was sent to you. It also must be insured when you mail it back to me. Buyer pays return shipping & insurance. I will refund your purchase price, including shipping that was paid for your initial order. If you paid by paypal, I will refund money to your paypal account or we can do store credit. I also may give refund by check. Store Credit does not expire but we suggest you use it as soon as you see something you want to purchase with it.

If any item is damaged or lost during shipping, please keep your shipping box just in case it is needed for claim. I will file a claim on my end unless it is required that you do so. Items damaged in transit may require your assistance for the claim. I insure most every box I ship so you will have a claim. Contact me if your item was damaged in shipping and keep the box, take photos and send them to me with your first email. I will be happy to assist in any way I can.

International buyers, I do not know the policies in your country regarding shipping and know that many items cannot be insured, so please check these policies before your purchase if you are concerned. Thank you.
We accept all major credit cards and Paypal and you can pay by credit card through paypal. It is very easy to sign up. We ship within 2 business days of receiving your payment. If you mail a check, it will have to clear before we ship which is approximately 5 business days depending where it is from. It is better to pay by U.S. Money Order for faster shipping. If there is a choice of an item, please let us know your choice, or we will choose it for you after one email to you requesting your choice.

If your purchase is a gift, please let us know so we can make the gift special for you. We will always work with you to make your experience a great one.
We ship First Class or Priority Mail with Insurance through the US Postal Service with Tracking. We pack with recycled packing materials to stay green and reuse. We will ship internationally on most items, so please ask. International buyers are responsible for the customs taxes when it arrives in your country. Please email/convo me with any questions.
Additional policies and FAQs
You can contact me directly at firehouseantiques [!at]

More information

Last updated on Feb 18, 2019
Frequently asked questions
Where do we find all our vintage and antiques?

We pick local farms and we travel the backroads of America looking for the hard to find antiques and vintage items that we sell in our Brick and Mortar shop and here on Etsy. Our favorite items to find are country store display pieces but they don’t last long so follow us on social media and let us know you found us on Etsy!