Hand-picked vintage home goods for your space

Nappanee, Indiana · 1580 Sales


Hand-picked vintage home goods for your space

Nappanee, Indiana 1580 Sales On Etsy since 2011

5 out of 5 stars

Shop owner



Announcement   Welcome! ForgottenPLUM offers hand-picked vintage decor and housewares to complement your space
Follow us!


Last updated on Mar 25, 2018

Welcome! ForgottenPLUM offers hand-picked vintage decor and housewares to complement your space
Follow us!


Contact shop owner


View all 245 items


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
Kimm D

Kimm D on Mar 20, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

Love this purchase. Shipping was fast and item packed carefully. Would definitely purchase again from this vendor!

Adena Matheny

Adena Matheny on Mar 19, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

My item arrived in a timely manner and packaged very well. Thanks for being awesome! The tray is a gorgeous accent to my coffee bar!

View all 490 reviews


Preserving the Forgotten

My love for vintage and antique items was fostered as a child by time spent with my four sets of grandparents. From the family farm and land settled by my family over 200 years ago to the country store run by two generations, I was surrounded by heritage, history, hard work, faith, honesty and frugal living. As a young child, I felt an unusual attraction to the ways and the things of my grandparents' pasts.

forgottenPLUM offers hand-picked vintage and antique home goods from the first half of the 20th century. We frequent thrift stores, tag sales, estate sales and country auctions to hand-choose classic vintage and antique items we believe have intrinsic value. We love saving vintage and antique items from obscurity. When you purchase a vintage ware or an antique from forgottenPLUM, you are preserving the utility, the history and the beauty of these forgotten treasures.

We're so glad you stopped by! We would love to discover a treasure meant just for you.
Contact us at fochtja [!at]

Follow us:

Shop members

  • Jeanne

    Owner, Photographer, Curator

    My maternal and grandparents owned a country store, where I sold lemonade on the porch and learned how to count change back to customers. My Mom and 4-H taught me how to cook, sew and collect insects. And, I have been playing piano since 3rd grade.

  • Joe


    My husband and partner in discovering treasures for forgottenPLUM; Fun fact: our birthdays are on the same day, one year apart

  • Joslynn, Jessica, & Jill

    Daughters, Consultants

    These 3 share my love of "Good & Junky." They frequently inspire and encourage me, style and market items, junk with me and make me laugh. And not to forget, give us grand babies!

Shop policies

Last updated on March 2, 2018
Thanks for visiting forgottenPLUM! New items are added weekly. We enjoy many vintage items from different time periods and believe there is value in lost treasures being found and used again, perhaps in a new way. If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to contact us. We are question friendly-you will never know unless you ask!

Contact us by clicking the blue "Contact Shop Owner" button in our shop Or you may email us at fochtja [!at]

Accepted payment methods

  • Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
I don't accept returns, exchanges, or cancellations
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
We do not accept returns. Because we believe in the beauty found in vintage items and their imperfections, all items are sold "as is." If you have any questions or would like additional pictures of an item, please ask prior to purchasing.

IF we come to an agreement with the buyer about returning a purchased item:
An item will be returned in the original packaging; buyer pays return shipping. When the the unharmed, undamaged item arrives, the customer's refund will then be processed. The refund total is the original purchase total minus 10% to cover fees for processing credit card purchases and refund transactions.
PayPal, credit, or debit payments accepted. Items are shipped when payment is received.
Items are usually shipped within 1-3 days of payment, unless communicated otherwise.

Need an item shipped internationally? Please contact us for a shipping quote. International buyers are responsible for any customs charges.

Want to add shipping insurance or upgrade to express shipping? Please contact us to add shipping upgrades.

forgottenPLUM is not responsible for any lost/stolen/damaged items if insurance is not purchased.

Combined shipping on multiple items may be used as the item sizes allow.

Shipping overages of $2.00 or more will be refunded. forgottenPLUM does not make money on shipping. If you have shipping questions, please ask.

Whenever possible, forgottenPLUM uses pre-used shipping materials, boxes and packaging. While these supplies aren't always the prettiest, they help reduce, reuse and recycle!

To contact us: click the blue "Contact Shop Owner" button on our shop page at Or you may email us at fochtja [!at]
Additional policies and FAQs
Interested in RESERVING an item? Contact us and we'll set up a purchase date.