Home of The Cupfake!

Staten Island, New York

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

frankschick is taking a short break

Melissa Semioli

Contact shop owner

Melissa Semioli


No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:

Shop policies

Last updated on May 10, 2022

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Welcome to the Cakery Fakery! Here you will find all sorts of yummy looking fake cupcakes! My cupcakes contain no edible materials. I use a combinations of items to create the perfect treat. Sometimes I even incorporate dollhouse miniatures on certain cupcakes to expand on a particular theme. Each of my cupcakes are handmade, hand painted and hand decorated by me.

I love cupcakes, but truth be known, I am a terrible baker! I make these fake cupcakes or as I call them "cupfakes" to bring joy to any room/space where they are displayed! Who doesn't smile when they see a cupcake??

I can custom make you a cupcake if you send me a message with your likes/specifications. I can also make party favors for your next event! They can be mini cupcakes or full size! Again, just send me a message and we can set everything up!

Accepted payment methods

Returns and exchanges
If you are unhappy with your cupfake, simply contact me and we will work it out. However, I am not responsible for reimbursing you for shipping the item back to me.
Paypal only at this time.
Shipping methods vary according to the weight of the order. Generally, I use US Priority mail or USPS First class mail. International orders cannot be tracked.
Additional policies and FAQs
My cupfakes are all hand made by me and are not mass-produced.

I welcome custom orders! Custom orders generally take about 10-12 days for delivery because I have to create the product(s) and then the item must have at least a week of "drying time".

I can also create favors for your next event! Just send me a message with details and what you have in mind and we can start the process. Bulk orders receive discounts!

These cupcakes are NOT toys. Many of them contain small parts which can present a chocking hazard. Please keep them out of the reach of small children!

Please keep in mind that these pieces ARE breakable (like any other piece of ceramics, lenox, china etc etc) therefore should be handled with care and not played with by kids. They should be kept in a safe lace where they won't be dropped or mishandled.