handpainted signs//meaningful decor and gifts//adoption

Ephrata, Pennsylvania | 520 Sales


handpainted signs//meaningful decor and gifts//adoption

Ephrata, Pennsylvania 520 Sales On Etsy since 2015

5 out of 5 stars (109)

ItAllBeganWithPaint2 is taking a short break


Note from shop owner We are taking a break to finish current orders. We will be back soon! If you have any questions, please email at itallbeganwithpaint2 [!at]

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Jan 21, 2019

We are taking a break to finish current orders. We will be back soon! If you have any questions, please email at itallbeganwithpaint2 [!at]

Abigail Good

Contact shop owner

Abigail Good


Buying as a gift! We are happy to offer gift wrapping. Choose "mark as a gift" when checking out!
A bunch of farmhouse style signs NEW to the shop! Multiple sizes of each available!
One day sale! Use code smallbusiness100 to get 15% off your order! Saturday only!
View all 13 updates


Welcome to my shop of unique and beautiful handpainted signs!

In 2015, we began creating things for local craft shows. We started It All Began With Paint 2 in January 2016.
We originally used scrap wood for our signs, but as this little business grew, we couldn't keep up with the amount of reclaimed wood we would need.
All of our signs are handcrafted with pine wood. Each part of the process is done by us. Cutting boards, sanding, painting backgrounds and adding lettering; then carefully packaged for you, our sweet customers.

If you would like a custom sign, please click the "Request Custom Order" button, and I will be happy to work with you in creating a sign just for you. If you live outside the continental USA, and wish to receive a sign, please send me a convo and I will send you a link with the adjusted shipping price.

You may also contact me at itallbeganwithpaint2 [!at]

Thank you for stopping by! Before you go, please favorite our shop so you do not miss out on what is happening! Be blessed!

Shop members

  • Lyndel Good

    Owner, Marketer

    carpenter // sign maker // power tool operator

  • Abigail Good

    Owner, Creator, Photographer

    designer // sign maker // artist // shipping manager

Shop policies

Last updated on January 21, 2019
Welcome to our little shop! We are so glad you are here!

We became a family of 3 in 2018 by the gift of adoption. This shop helped that dream come true. It is an honor to work with each of our customers to create a sign that is meaningful for their own family!

Our shop's mission is to provide you with clean, uplifting, upbuilding words to fill your home. We reserve the right to politely decline any requests for quotes that include slang or swear words or have a negative connotation towards others. Thank you for understanding.

All signs of our signs are hand painted, and no two are exactly alike. We are honored to offer these heirloom pieces.

While you are here please favorite our shop so you will be updated every time we list a new sign.

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept returns and exchanges
Contact me within: 14 days of delivery
Ship items back within: 30 days of delivery
I don't accept cancellations
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
The following items can't be returned or exchanged
Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:
  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Perishable products (like food or flowers)
  • Digital downloads
  • Intimate items (for health/hygiene reasons)
Returns and exchange details
Returns: A refund will be issued for sign price after the shipping info (tracking number) is received for the return. Buyer pays return shipping.

Custom orders: Please double check all details on special orders before approving the final proof. Due to the custom availability we offer, refunds cannot be made on personalized custom orders (i.e. names, dates spellings) because of an error. However it may be possible to redo that particular part of the sign, free of charge, but buyer pays the extra shipping costs.
Buyer must contact me within 7 days of delivery regarding an issue with the sign.
Refunds or a new sign will be granted if your order is damaged or lost while shipping. Must provide picture proof of damage.
This shop accepts all major credit cards, Etsy gift cards, and Pay pal payment.
All items are shipped within 4-6 weeks of purchase. A rush order may be purchased along with your order to ensure next day shipping. Items are shipped via USPS with a tracking number and package insurance. Shipping charges will be calculated at checkout based on location. You may chose whichever shipping option best fits your needs.
Sometimes, depending on location, for larger signs FedEx is a cheaper shipping option then USPS. If you would like me to check that option for you, please send me a convo. If I find it is cheaper, you would be refunded the shipping difference.

If your sign is a gift for someone, I will be happy to ship it straight to them. (If you are purchasing a sign for a gift, please leave a message in the Note to Seller in the checkout that it is a gift, so I am sure to send it to the right address.
Optional: If you would like a message sent with the gift, I also provide that service.
Additional policies and FAQs
Custom orders are welcome! Follow us on Facebook and Instagram to see some of the signs we have made for special orders.