just-iced: hand decorated sugar cookies and treats

Salt Lake, Utah 167 Sales On Etsy since 2010

0 out of 5 stars (79)


just-iced: hand decorated sugar cookies and treats

Salt Lake, Utah | 167 Sales

justicedcookies is taking a short break


Note from shop owner Not currently taking orders.

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Mar 3, 2019

Not currently taking orders.

Kristen Fenton

Contact shop owner

Kristen Fenton


No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:
quality 4 shipping 15 customer service 11

Shop policies

Last updated on August 16, 2015
My sugar cookies are made from the finest and freshest ingredients, a recipe I have been working with and perfecting for over 15 years. They are decorated by hand and with delicious royal icing. My cookies are thick and soft; have been described as "ADDICTING", "MELT IN YOUR MOUTH", and "AWESOME!" I can also make gingerbread and chocolate sugar cookies.

PRICE: The prices of my cookies are based on size and detail involved. It takes time and a steady hand to make a pretty cookie. I think you'll find my cost is less than your neighborhood bakery or online retailer. I will do my best to be as descriptive as possible in my listings so you have a good idea of what type of product to expect.

My kitchen is my sanctuary. I take great care in making sure all my utensils, appliances, and working surfaces are clean and sanitary. The ingredients I use for my cookies are separate from those I use for my family. My kitchen has been inspected is currently certified by the Utah Department of Agriculture and Health Department. My home is also pet-free and smoke-free.

I have a background in art (drawing, graphic design, oil and watercolor), so if you have something specific in mind, I will do my best to bring it to life (as a cookie, of course!).

Please allow one week (7 days) for your order to be processed, baked, decorated, packaged and shipped. A $10 rush fee will be applied to orders needed to be delivered in less than 7 days, and shipping costs will likely increase.

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
  • Money Order
Returns and exchanges
Let's face it...sugar cookies are FRAGILE ~ and the postal system can be ROUGH! I take great care in packaging my cookies so that they are well cushioned and can take a beating. Please check your order once it is received, and if there are ANY damaged goods, please take a picture and contact me so we can figure out a solution. Again, I HIGHLY recommend shipping insurance!

Also, as stated above, I cannot be held responsible for shipments sent to an outdated address. If any packages are returned to me, the buyer will be charged to have it resent.
Unless you're local, currently the only method of payment I accept is Paypal. Payment is due within 24 hours of ordering, and your order will be processed once payment is received. PLEASE make sure the address associated with your Paypal account is current!! I DO NOT ACCEPT PERSONAL CHECKS.

Local (SLC, Utah) Residents: Cash, Money Order or Paypal accepted. NO PERSONAL CHECKS.
To maximize freshness and protect from breakage, orders are well-padded and often double-boxed and shipped in a USPS Priority package. Orders will be shipped within 3-4 days of processing, and should arrive in 2-3 days. Fedex or UPS is available upon request. I am also more than happy to ship to an APO address - I'm a military wife myself and am often sending cookies to the troops.

FREE LOCAL PICKUP in the Salt Lake City, Utah area. Delivery charges may apply.

Large orders (over 3 dozen) often need to be shipped in two separate boxes. Cookies are super fragile and the postal service can be ridiculously brutal (with or without "FRAGILE" stickers plastered all over the box!), so I use lots and lots of padding. Shipping costs usually cause a little sticker shock so be prepared! It usually evens out to about $8 a dozen, and I highly recommend adding shipping insurance (about $2 extra).

PLEASE confirm that the mailing address associated with your Etsy account is current, as well as your Paypal account. I cannot be held responsible for shipments mailed to an outdated address. If your address has changed recently, please make a note of it in your transaction notes to buyer or send me a convo.
Additional policies and FAQs
ALCHEMY: Do I take custom orders? ABSOLUTELY! If you have something specific in mind let me know - the more details (pictures or drawings) you can provide me, the better. I need at least 14 days notice for custom orders.

CUTTER SHAPES: I have many cookie cutter shapes, however, not all shapes ship so well. Simple pictures work best with cookies 3-4" in size. Anything with appendages or tails will likely break during shipping. If you would like a specific shape that I don't have please give me plenty of notice (an additional 3-5 days) so I can track it down.


NUTS: Unfortunately, my baking utensils have handled nut products in the past. Please keep that in mind before ordering - and especially before serving!

DAIRY and EGGS: My cookies contain dairy products and eggs.

GLUTEN FREE: I now produce gluten-free cookies. Prices are slightly higher as the ingredients are priced higher. Please convo me for an estimate on Gluten Free Sugar Cookies.