Witchy 90s Jewelry, Crystals, Gemstones, and Charms

Fullerton, California | 369 Sales


Witchy 90s Jewelry, Crystals, Gemstones, and Charms

Fullerton, California 369 Sales On Etsy since 2011

5 out of 5 stars (116)

MyCreakyStairs is taking a short break


Note from shop owner The shop is on pause for a quick vacation but we will reopen on Tuesday, May 28 Cheers!

My Creaky Stairs

Note from shop owner

Last updated on May 23, 2019

The shop is on pause for a quick vacation but we will reopen on Tuesday, May 28 Cheers!

My Creaky Stairs

Natalie McGlocklin

Contact shop owner

Natalie McGlocklin


Holiday wrapping for 2 bucks. Because you aren’t Martha Stewart.
heavy_plus_signThe Autumn Stack heavy_plus_sign is new and perfect for the fall season, also known as “sweater weather”.
Labor Day sale is on!! All your favorite bracelets 20% off through Monday, because starting Halloween season with some fresh My Creaky Stairs is required reading.
View all 6 updates


Jewelry, gems, charms and chains for witchy vibes and earthy connections. See and be free from fast fashion ☠

My Creaky Stairs is for witchy vibes, earthly connections, and anti-fast fashion. It was born from a desire to create in the image of humanity, earth, and spirituality, not religion. Pieces started coming together out of my maudlin obsession with the Day of the Dead, American pop art, and beautiful things that come from the earth and the female psyche. I love Halloween with its symbolic and literal ability to transform, disguise, and open our minds to the "other side". I love witches, and the power they embody by tapping into the intuition, power, and love inside each of us.

My Creaky Stairs was created by me, Natalie McGlocklin, and is based in Fullerton, California. I wish to create edgy, sometimes extreme pieces that are still wearable and beautiful. All bracelets are created to order so that I can offer the perfect size for each customer, as I know first-hand how difficult it can be to find a well-fitting bracelet when they only come in one standard size. Quality metal parts and gemstones are the priority, and many items are tarnish resistant, when available. A lot of pieces are made from extremely durable stainless steel. Custom manufacturing is done in the good ol' USA.

I am currently a one woman shop, doing all parts of the business from designing, sourcing, creating, inventory, marketing, photography, and even paying taxes like a good citizen. Although this business is currently only partially what I do, I hope to some day expand and grow. Thank you for stopping by, and I hope you find something here that speaks to you.

Shop members

  • Natalie McGlocklin

    Owner, Maker, Designer

    Into creepy stares, good vibes, dark visions and karma (it's real). Mixing goth with glam and a dash of natural gems and witchy crystals.

Production partners

  • LogoTags

    NY, United States

    LogoTags manufactures metal jewelry and chains, such as dog tags used by the U.S. military. They used lost cast waxing to create the custom skull bead you see in many of my designs, as well as the MCS charm.

Shop policies

More information

Last updated on Nov 13, 2017
Frequently asked questions
Care instructions

Please keep items away from perfumes and lotions, and store out of direct sunlight when not in use - store in original packaging with the included anti-tarnish strip for best results. Rub with an eyeglass cloth and cleaner to remove surface discoloration or build-up.

Contingency Plan

I also know that sh*t happens, so feel free to contact me for repairs, replacement, or resizing, and I will do my best. I want you to LOVE every single MCS piece!

About Materials

All items are sourced with the intention of quality - most metal parts are made from stainless steel, pyrite, rhodium plated silver, 14k gold fill, white bronze, or galvanized coating and are tarnish resistant when available - meaning most pieces should last a long time with simple care. Gemstones are semi-precious or precious (unless otherwise noted), and the white bronze skull is made custom for MCS here in the US. All items are hand assembled by me at my home in Fullerton, California.

Sizing details

To find the correct size, measure your wrist where you would naturally wear a watch. Add 1/2" to that measurement to find your bracelet size. At this size, bracelets will be snug so that they do not jangle or slide around. If you would like your bracelets to move around your wrist, more like a bangle, order one size up from that.

For example, my wrist measures 6". I wear an extra small 6.5" when I want the skull bracelets to stay tight on my wrist and not rotate around. If I want a little jangle and jiggle for a more natural look, I put on a size small 7". Please note bracelets will stretch out a tiny bit after a couple wears, but minimally. I am happy to resize any bracelets, you just pay return shipping.