Nays Custom Leather

5184 Sales


Nays Custom Leather

5184 Sales On Etsy since 2012

5 out of 5 stars

Shop owner

David Nay


David Nay

Contact shop owner

David Nay

View all 45 items


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars

Dakota on Apr 21, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

This is hands down the highest quality leather sheath for the Leatherman OHT period. I work in the natural gas business and walk in hip deep trenches rubbing it on the dirt and rocks every single day, there is hardly a scratch on it. Also it is formed leather for a perfect fit. It almost seems to “lock” into place. All in all if you have an OHT you have found it a permanent home.


Dominik on Apr 19, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

Great leather sheath, really amazing and it took only two weeks to germany. My new favorite edc. Thank you David

Jake Saar

Jake Saar on Apr 17, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

Excellent quality, perfect fit, will defiantly hold up.

View all 787 reviews


We've added a new listing for our leather crafters! You can now buy belt blanks from us! Make your own belt and do everything but cut out the shape! We took care of that for you! ;)
We have a new store JUST for instrument straps! So, if you've ever bought an instrument strap from our @NaysCustomLeather store, now you'll find it at our @NaysInstrumentStraps store! Go check it out!
PS. The listing tagged is just a random listing!
View all 7 updates


Nay's Custom Leather

I was shoeing horses for a living when a health problem slowed me down so, I started spending more time with my hobby, leather crafting. I was making saddles for friends, neighbors, and making repairs, and it turned into my main stay. After a time I wanted to make other items and they took off. So, now I'm here sharing with the world, my love for leather.

Shop members

  • David Nay

    Owner, Creator, Curator

    I am a custom saddle maker and have been in business for 20 years. I enjoy working with leather and have been branching out, making all kinds of custom leather projects. I'm wanting to share with the customer my love of the trade!

  • Megan Nay

    Assistant, Photographer, Shipper

    I am the daughter of the, "Leather Wizard" himself as I like to call him...and I basically do what I'm told(That's just what I let my dad believe...Shhh!). Just kidding, I have my responsibilities here just like my dad! I do everything I can to help

Shop policies

More information

Last updated on May 16, 2017
Frequently asked questions

"I don't see my tool in your dropdown box options. Can I get a sheath made for my tool?"

Yes! We mold the leather right to the tool to make our sheaths. We have most Leatherman and Gerber tools on hand in the shop to mold it to. If we don't have your specific tool/knife, you have to send us yours to us so we can build it! Note with your order your tool/knife!

"What is the best way to care for my leather item?"

Most of the over the counter items are fine to use. The best way we have found is to clean with Murphy's Oil Soap and water, then condition with Nay's Leather Cream. It works very well and can make your sheath, belt or whatever leather item look as good as new! We make our own leather cream here in the shop that we sell on our Etsy store! Click the link to buy the cream for your leather care!