Vintage Jewelry, Charms & Religious Medals.

oneofakindwisconsin is taking a short break.

Sign in to be notified by email when the shop owner returns.

oneofakindwisconsin's Shop Announcement

VACATION ANNOUNCEMENT: One of a Kind Wisconsin will be closed for vacation from May 22nd until June 8th. I will be unable to answer emails at this time and be offline. All orders placed this week- will be shipped out until Friday at 3pm. Thanks so much!

ღஐƸ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄ƷஐღOne of a Kind Wisconsin sells a wide selection of vintage and antique jewelry for both collectors and jewelry artisans alike. We also offer brand new supplies- we will clearly mark what is Vintage (20 years or older), Antique (Pre 1930) and NEW (modern unused supplies). New items are added weekly.

PLEASE NOTE: I do not acid test any of the sterling items due to environmental reasons and disposing of acid into sinks at my office is messy. Thanks so much!

ღஐƸ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒஐღ Looking for a COUPON CODE? Use ONEOFAKIND15 for 15% off orders over $50 and for bulk orders use ONEOFAKIND20 for 20% off any orders over $75. Discount does not apply to shipping. For help with using coupon codes see this link Thanks so much!

If you are a new customer to One of a Kind Wisconsin- please read our shop policies before placing an order.

Regarding Reserved Items: I am no longer able to reserve items at all. I have a very limited time to list each day due to being the accountant and office manager of my husband's computer repair business. I appreciate your understanding regarding our "No Reserves" policy.

Items come from a smoke free environment.

oneofakindwisconsin's Shop Policies


One of a Kind Wisconsin LLC is owned by Michelle Gartner, who started the company in 2006 to share her love of vintage jewelry and charms.

Buyers in the Sheboygan area can purchase items by appointment. We are located in the Jake's Cafe Creative Community Campus. Please email or convo me if you would like to stop in.


We now accept credit cards and ETSY gift cards through the direct checkout feature.

We also accept Paypal and some mail in payments on a case by case basis. Please email if you would like to send in a payment.


ATTENTION INTERNATIONAL CUSTOMERS: I still ship items internationally- however the US Postal service has greatly increased the cost of first class international as of January 26, 2014. If you are interested in purchasing items and you are an international customer, please convo me for rates. Sorry for the inconvenience. -Michelle

Regarding International Shipping: I do ask that international customers make a minimum purchase of $10 not including shipping, because I do pay merchant fees for payments, listings, etc and it is makes it cost prohibitive for me to ship small low cost items internationally when I pay merchant fees on the shipping.

We ship every weekday- Monday through Friday unless it is a holiday or we are on vacation or an emergency comes up.

Refunds and Exchanges

We want our customers to be 100% satisfied with their purchase. Please feel free to contact us with any questions or concerns and we will be glad to work with you.

Returns are accepted within 7 days. Buyer to pay return shipping.

Additional Policies and FAQs

Regarding Reserved Items: I am no longer able to reserve items at all. I have a very limited time to list each day due to being the accountant and office manager of a computer service business and taking care of my disabled son. I appreciate your understanding.

Please do not leave negative feedback without first consulting with me- as I believe we can reach a mutually satisfying resolution before it would be necessary to leave negative feedback regarding a transaction. Thanks so much- Michelle

Last Updated November 11, 2014