Celebrating 7 years on Etsy!

5320 Sales


Celebrating 7 years on Etsy!

5320 Sales On Etsy since 2008

0 out of 5 stars

papertreats is taking a short break


Note from shop owner I have moved my cake toppers to my other shop Thank you all you lovely people interested in my products! Feel free to contact me on if you have any questions.
Have a delightful day! :)

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Mar 5, 2015

I have moved my cake toppers to my other shop Thank you all you lovely people interested in my products! Feel free to contact me on if you have any questions.
Have a delightful day! :)

Caroline Stender

Contact shop owner

Caroline Stender


No reviews in the last year

Lizzyladie on Apr 10, 2015

5 out of 5 stars

Quick service exactly what I expected. Will make future purchases. 👍👍


L.L. on Mar 6, 2015

5 out of 5 stars

i changed my star because I LOVE that you were gracious enough to refund my money. thank you.


L.L. on Mar 6, 2015

5 out of 5 stars

____updated: i changed my original 1 star to 5 stars on this because the seller was most gracious and refunded my purchase price. that was so much appreciated and helped cover the cost to purchase replacements for the party. many thanks for doing so

View all 3228 reviews


Handcrafted Paper Treats

I had been selling handcrafted scrapbook pages, in 2007, on ebay, and I was doing very well. But I decided I wanted to move on. I came across Etsy when it was just becoming known to the world. The whole concept felt right to me.

February of 2008, Paper Treats was born. If you look at my early listings, you can tell I was trying to establish what I wanted to create and sell. I began to work hard at creating unique gift tags using Martha Stewart punches, because they really inspired me.

In October of that year, I had the pleasure of going to a Martha Stewart book signing with the encouragement of my friend. So I made Martha a package of cupcake toppers ( a new concept at the time).
Martha didn't say anything to me, but as I was walking away I heard a voice say "Paper Treats ?" She was holding up my gift. I ran back over there, and in my giddy way began to tell her how much I loved her products. "I'll tell Lenore, maybe will have you on" she said.
I walked away thinking, yeah right. She probably says that to lots of people!

In November, I was contacted by a producer from the show. She said she love my gift tags and asked if I was willing to come to NYC and show Martha how to make my Christmas tags. I just about fell over. I had to overnight a bunch of product for them to look at first. When the producer showed Martha all the tags, Martha said " Oh yeah, I saw all that before. I met her at a book signing." So come to find out, the producer didn't even know Martha had already met me. They both agreed I needed to be on!

December 9th was the big day! Follow this link to watch the episode.


Shop members

  • Caroline Stender

    Owner, Designer, Photographer

    There's never been a time in my life that I wasn't creating something. I'm self taught, but God has given me the artistic ability. I feel so blessed to be living my dream!

Shop policies

Last updated on August 4, 2014
When buying a handmade item from Paper Treats, you can have confidence that each item is carefully handcrafted! Paper Treats studio is smoke free!

I value your feedback, so if you are pleased with your Paper Treats purchase, I'd love to hear about it with your comments.

Thank you for visiting my shop, please come back again and bring a friend.

Accepted payment methods

  • Pay with Visa
  • Pay with Master Card
  • Pay with American Express
  • Pay with Discover
  • Pay with PayPal
  • Buy with Apple Pay
  • Pay with Sofort
  • Pay with iDeal
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards
Pay Pal is accepted. You can also make a credit card payment with out having a paypal account. New to Etsy? This link will help you with the checkout process
Shipping and handling fees not only cover postage, but also shipping materials, time listing, packaging orders, service to & at the Post Office. All my international packages must be hand delivered to the Post Office due to the customs slip that's needed. Actual costs will be put on the customs slip. Tracking numbers are included with U.S. packages only.

Shipping 1-4 business days after payment. (May through August 2-10 days) I try to accumulate several packages and drive to the Post Office 2 times a week. Paper Treats does not accept local pick-ups.

***Buyers need to make sure their address is correct before the order goes out. Paper Treats is NOT responsible for wrong addresses, or misguided mail. Paper Treats CANNOT put in a new address for the buyer once the package has left our hands.***
Refunds and Exchanges
Due to the nature of our products all sales are final.
Additional policies and FAQs
Keep in mind I am a one person operation. I do my best to get the orders made & sent out in a timely manner. Orders may be delayed a few days for my children's important occasions. Your consideration is much appreciated!

I want happy and satisfied customers! If for some reason you are not happy with something, Please convo me first, so we can resolve it together!

Paper Treats working business hours are 8:00am-3:00pm EST Tuesday-Friday. Saturday and Sunday convos will be answered on Tuesday.

Sorry, no wholesale orders available.

All items are proudly made in Michigan, in my smoke free/pet free studio.
© 2008 - All text, designs and images are copyright of papertreats and are not to be used without prior consent.