Plushes with Personality!

New Philadelphia, Ohio

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

peachypaws is taking a short break


Note from shop owner Thanks so much for stopping by! I'm on an Etsy break thru early May, but I'll be back with lots of goodies and. . .PATTERNS!

In the meantime, if you're in the Tuscarawas County Ohio area, stop by the JoAnn Fabrics store at New Towne Mall and sign up for a crochet class. You can learn how to crochet and make lots of fun projects from yours truly :)

I'll also be on display at the Quail Hollow State Park Craft and Herb fair Saturday and Sunday, May 5-6 with my Mom of

Happy Spring!

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Aug 4, 2022

Thanks so much for stopping by! I'm on an Etsy break thru early May, but I'll be back with lots of goodies and. . .PATTERNS!

In the meantime, if you're in the Tuscarawas County Ohio area, stop by the JoAnn Fabrics store at New Towne Mall and sign up for a crochet class. You can learn how to crochet and make lots of fun projects from yours truly :)

I'll also be on display at the Quail Hollow State Park Craft and Herb fair Saturday and Sunday, May 5-6 with my Mom of

Happy Spring!


Contact shop owner



No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:

Shop policies

Last updated on May 10, 2022

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Welcome to my Etsy shop--it's a zoo in here! Looking for original crochet critter designs and custom pet replicas? You've come to the right place! If you have any questions about my work, feel free to convo me--I'd love to hear from you!

Here are a few FAQ:

Q: I'm interested in ordering a custom pet replica. How do I get started?
A: Step 1: Send photos of your pet to peachypaws [!at] The more photos of different angles you're able to send, the more acurate your pet replica will be. Also, please be sure your photos reflect the true color(s) of your pet as I will be color matching yarn against these photos. Again, the higher the quality of your pics, the better :)

Step 2: Include any special traits you'd particularly like highlighted that might not be apparent from the pics. (Like, green eyes or a tail kink, etc.)

Step 3: Also specifiy what position you'd like your pet replica to be in. I offer seated, standing, or reclining. Take a peek at my sold orders for samples of each option.

Step 4: Please let me know if you have any fiber allergies. I often use wool and mohair blends for pet replicas, and sometimes synthetic fibers, too. All plushes are stuffed with hypoallergenic polyfil. If you require organic or specialty fibers, please be aware that there may be an upcharge.

After reviewing your photos and notes, I'll contact you ASAP with my current turnaround time for your order. My typical turnaround is between 2-4 weeks, but it's often 6-8 weeks from October thru December.

Q: How do you design custom pet replicas without a pattern?
A: I've been freehand crocheting for over a decade, which means I have a lot of experience creating specific shapes without a pattern. I love the challenge of freehand crocheting and the freedom of not being tied down to a pattern. Plus, this ensures that just like your special pet, there will never be another one quite like it. In many ways, I think of what I do as sculpting with yarn because I strive to achieve very specific shapes when I crochet--not just perfectly numbered rows or rounds. This is also how I'm able to make the same animal in multiple sizes.

Q: Are your animals baby safe?
A: All my critters (with only a few exceptions) are intended to be loved and played with--especially those with embroidered or needlefelted eyes. Animals with safety eyes aren't intended for anyone under the age of 5, due to choking hazards. A lot of care goes into making my animals durable so they'll last the long haul of childhood. Check out my feedback ratings for photos of my plush creations "in action" with their new owners :)

Q: What do you stuff your plush animals with?
A: All my critters are stuffed with hypoallergenic polyester stuffing. Each animal gets just enough to remain plump, soft, and cuddly--never firm or stiff.

Q: How do I care for my new plush purchase?
A: All critters come with a care tag identifying if they are hand wash only or machine washable. (This info is also indicated in each individual item listing.) Hand wash plushes can be cleaned with a damp cloth and air dried. Machine washable plushes should be cleaned on the gentle cycle and then left to air dry for at least 8 hours. Some re-fluffing may be necessary, but otherwise, your plush will be as good as new!

Q: Can you ship my purchase as a gift to another address?
A: Absolutely! I'm happy to giftwrap and add a handwritten note to your recipient (for free! :) and ship the package directly to them. Be sure to enter your recipient's address at checkout or send me a convo with their address info. No shipping upcharge will be applied unless you are a US buyer seeking to send a package outside the continental US. In that case, standard international shipping rates will apply. International buyers will be refunded the difference in shipping fees if they are seeking to send a gift within the continental US.

Q: Do you make copyrighted TV, book, or movie characters?
A: Only if no officially registered plushes (crochet or otherwise) are in existence. Copyright infringement is illegal, and Etsy discourages sellers from replicating copyrighted characters.

Q: If I buy a pattern from another seller on Etsy, will you make it for me?
A: Only if that seller is offering the pattern for commercial use. Many pattern designers on Etsy have strict guidelines about how their patterns may be used and distributed. Your best bet is usually to approach the designer and request they make the physical item for you to avoid any copyright infringement issues.

Q: If I buy your pattern, can I have someone else make it for me?
A: Yes, but I'm also happy to make the physical animal for you if you don't know how to crochet and it's not already listed in my shop for sale :) Just ask!! I've been working with these patterns for years, and I may be a little biased, but I can guarentee there's nothing like the "real McCoy" :)

Q: If I buy your pattern, can I sell the items I make from it?
A: Definitely! However:
*You may not market your items under my brand or logo (Peachy Paws and the tagline Plushes with Personality are protected under federal trademark law),
*You may not use my listing text, pattern text, or photos as your own. These are protected under federal copyright law.
*You may not imply that the items you create from my patterns are your original designs. You may choose not to reveal your pattern source or you may use this optional credit line in your item listings: "Pattern design by Ashley Casteel of" In return for using the optional credit line, I will reccomend your shop or website in my shop announcement.
*You may not offer the actual pattern for sale or redistribute the pattern en masse physically or electonically. This includes making any portion of the pattern publicly available online or making copies of the pattern to distribute to a crochet circle, etc.

I'm extremly flattered that people are interested in reproducing my work and very excited to give others the opportunity to earn an extra income from my designs. I simply ask that you respect my terms. Should I find a buyer in violation of my terms, I reserve the right to prompty refund all future sales and refuse service.

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.


I DO NOT require upfront payment on custom orders under $100 :) I strive to create a pressure-free, risk-free atmosphere for my buyers, so you don't owe me anything until you are 100% satsified with the finished product.
On orders over $100, I ask for a 50% refundable deposit to cover materials. If you are not satisfied with the finished product, I'm happy to refund your deposit :)

PLEASE NOTE: I accept payment via Paypal ONLY! I use PayPal's invoicing system to arrange payment for alchemy items. If you have questions about PayPal before purchasing, just let me know!


I ship instock items within 24 hours of recieving payment. Please allow at least 2 weeks for custom order projects if my shop announcement doesn't indicate that I am pre-booked with custom orders.

Items listed with $3.00 shipping rate will be shipped first class. Items listed with a $5.00 rate will be shipped priority. Please conact me before checkout if you'd prefer a faster shipping method or UPS shipping. If you're outside the US and interested in making a purchase, please convo me and I'll get you a precise shipping quote ASAP. Most international purchases are shipped first class international. International buyers should allow at least 2-4 weeks for delivery after your item is shipped.

Patterns are e-mailed in PDF format within 24 hours of recieving payment. Please be sure to include your e-mail addess at check-out if the e-mail you have registered with Etsy and Paypal is not the address you want the pattern sent to. Please contact me if you would like a physical copy of the pattern mailed to you. Snail mail shipping is just $1.00 extra :)

Additional policies and FAQs

CUSTOM ORDER POLICY: Please allow at least 2 weeks for custom orders. I am often booked in adavance with custom requests, so please be sure to check my shop announcement to be sure I can make your order within your desired timeframe!

BULK ORDER POLICY: I'm always flattered by buyers seeking large quantities of critters, but unfortunately I'm a one-woman crochet machine with a family and full-time day job. In that way, I function a lot like the express lane at the grocery store: I cannot accept orders that consist of more than 10 items. Also, there is NO DISCOUNT on bulk orders. Please understand that each item is my shop takes between 4 and 12+ hours to create. A 50% refundable deposit is due at time of order. Please allow at least 4-6 weeks to complete your bulk order. Absolutely no last-minute bulk orders will be considered! (Read also my custom order policy, above.)

WHOLESALE AND CONSIGNMENT POLICY: At this time, I am declining all wholesale and consignment offers as it is financially and logistically impractical for me to offer my items for sale anywhere but Etsy. (Read also my bulk order policy, above.)

TRADE POLICY: On rare occassions, I will consider trading my plush creations for other items on Etsy. However, due to the time-consuming nature of crochet and the work that goes into designing each item, I will not trade for bead jewelry, bath products, or most other personal luxury items. Also, no children's items. Things I almost always consider trading for: supplies (safety eyes, yarn, wool roving, felting supplies, etc), vintage clothing, gemstone jewelry, mixed media artwork, practical housewares or organizational items, and vintage display pieces that I can use at craft shows (especially 50s-era hard-side suitcases!).
The bottom line: Please respect that I'm a picky person who trades at my own discretion. If you ask for a trade, understand that does not mean I am in any way obligated to oblige. I will respond to all trade offers, but do not request a trade if you will be offended if I politely decline.