Affordable & Customizable Body Jewelry

413 Sales


Affordable & Customizable Body Jewelry

413 Sales On Etsy since 2012

5 out of 5 stars

Announcement   Hello, and welcome to PinUpPlugs! Use coupon code "PLUGS10" for a 10% discount off your order for a limited time only!


Last updated on Sep 24, 2015

Hello, and welcome to PinUpPlugs! Use coupon code "PLUGS10" for a 10% discount off your order for a limited time only!

Michelle Whitehead

Contact shop owner

Michelle Whitehead

Single Flared Stainless Steel Tunnels
Faux Cheater 18g Stainless Steel Tapers
Spider Web Screw Top Plugs
Cute Heart Plugs (ANY color combination)
Faux Cheater Stainless Steel Star Tapers (18g)
Faux Cheater Stainless Steel Plugs (Illusion) 18g
Star Plugs (ANY color combination)
Yellow Daisy Plugs
White Summer Daisy Plugs
Stainless Steel Double Flared Eyelets


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
Teresa Swartz

Teresa Swartz on Mar 28, 2017

5 out of 5 stars

Super fast shipping and exact match on size, material, etc. I love them.. thanks!

Lukas Fuller

Lukas Fuller on Jan 30, 2017

5 out of 5 stars

fast shipping, clean packaging. nice!

View all 138 reviews


Happiest Day Ever

One christmas, when money was tight, my husband surprised me with his own creation- plugs! I wanted a pair of plugs going for $50.00 and when I opened the present he got for me, they were the plugs I wanted, just better... Hand made and with a ton of love! From that moment on, my goal was to get that exact happiness and exciment from all my customers. I am so proud of PinUpPlugs!


Shop members

  • Michelle Whitehead

    Owner, Maker, Designer, Curator

    I love what I do!!! I get to make jewelry that I adore and I get to read all the feedback that my lovely customers have left me, I love reading about their happiness.

  • Jordan Khan

    Owner, Maker, Designer

    Bestest husband, friend and co-owner out there! :) Jordan is usually in charge of the more creative aspect of the company. He rolls the polymer clay and designs the tedious designs you see in the shop.

Shop policies

Last updated on November 10, 2012
We have a huge variety of jewelry. If we don't sell your desired color, style or size, let us know so we can try to keep our shop updated and you happy :)

Accepted payment methods

  • Pay with Visa
  • Pay with Master Card
  • Pay with American Express
  • Pay with Discover
  • Pay with PayPal
  • Buy with Apple Pay
  • Pay with Sofort
  • Pay with iDeal
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards
In order to make the process smoother for everyone, I adhere to the following policies:
-If an order is not paid in full within 72 hours, the order will be canceled, unless other arrangements have been previously made. If you need time to send me payment, just let me know, and we'll work it out!
-Orders will not be shipped out until payment is cleared in full.
-All custom orders must be paid in full before I begin work

Thank you for your understanding, I look forward to your business!
If your paypal and etsy addresses do not match, I will contact you to confirm which address to send your order to. If I do not receive notification of which address to ship to within 72 hours, your order may be cancelled.

I wrap each and every item very carefully. I want your item to arrive safe and sound, in pristine condition. I ship all my items by first class mail. If you would like faster shipping, please let me know so I can calculate additional cost for you.

All items will be shipped within 72 hours of order completion for custom orders.

Please respond to our confirmation message and email after purchase. If you do not respond with a confirmed address and/or choice of plug color, I will send out default photo plug and ship packages within 5 business days with no option of return.
Refunds and Exchanges
I strive to describe each and every item I sell to the best of my abilities, and get it to you in one piece. Should my products or service fall short of your expectations in any way, I will gladly work with you to assure you end up happy. All items are custom made and are non-exchangeable however if damaged may possibly be replaced. Refunds or replacements will be given at the sellers digression.
Additional policies and FAQs
I love making custom plugs! Be it an extra large size or a special color combination, I can make exactly what you need!

Feel free to contact me with any questions, concerns or suggestions. I promise to respond as quickly as possible!!!