Unique Jewelry, Handcrafted Items, Repurposed Wares

Seattle, Washington · 315 Sales


Unique Jewelry, Handcrafted Items, Repurposed Wares

Seattle, Washington 315 Sales On Etsy since 2010

0 out of 5 stars

StormRiderGoods is taking a short break


Note from shop owner StormRider Goods will be back in action soon!

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Jun 7, 2017

StormRider Goods will be back in action soon!

Sarah Jane Scherer

Contact shop owner

Sarah Jane Scherer


No reviews in the last year

sweetsarahjane on Feb 29, 2016

5 out of 5 stars

These plugs are beautiful and very comfy to wear. I always get lots of compliments when I wear them.

Letitia Getka

Letitia Getka on Jan 22, 2016

5 out of 5 stars

Shipped quickly and they look great - even better in person than in the photos.

View all 68 reviews


LAST DAY to get 20% off the entire store ! Added new plugs and earrings yesterday !!!

Tagged in this photo

HEY! I'm having a small business/cyber Monday sale this weekend ! EVERYTHING ON SALE in my ETSY shop. 20% off. Use coupon code PRETTYCOOL. ONLY VALID THROUGH MONDAY. so get on it ! Plugs! Earrings ! Live fast , stay pretty.

Tagged in this photo

All Seeing Eye Illuminati Craft Cross Earrings
All Seeing Eye Illuminati Craft Cross Earrings


Pretty Plugs for stretched ears and pretty earrings too!

Making your stretched ears beautiful! I love to be creative and design plugs and earrings to complete your cool and unique look. See a pair of earrings that I made that you would like made into plugs? See a pair of plugs you like that is not your size? Send me a message, and I'll see what I can do! Thanks for checking out my shop and stay pretty! xoxo.

Around the web

Shop members

  • Sarah Jane

    Owner, Maker, Designer

    I love making jewelry for stretched ears! I've always wanted the perfect pair of earrings that are also plugs, so I decided to start doing it and share my creation with you. I also make unique earrings for those of you that don't have stretched ears!

Shop policies

Last updated on April 22, 2016
Hello and thank you for stopping by my shop! For years and years, I have had stretched ears and have been searching for the prettiest plugs to wear. I love having my ears stretched, but I always felt like I wasn't able to wear real earrings without it being an uncomfortable fit. SO, I have created Pretty in Plugs! I offer handmade, unique, often one-of-a-kind, pretty plugs using new and vintage pieces. I hope you love what you see! And due to popular demand, I have started making real earrings as well!

Accepted payment methods

  • Pay with Visa
  • Pay with Master Card
  • Pay with American Express
  • Pay with Discover
  • Pay with PayPal
  • Buy with Apple Pay
  • Pay with Sofort
  • Pay with iDeal
  • Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
  • Money Order
I accept PayPal, credit cards, debit cards and etsy gift cards.. Payment is due within 3 business days of purchase on Etsy. If you need to cancel an order, please contact me within 2 days of purchase. Cancellation will not be accepted after order is sent out.
All packages will be shipped USPS ground mail. Upgraded shipping is available for an extra cost. I only ship to United States ,Canada and select other countries. See shipping on item listing. All items will ship within 5 business days of received payment (special orders may take longer)Expect longer shipping times if you are outside the US. I will send tracking information when package is shipped out. After package has been delivered with a tracking number , I unfortunately am not responsible for lost or stolen goods.
Refunds and Exchanges
Refund or exchange will be accepted only in the case of damaged or broken item within 30 days. Buyer must contact me within 30 days and explain issue. Refunds or exchange will not be offered for any other reason. All plugs used in process are brand new and cannot be returned or exchanged for sanitary purposes. As most handmade items, the plugs are delicate. Please be gently with the jewelry :) I have tested all items for strength and will be happy to fix or send a replacement piece for anything broken.
Additional policies and FAQs
All items listed are specific to their size and design. If you see something you like that isn't in your size, please contact me through my store or sjaney77 [!at] I may be able to make a custom pair of plugs if I have the supplies available and the pieces coordinate correctly. I do not offer wholesale or consignment at the moment.