Quality Handcrafted Jewelry

386 Sales


Quality Handcrafted Jewelry

386 Sales On Etsy since 2009

5 out of 5 stars

Announcement   Welcome to my shop!
I strive to create timeless, custom, artisan jewelry that you'll enjoy for years to come. I hope you enjoy looking around.


Welcome to my shop!
I strive to create timeless, custom, artisan jewelry that you'll enjoy for years to come. I hope you enjoy looking around.

Sarah B Flanagan

Contact shop owner

Sarah B Flanagan

View all 25 items


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
View all 64 reviews


Lawyer Turned Jewelry Designer

I am a mom. A wife. A friend and sister. A loyal fan of a dog named Flynn. I am also a lawyer turned jewelry designer / creator. I gave up my downtown office for a cozy basement studio. My tailored suits and love of high heels were replaced with, well, let’s just say more comfortable attire. And while I used to spend my days putting out one fire after another, I now get to create things with it.

I want my daughter to know that dreams don’t have to wait until “someday.” So I turned my long-time hobby into my “real job.”

I make jewelry because I believe it’s the little things that make life grand. And because I’ve found I really do prefer playing with fire, rather than putting it out.

Around the web

Shop members

  • Sarah B Flanagan

    Owner, Maker, Designer

    I'm Sarah and I love creating & wearing handcrafted jewelry. I try to find inspiration in the everyday. Every day. And I hope a little of that inspiration comes out in the jewelry I create for you.

Shop policies

Last updated on September 6, 2014
Welcome to Sarah B Flanagan Handcrafted Jewelry. My goal is to create timeless jewelry that is simple, elegant and eye-catching. Everyday surroundings serve as my inspiration, and I try to capture in my designs those glimpses of momentary brilliance that stop me in my tracks. It is my hope that, when worn, each piece will make you feel a little brighter.

Accepted payment methods

  • Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
RETURNS: I want you to LOVE the jewelry you receive. I do my very best to give details about the size and materials of each piece, but I understand there is no substitution for seeing it in person. If you are unhappy with your purchase for any reason, please contact me directly WITHIN ONE WEEK of receipt (through Etsy convos, directly by email sarah [!at] or feel free to call 414.943.3526). Your satisfaction is very important to me and I will be happy to work with you and find a good resolution.

My formal return policy looks like this:
✭ Custom orders may not be returned unless I made a mistake in the jewelry's production.
✭ For all non-custom pieces, please contact me prior to shipping a return back to me. ✭ Returns are only accepted upon my approval.
✭ Returns must be shipped within 7 days from the date of receipt.
✭ Refunds will only be given if the jewelry is in its original, unworn condition and with its original packaging.
✭ Original shipping costs are non-refundable.
✭ The customer is responsible for all return shipping costs.

REPAIRS: I am happy to repair any jewelry that I have made. Estimates for repairs are handled on a case-by-case basis. PLEASE CONTACT ME PRIOR TO SHIPPING ANYTHING and we can discuss the best possible next steps.

Please note: My jewelry is not mass-produced and I buy small quantities of most of my materials. If replacement materials are needed for repairs, I will try to find an exact match if I do not have it in stock, but I cannot guarantee that I will be able to do so.
I accept all major credit cards through Etsy Direct Checkout. I also accept payment through PayPal (a secure online financial service). You are not required to have an account with PayPal to use it, just a credit card. If you need help with this process, please let me know.

WISCONSIN RESIDENTS: All WI residents will be charged sales tax on the amount of their total purchase (including shipping costs). No sales tax will be charged on orders outside the state of Wisconsin. Please let me know if you have any questions.
PLEASE confirm your shipping address. If you pay with a credit card through Etsy, I will ship to the address you provide. If you pay through PayPal, I ship to the address you provide through PayPal.


✭ I ship via USPS First Class with Delivery Confirmation. I will ship all orders within 3 days of receiving payment, unless stated otherwise. If you need expedited shipping, contact me and I will let you know what the additional shipping charges will be.

✭ Insurance is not included with shipping. However, if you would like insurance, please contact me before finalizing your order and I will add it to your total and send you a revised invoice.


✭ I ship USPS First Class International for most pieces. I reserve the right to charge additional shipping costs in order to ship Priority Mail International or Registered Mail when applicable based on your country's specific shipping restrictions. I will ALWAYS notify you of this prior to shipping and you may cancel your order at that time if you no longer want to pay those fees.

✭ Please be aware of any customs duties and / or fees you may incur before placing your order. THESE ARE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE BUYER. By law I am required to mark the shipment as MERCHANDISE. I will not mark it as a gift. I put the price paid on the customs form and include an invoice in the package. If you have any questions about this, your local post office / customs organization can advise you on this.

✭ Please understand that once I ship your package, I have no control over how long it takes. Delivery time can vary widely place to place due to customs. Typically, parcels are delivered within 3 weeks to most locations. However, there are instances when parcels get stuck in customs for longer. In addition, during holidays international shipping often takes longer than usual. I will always notify you when your package has shipped and will provide a tracking number when available (although please note that tracking is often not provided once outside of the US).
Additional policies and FAQs
HANDCRAFTED JEWELRY CARE & STORAGE: Handcrafted jewelry is wearable art. Some pieces require more care than mass-produced jewelry. I recommend that jewelry be stored in the box in which it was sent, or something comparable. This will help keep it shiny for longer and it will help protect it from damage. It is always best to put your jewelry on after applying lotions, makeup and hairspray- as these can all create a film on gemstones and silver. For polishing, I recommend using a jewelry polishing cloth. Please contact me with any questions on the care of your specific piece. I'm happy to help.

CUSTOM ORDERS: I love creating custom jewelry. More than that, I love the process of working with people to create jewelry that is perfect for them. The pieces that result from this process are often some of my favorite. Maybe you just want something in a different color or length. Maybe you want to create a design that compliments a specific outfit or that perfectly compliments you regardless of what you’re wearing or where you’re going. Or maybe you are looking for bridal jewelry for yourself and/or your wedding party. Whatever the situation is, your level of involvement in the design process is completely up to you.  The jewelry, and the experience, are customized to fit you and your style.

I look forward to working with you.

COLORS/SIZE/GEMSTONES: I take detailed photographs of each piece of jewelry. Please look through the photos and read the descriptions and sizing information. I try to portray the colors of my jewelry as accurately as possible. However, please note that colors may vary slightly with individual monitors. Contact me with any questions.



MAILING LIST: If you would like to be added to my mailing list, please email me at
sarah[at] "mailing list" in the subject line.

FACEBOOK: "Like" Sarah B Flanagan Handcrafted Jewelry on Facebook:

THANK YOU! This is what I love to do and my customers make it all possible.