Following shop Follow shop

schmaltzycraftsyjen

Schmaltzy Craftsy - Handcrafted Pincushions & Feltworks

Enon, Ohio
|
| 2,158 Sales | 5 out of 5 stars 5 out of 5 stars

schmaltzycraftsyjen is a Star Seller!

Smooth shipping

Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies

Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews

Average review rating is 4.8 or higher

Contact

Following shop Follow shop

Announcement    LONG SHIPPING TIMES: I am currently working in a 2-4 week turnaround on all pincushion orders as each is completely handmade by me alone. There can be an added delay if I get a glut of orders. There is less of a wait for bookplates and other items. On top of all this, USPS FIRST CLASS SHIPPING times are being slowed down.
** Some orders I can get out quicker depending on design, but if you have a deadline please contact me first to see if I can push it ahead.
___________________________________________

Schmaltzy Craftsy makes felt handmade pincushions of extraordinary awesomeness for the sewist in your life. The perfect gift for the crafter who thinks they have everything.

NEED IT FAST? The READY TO SHIP section or IN STOCK title will point you to pincushions that are actually in stock and can ship next day. All others: Current shipping window since everything is made to order is 14-21 days.

I SHIP USPS FIRST CLASS FOR FREE IN THE USA ONLY. I cannot offer Overnight mail, or free international shipping at this time, sorry. I DO remove a couple bucks off shipping for international orders (what US shipping typically costs me), but that's the best I can do. International shipping it too costly to absorb fully.

Announcement

Last updated on Apr 15, 2024

LONG SHIPPING TIMES: I am currently working in a 2-4 week turnaround on all pincushion orders as each is completely handmade by me alone. There can be an added delay if I get a glut of orders. There is less of a wait for bookplates and other items. On top of all this, USPS FIRST CLASS SHIPPING times are being slowed down.
** Some orders I can get out quicker depending on design, but if you have a deadline please contact me first to see if I can push it ahead.
___________________________________________

Schmaltzy Craftsy makes felt handmade pincushions of extraordinary awesomeness for the sewist in your life. The perfect gift for the crafter who thinks they have everything.

NEED IT FAST? The READY TO SHIP section or IN STOCK title will point you to pincushions that are actually in stock and can ship next day. All others: Current shipping window since everything is made to order is 14-21 days.

I SHIP USPS FIRST CLASS FOR FREE IN THE USA ONLY. I cannot offer Overnight mail, or free international shipping at this time, sorry. I DO remove a couple bucks off shipping for international orders (what US shipping typically costs me), but that's the best I can do. International shipping it too costly to absorb fully.

Request Custom Order
Contact shop owner
2158 Sales
1276 Admirers

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

All Items

Welsh flag Wales Men's Hawaiian bowling Shirt (AOP)

Welsh flag Wales Men's Hawaiian bowling Shirt (AOP)

$54.84

FREE shipping

I use protection Cotton Canvas Tote Bag I use protection sewing thimble sewist

I use protection Cotton Canvas Tote Bag I use protection sewing thimble sewist

$22.30

Made to Order - Floral Bouquet Large Bottlecap Pincushion - free usa ship

Made to Order - Floral Bouquet Large Bottlecap Pincushion - free usa ship

Sale Price $35.20

Original Price $44.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - The Original Eyeball Bottlecap Pincushion - choose S, M or L - free usa ship creepy witchy anatomical voodoo zombie gross

Made to order - The Original Eyeball Bottlecap Pincushion - choose S, M or L - free usa ship creepy witchy anatomical voodoo zombie gross

Sale Price $20.00

Original Price $25.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

FREE SHIP Ruler Bottlecap adjustable pincushion ring made to order

FREE SHIP Ruler Bottlecap adjustable pincushion ring made to order

Sale Price $16.80

Original Price $21.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - Cornflower Blue Floral Large Pedestal Pincushion

Made to order - Cornflower Blue Floral Large Pedestal Pincushion

Sale Price $44.00

Original Price $55.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to Order free us ship - Large Bottlecap Royal Crown

Made to Order free us ship - Large Bottlecap Royal Crown

Sale Price $48.80

Original Price $61.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

I'll Make your dream pincushion! Or a personalized one for someone! GREAT GIFT!

I'll Make your dream pincushion! Or a personalized one for someone! GREAT GIFT!

$1.00

FREE shipping

Made to order - Throughly Girly Tomato Pincushion free usa ship

Made to order - Throughly Girly Tomato Pincushion free usa ship

Sale Price $29.60

Original Price $37.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - Large Multicolor pincushion free usa ship

Made to order - Large Multicolor pincushion free usa ship

Sale Price $28.00

Original Price $35.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - 30 Personalized Custom floral garden book bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - Protect your library! free usa ship

Made to order - 30 Personalized Custom floral garden book bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - Protect your library! free usa ship

Sale Price $26.40

Original Price $33.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Tiny and Twee Tomato pincushion earrings - cute adorable miniature novelty unique sewist seamtress gift free US shipping

Tiny and Twee Tomato pincushion earrings - cute adorable miniature novelty unique sewist seamtress gift free US shipping

Sale Price $13.60

Original Price $17.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

MADE TO ORDER - English Countryside Large Bottlecap Pincushion free usa ship

MADE TO ORDER - English Countryside Large Bottlecap Pincushion free usa ship

Sale Price $57.60

Original Price $72.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

MADE TO ORDER - Large Round Amazing Paisley Pincushion

MADE TO ORDER - Large Round Amazing Paisley Pincushion

Sale Price $105.60

Original Price $132.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - 30 Personalized - Custom Midnight Reader Library bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive

Made to order - 30 Personalized - Custom Midnight Reader Library bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive

Sale Price $26.40

Original Price $33.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

MADE TO ORDER - Antique Mauve Floral Large Pedestal Pincushion free us shipping

MADE TO ORDER - Antique Mauve Floral Large Pedestal Pincushion free us shipping

Sale Price $38.40

Original Price $48.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - Beehive Bottlecap Pincushion - choose S, M or L - free usa ship

Made to order - Beehive Bottlecap Pincushion - choose S, M or L - free usa ship

Sale Price $25.60

Original Price $32.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - English Gardens Floral Large Pedestal Pincushion

Made to order - English Gardens Floral Large Pedestal Pincushion

Sale Price $57.60

Original Price $72.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - Lavender and Teal Charming Double Small Bottlecap pendant wearable chatelaine pincushion

Made to order - Lavender and Teal Charming Double Small Bottlecap pendant wearable chatelaine pincushion

Sale Price $28.00

Original Price $35.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - Groovy Hippie Medium Bottlecap Pincushion - free usa ship

Made to order - Groovy Hippie Medium Bottlecap Pincushion - free usa ship

Sale Price $52.80

Original Price $66.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - Summer daisies Floral Large Bottlecap Pincushion

Made to order - Summer daisies Floral Large Bottlecap Pincushion

Sale Price $41.60

Original Price $52.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - free us ship - Tangled Threads Large size bottlecap pincushion -

Made to order - free us ship - Tangled Threads Large size bottlecap pincushion -

Sale Price $50.40

Original Price $63.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - 30 Personalized - Custom Dragon's Treasure Library bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - 7 Dragon color choices

Made to order - 30 Personalized - Custom Dragon's Treasure Library bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - 7 Dragon color choices

$33.00

FREE shipping

Made to order - Scenic Rainbow and tree landscape Large bottlecap pincushion free us shipping

Made to order - Scenic Rainbow and tree landscape Large bottlecap pincushion free us shipping

Sale Price $48.80

Original Price $61.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made To Order free us ship - Scrolling Vines Medieval inspired floral Large size bottlecap pincushion your choice of colors

Made To Order free us ship - Scrolling Vines Medieval inspired floral Large size bottlecap pincushion your choice of colors

Sale Price $44.00

Original Price $55.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order Scrolling Vines Medieval inspired bottlecap pincushion - free ship

Made to order Scrolling Vines Medieval inspired bottlecap pincushion - free ship

Sale Price $28.00

Original Price $35.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Custom order - Charming Garden bottlecap Pincushion

Custom order - Charming Garden bottlecap Pincushion

Sale Price $22.40

Original Price $28.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Custom made to order - Boho Paisley Small Bottlecap pendant wearable chatelaine pincushion - free us ship

Custom made to order - Boho Paisley Small Bottlecap pendant wearable chatelaine pincushion - free us ship

Sale Price $29.60

Original Price $37.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

MADE TO ORDER - Ohio Star Quilt Pattern Large Bottlecap Pincushion free us ship

MADE TO ORDER - Ohio Star Quilt Pattern Large Bottlecap Pincushion free us ship

Sale Price $28.00

Original Price $35.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

IN STOCK free US ship - Hand Embroidered Ethnic Paisley Coffee Cup Cozy Sleeve sheath in Grey and Jewel Tones

IN STOCK free US ship - Hand Embroidered Ethnic Paisley Coffee Cup Cozy Sleeve sheath in Grey and Jewel Tones

Sale Price $25.60

Original Price $32.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

MADE TO ORDER- Hand Embroidered Ethnic Paisley Coffee Cup Cozy Sleeve sheath in your choice of colors free usa ship

MADE TO ORDER- Hand Embroidered Ethnic Paisley Coffee Cup Cozy Sleeve sheath in your choice of colors free usa ship

Sale Price $31.20

Original Price $39.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

MADE TO ORDER Rainbow Unicorn Large Bottlecap Pincushion - free usa ship

MADE TO ORDER Rainbow Unicorn Large Bottlecap Pincushion - free usa ship

Sale Price $52.80

Original Price $66.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - 30 Personalized Custom Poppies Art Nouveau bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - Protect your library! free usa ship

Made to order - 30 Personalized Custom Poppies Art Nouveau bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - Protect your library! free usa ship

Sale Price $26.40

Original Price $33.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - 30 Personalized Custom Poppies Art Nouveau bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - Protect your library! free usa ship

Made to order - 30 Personalized Custom Poppies Art Nouveau bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - Protect your library! free usa ship

Sale Price $26.40

Original Price $33.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to order - 30 Personalized -9 color choices- Custom Woodland bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - Protect your library! free usa ship

Made to order - 30 Personalized -9 color choices- Custom Woodland bookplate Ex Libris Sticker Adhesive - Protect your library! free usa ship

Sale Price $26.40

Original Price $33.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Made to Order - Floral Bouquet Large Bottlecap Pincushion - free usa ship

Made to Order - Floral Bouquet Large Bottlecap Pincushion - free usa ship

Sale Price $38.40

Original Price $48.00 (20% off)

FREE shipping

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Schmaltzy Craftsy

Contact shop owner

Schmaltzy Craftsy

Contact shop owner

Reviews

Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
(809)

About schmaltzycraftsyjen

Sales 2,158
On Etsy since 2007
  •  
  •  
  •  
  • Have an idea? Looking for a personalized option?
  •  

You wouldn't think pincushions needed such a long story

Shop members

  • Jen

    Owner, Maker, Designer

    Jen Segrest is a graphic and web designer in the Dayton, Ohio area. She's married and an unrepentant a Mac user with two cats and two dogs. She basically spends every waking moment online doing one thing or another while binging TV.

Shop policies

Last updated on Nov 7, 2022

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Digital downloads

Instant downloads
Your files will be available to download once payment is confirmed. Here's how.

Payment options

Secure options
Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: not accepted

Please contact the seller if you have any problems with your order.

Privacy policy

Seller details

View seller details

Captcha failed to load. Try using a different browser or disabling ad blockers.