From Depression Era Glassware to Mid Century Decor

Madison, Wisconsin · 544 Sales


From Depression Era Glassware to Mid Century Decor

Madison, Wisconsin 544 Sales On Etsy since 2011

5 out of 5 stars

Announcement   Vintage home & wedding decor, dishes, barware, holiday decorations, toys & party supplies!


Last updated on Nov 23, 2016

Vintage home & wedding decor, dishes, barware, holiday decorations, toys & party supplies!


Contact shop owner


View all 111 items


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars

thecooper1 on Mar 17, 2017

5 out of 5 stars

I purchased this vintage Solid Perfume bottle along with another item from SentimentalFavorites. It was my first purchase on Etsy. The bottle is much pettier than in photo. The quality and color is impressive; I am very pleased with my purchase. Not only is the jar pretty, it is obvious that the owner took great care of it. I have already filled the jar with my home-made solid perfume with vitamin A and E. My encounter with the shop owner was unbelievably pleasant. She wasn't pushy, she was helpful, professional, and accommodating. My delivery box arrived very quickly and the items was professionally packed with care. I usually don't purchase items online; it seem so impersonal. However, purchasing from SentimentalFavorites seemed like purchasing from a friend. I plan on purchasing from her again very soon.


thecooper1 on Mar 17, 2017

5 out of 5 stars

The Vintage Lipstick Organizer is Beautiful. It reminds of a piece my great-grandmother had and I admired as a child. I used to love placing her lipsticks in the slots and then gaze into the attached mirror imagining how I'd look in the lipstick. (Okay, sometimes I did try on a few colors when she wasn't looking.) I am very please with the quality and obvious upkeep of this precious piece I purchased from SentimentalFavorites. The package arrived quickly and I can't stop smiling when looking at it on my Victorian vanity table. This was my first transaction on Etsy, and the shop owner was an angel. She was professional and knowledgeable of her products. She was also pleasant, patient, and flexible. I usually don't like purchasing online because it seems so impersonal. Yet, this interaction felt like friends.

Hannah Vuong

Hannah Vuong on Mar 11, 2017

4 out of 5 stars

Mary is such a lovely seller, one the best I've ever dealt with in fact. The items were sent very quickly but unfortunately the tray's mirror arrived broken. Luckily Mary helped me file an insurance claim and I got my money back for said item. I'd definitely shop here again.

View all 197 reviews


Vintage Christmas decor galore!
Attention, treasure hunters! Deer season is officially open!
Check out these fresh finds for a holly, jolly mid century Christmas!
View all 9 updates


Grandma's Dishes

Antiques and vintage have always been part of my life, though growing up, I didn't really enjoy it. I see now that it was because my Mom rarely bought anything. She would go antiquing and just look! Obviously, I do not have that self control: I love to discover cool finds and buy them, whether for my own collections or to share with you via this Etsy shop.

I got the bug in the late '80s when my friend Sarah took me to my first auction, where I won a set of pink Depression glass bowls that reminded me of Grandma's dishes. I bought a book to research the pattern, and soon I was going to estate sales and auctions, finding lots of pretty glassware at bargain prices.

Inevitably, this led to antique mall booths and then ... this Etsy shop, named Sentimental Favorites for all the childhood memories sparked by its merchandise.

I hope the items assembled here spark something in you too! If you don't see your personal Sentimental Favorites, be sure to ask. I'd be happy to add them to my treasure-hunting wish list.


Shop members

  • Sentimental Favorites

    Owner, Chief Treasure Hunter

Shop policies

Last updated on April 3, 2016
Thanks so much for checking out my shop! I'll be posting NEW items all the time.
So keep checking back in with me and tell your friends!

Accepted payment methods

  • Pay with Visa
  • Pay with Master Card
  • Pay with American Express
  • Pay with Discover
  • Pay with PayPal
  • Buy with Apple Pay
  • Pay with Sofort
  • Pay with iDeal
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards
  • Money Order
I accept credit cards, PayPal, money orders.
I ship orders in 1-3 business days, usually 1.

Domestic shipping is via U.S. Postal Service, Priority, unless otherwise specified. International is USPS First Class unless otherwise specified. Certain larger items go UPS or FedEx ground.

Please let me know if you prefer a speedier method.

I gladly ship internationally, though the size and weight of some items make it prohibitively expensive. If you don't see international rates or would like a specific quote for your country, just let me know what item(s) and I'll adjust destination and rates.

If I overestimate shipping, you will be refunded excess greater than $1.

Buyer is responsible for any duties/customs charges.
Refunds and Exchanges
I will do my best to identify and describe each item and its condition. We are also careful shippers! However, if I mistakenly misrepresent a piece, or you are unhappy with its condition, please contact me to discuss a return.
Additional policies and FAQs
Please convo me with any questions about items (condition or more pictures, etc.) or to inquire about additional or related pieces available.