Shirts By Sarah - Novelty T-Shirts For Any Occasion

Pennellville, New York
51,550 Sales | 5 out of 5 stars

Buyers are raving!

This shop got multiple 5-star reviews in the past 7 days.

Announcement    Please remember to favorite our shop so you're up to date on all new designs!


Last updated on Aug 20, 2021

Please remember to favorite our shop so you're up to date on all new designs!


51550 Sales

All Items

Sarah Eldred

Contact shop owner

Sarah Eldred


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
Quality 1602 Shipping 1768 Customer service 769

About ShirtsBySarah

Sales 51,550
On Etsy since 2013

Small Town, Small Business

Shirts By Sarah is a small family owned business in a small upstate NY town. Feel good about your purchase! You're helping support small business and rural community. I started printing t-shirts in 2012 and have been loving it ever since. In 2014, my husband left his day job and joined me in the shop.
We do all of our own printing in house which means your order receives the attention to detail it deserves. Each order is printed by either my husband or myself and carefully packaged in a cotton drawstring bag. Your item is ready to gift when you receive it. We use exclusive designs that are done by myself as well as work with other artists to bring you a diverse selection of awesome t shirt designs.
Customer satisfaction has been and always will be our #1 priority. If for any reason you are not satisfied with your purchase, contact me. Returns are always no questions asked and hassle free. I understand you work hard for your money just like we do, and I don't ever want any customer to feel that they didn't get a great value for the price paid for one of our products. We understand that shopping for clothing online can be a challenge. If your item doesn't fit, just let us know, we'd be happy to take the return for you.
It is absolutely amazing how a t-shirt can change someone's day. We love seeing all the photos customers send us. If you're up to it, be sure to tag us on Instagram!

Shop members

  • Sarah Eldred

    Customer Service, Owner, Marketer, Designer

    Hey guys! Thanks so much for stopping by. I started this company in 2012 after battling a long illness that prevented me from working outside the home. It's really grown over the years and now my husband, Rick works full time in the shop with me.

  • Rick

    Creator, Customer Service, Shipper

    My husband Rick who helps with everything and all things Shirts By Sarah.

Shop policies

Last updated on November 19, 2020
Thanks for checking us out! We are a family owned and operated store specializing in shirts, creepers, hoodies, bags, totes, and more!

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept returns
Contact me within: 14 days of delivery
Ship items back within: 30 days of delivery
I don't accept exchanges or cancellations
But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.
The following items can't be returned or exchanged
Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:
  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Perishable products (like food or flowers)
  • Digital downloads
  • Intimate items (for health/hygiene reasons)
  • Items on sale
Returns and exchange details
I want you to be 100% satisfied with your purchase! If you are unhappy with your item(s) please contact me to return it. We accept returns within 30 days of receipt. We refund all items upon return. If you need a different size or color, please repurchase the item you need as we do not offer exchanges at this time.

Items must be returned in new condition with all tags attached and with our cotton garment bags. Items not returned in new condition or missing bags will be subject to restocking fees. We reserve the right to refuse returns on garments that have been worn or are missing tags.

Personalized items - items that have been printed with custom requests, names, etc.
We currently accept etsy checkout.
Orders typically ship the following business day. This can be slightly delayed by 2-3 days during busy holiday times. All of our items include free standard shipping via the USPS postal system. Most customers will receive their item(s) within 5-7 mailing days of purchase.

Priority mail upgrade is available on all of our items. Priority mail is 2-3 day transit time with 1-2 business day handling/processing time. If you need something in a flash, please contact me prior to purchase. Express shipping is available on some items - please see listings for details.
Please note that transit times DO NOT include time to process your order.

International shipping is available. Except where required, VAT and import taxes are the purchasers responsibility. We are not responsible for paying VAT tax. We do not hide values or mark items as gifts. Please consider prior to purchase.
Additional policies and FAQs
If you have ANY issues with your order please contact me, I will make it right. Shirts By Sarah has a great reputation and I intend on keeping it that way! I will ALWAYS work with you to correct any issues with your order. Feel free to contact me via text or email! 315-546-4190 or sarah [!at]

More information

Last updated on May 8, 2018
Frequently asked questions
Do You Do Custom Orders?

Yes! We do. All of our printing is done in house and we can accommodate custom requests. We offer full color, direct to garment printing services. Please contact me for details.

Do You Print With Vinyl Or Decals?

No, we do not. 99% of our items are direct to garment printed right here in our facility in Update NY. Some of our more popular designs are screen printed.

Do You Accept Returns Or Exchanges?

We want you to be 100% satisfied with your purchase. Returns are always no questions asked, hassle free. We refund all items upon return. You may then repurchase a different size and color if you wish to do so. This is how we handle all exchanges and returns. We apologize if this is inconvenient, but this is the fastest, most efficient way to get an exchange as your purchase creates an open order within our system.

Do You Print Your Own Orders?

Yes! All of our items are printed right at our facility in Upstate NY. We are a small, family owned and operated business, so you can rest assured your order is given the attention to detail it deserves.

Sizing details

Sizing information is listed on each listing. Click 'More Details' and scroll down to see the sizing for each style we carry.

I Like A Design But Don't See The Style I Want

Contact us!! We can print any of our designs on any style we carry except tote bags. If you require a style we do not carry, such as an extra long tee or pocket tee, we would be happy to order that for you. Please contact us prior to purchase so that we may provide a quote as well as create a custom listing for you.

How Long Does Shipping Take?

We try to ship all orders the following business day. In many cases, we can get items out same day if the order is placed before 12pm EST. During busy holiday seasons such as Christmas, shipping can be slightly delayed by 2-3 days. If you need something in a flash, please contact me prior to purchase.