Sincere Costumes

Chicago, Illinois

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

Announcement    Fun, Unique, and Affordable Costumes and Gifts:
Nothing but sincerity as far as the eye can see!

Sincere Costumes is proud to provide quality products, fast shipping, and great customer service.


Last updated on Aug 14, 2017

Fun, Unique, and Affordable Costumes and Gifts:
Nothing but sincerity as far as the eye can see!

Sincere Costumes is proud to provide quality products, fast shipping, and great customer service.


No items listed at this time
Tara Schile

Contact shop owner

Tara Schile


No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:
Quality 12 Shipping 28 Customer service 23

Shop policies

Last updated on October 4, 2013
Welcome to SINCERE COSTUMES! I strive to create fun, unique, and awesome costumes for every age, every size, & every personality. Every piece is made with care and consideration... and sincerity!

As these are costumes to be worn on special occasions, there are NO returns or refunds except for extenuating circumstances worked out with Sincere's owner and creator, Tara Schile, personally. Thank you for your understanding!

Enjoy perusing Sincere Costumes, and remember, these are unique pieces; if you find one you love, it may not be there tomorrow, so act fast! Custom work also available---just send me a message!

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
There are NO refunds or exchanges except in extenuating circumstances, including: garment lost in shipping, garment or accessory arriving broken, death or natural disaster, or a few other severe cases. In ANY case, details must be worked out with Sincere Costumes' owner, Tara Schile.

Costumes are sold AS IS. Modifications and alterations will require a discussion and possibly a small additional fee.

Orders that need to be canceled must go through Sincere Costumes before the item has shipped. Once shipped, there are no refunds or exchanges unless otherwise worked out with Tara Schile. A cancellation must have a really good reason for it and Sincere Costumes must be notified before payment has processed and the costume has shipped.
PayPal is the recommended method of payment, but check or money order is acceptable in certain cases worked out with Sincere's owner, Tara J. Schile. Costumes will not be sent out until payment is received in full.

Taxes are included in the pricing, but shipping is additional, as the shipping cost varies on the weight of the costume.
Shipping is done through USPS. If you need an upgrade from regular priority or ground shipping for speed, there will be a small additional charge. Delivery Confirmation will be included in order to be sure your costume is received and intact upon delivery.

Costumes come packaged with care, in most cases wrapped in tissue paper, in a padded envelope or box.

In the case of international shipping, cost of shipping and customs fees are built into the shipping price. International order delivery times cannot be guaranteed as the Customs process is out of my control entirely.

Custom or made-to-order pieces will ship as soon as they are completed, the customer receiving updates of the progress. Custom pieces are expected to be paid in full before created, and will be completed promptly after receiving payment.

Orders placed too close to a holiday deadline will be declined except in extenuating circumstances, as shipping will be unavailable.
Additional policies and FAQs
Sincere Costumes and Tara Schile are not responsible for what the buyer does with the costume after purchase. Costumes are to be worn by humans unless otherwise specified and are not edible, nor are they good life rafts, parachutes, weapons, or shields. They are not fire proof, water proof, natural-disaster proof, or otherwise completely indestructible. All that being said, take care of your costume and it might win you prizes in costume contests, one never knows!

The Sincere Costumes workshop is smoke-free, but pet friendly. The costumes will be checked for pet hair before leaving the shop, but a rogue stray hair may accompany the occasional garment. If you have a severe pet allergy, please be careful when handling the outside of the garment.

By purchasing this item, you acknowledge you've been notified of the above things.

Sincere Costumes has a penchant for taking garments like bridesmaids dresses and turning them into fantastic costumes. If you would like to donate a garment or have Tara re-work one for you, or for any other questions or concerns, contact her at MrsTaraSchile [!at]