
Announcement
We specialize in decorated sugar cookies. Our cookies are hand rolled, baked and frosted to order so they are absolutely fresh when you receive them. Each and every cookie is made from scratch in our bakery.
If there is a particular shape you're looking for but you don't see it here, please contact us. We are constantly getting new cutters, or we can make a custom shape just for you.
When contacting us, please be as specific as possible with your request. The more details you can provide up front (event date, quantity of cookies needed, and zip code), the less conversations back and forth we have to have.
We have an edible image printer. Looking to do a corporate logo on cookies? We can do that!
ARE YOU IN THE MILWAUKEE AREA? Please come visit us at our retail shop in the Village of Greendale, just 15 minutes south of downtown Milwaukee. We're open Tuesday - Friday 8-3, Saturdays 8-3. 414.421.5565
Announcement
We specialize in decorated sugar cookies. Our cookies are hand rolled, baked and frosted to order so they are absolutely fresh when you receive them. Each and every cookie is made from scratch in our bakery.
If there is a particular shape you're looking for but you don't see it here, please contact us. We are constantly getting new cutters, or we can make a custom shape just for you.
When contacting us, please be as specific as possible with your request. The more details you can provide up front (event date, quantity of cookies needed, and zip code), the less conversations back and forth we have to have.
We have an edible image printer. Looking to do a corporate logo on cookies? We can do that!
ARE YOU IN THE MILWAUKEE AREA? Please come visit us at our retail shop in the Village of Greendale, just 15 minutes south of downtown Milwaukee. We're open Tuesday - Friday 8-3, Saturdays 8-3. 414.421.5565
Items
All Items
Reviews
-
DOREEN on Feb 21, 2021
5 out of 5 starsThese cookies are so buttery. I’ve ordered from this seller four times. Everything I’ve purchased has been delicious!!!
-
-
sallysilver1 on Feb 16, 2021
5 out of 5 starsThese are delightful little cookies -- quite delicious! They arrived promptly and my experience communicating with the seller was excellent.
-
-
Beth Clothier on Mar 4, 2021
5 out of 5 starsPerfect gift for my friend and her family. Thanks so much for the cute cookies and quick shipping. :)
-
-
Jenna on Feb 27, 2021
5 out of 5 starsShe worked with me to get exactly what I wanted - a custom made gift for my exotic vet!! They loved it.
-
Kimberly on Feb 24, 2021
5 out of 5 starsI love these so good. I had to cut back on sweets and these are perfect. I have one to curb my sugar craving vs. A whole cookie. These are hands down the best frosted sugar cookies I ever had. I have bought gourmet cookies and these are so much better. Will definitely order again. Also, there were no cookies that were broken.
-
-
Shop policies
****Our facility processes foods that contain wheat, eggs, soy, nuts (including peanuts), chocolate and seeds.
Accepted payment methods
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept cancellations
I don't accept returns or exchanges
Returns and exchange details
In the event that we've somehow made an error with your cookies (colors etc), it is only the cookies affected that will be discounted/refunded. The remaining cookies will not be discounted or refunded.
A NOTE ABOUT COLOR BLEEDING: Please know that very dark colors have a tendency to bleed. While there's no way to prevent this, we do our best to minimize it. Cookies with a normal amount of bleeding will NOT be discounted. This includes "shadowing" of polka dots and darkening of monograms.
A BROKEN COOKIE is a cookie that has been broken into two or more pieces. Cracks in the frosting or minor chipping of the cookie is not considered to be a broken cookie. We do not offer refunds or adjustments for cracks or chipping.
Having said all this, PLEASE CONTACT US IF THERE IS A PROBLEM so we can talk. We're nice people and understand sometimes things go awry.
If you are ordering favors for a special event, perhaps you may want to consider ordering a few extra just in case.
Because of the perishability of our cookies we do not accept returns. Returning cookies or refusing delivery will not facilitate a refund.
Payment
Shipping
We will ship your order USPS Priority Mail (2-3 business days transit) within 2-6 business days of your order being placed and paid for, unless otherwise requested during checkout. If you need your cookies for a specific date, this MUST be made known during checkout. We do not refer back to previous conversations to see when an event date is.
Priority Mail is NOT a guarantee of delivery within 2-3 business days, rather it is an "expected time frame". USPS only guarantees delivery with their overnight service. If you'd like expedited shipping, please message us for a quote.
THE CORRECT ADDRESS MUST BE ENTERED INTO THE SHIPPING FIELD ON THE ETSY ORDER FORM. This is the address we will default to. Putting the correct address in the "note to seller" section will NOT guarantee that your box will be delivered there. We do our best to double check before shipping but putting the address in the correct spot will ensure it gets sent to the right address.
Are you local? Pickup is always a great option. Feel free to message us with any questions. Our bakery is open Tues-Fri 8-5 and Saturdays 8-4.
We are not responsible for shipping delays caused by USPS, incorrect address information, weather or disaster conditions, or for charges incurred for redelivery attempts and/or incorrect address information. WE WILL SHIP TO THE ADDRESS SPECIFIED IN THE SHIPPING FIELD ON THE ETSY ORDER FORM. PLEASE DO NOT CONVO YOUR SHIPPING ADDRESS SEPARATELY - IT MAY NOT MAKE IT ONTO YOUR ORDER. Please make it extremely clear where your box is to be shipped to. Refunds are not available for the cost of cookies or shipping charges if any of these circumstances occur.
We generally ship "special occasion" cookies to arrive 2 days prior to an event unless other arrangements have been made.
Shipping is NOT refundable.
Excess shipping charges are refunded at time of shipping.
Additional policies and FAQs
Once received, store your cookies at room temperature away from direct sunlight. Your cookies will stay fresh, if kept covered, for around 2 weeks. You can also freeze your cookies for longer term storage - at least a month. Thaw at room temp. in closed original packaging. Do not refrigerate. Some discoloration may occur after freezing.
We can prepare your order to custom specifications. Color, shapes, and variety are all your choice!
CANCELLATION OF PARTY FAVOR COOKIES MUST BE MADE 10 DAYS PRIOR TO EVENT DATE IN ORDER TO RECEIVE REFUND.