TheCookieBugShop
Top shop for gifts.
Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!
TheCookieBugShop is taking a short break
Reviews
-
![]()
-
![]()
-
![]()
ntburton1 on Dec 12, 2020
5 out of 5 starsOh my god these cookies are gorgeous! I placed a custom order for 1 dozen cookies with goats on them and they delivered hard! They are beautiful. All arrived individually packed and are delicious. They were perfect. Thanks so much!
-
![]()
Danielle on Dec 8, 2020
5 out of 5 stars100 stars for gorgeous looking cookies that also tasted fantastic! Will order again for sure.
-
![]()
Janessa on Nov 7, 2020
5 out of 5 starsNinjago cookies are perfect for my sons 5th birthday. Even one personalized with his name. I’ll try to add a photo from the party later. Safely waiting in fridge for the big day. I would buy these again.
-
![]()
Katharine on Oct 29, 2020
5 out of 5 starsAmazing Masters Tournament themed cookies for my sons first birthday! Quick shipping, arrived safely!
-
![]()
Tammy on Oct 18, 2020
5 out of 5 starsThe day I dread was approaching and my husband said (knowing that I have a major sweet tooth) to pick out what I wanted for my birthday. And I immediately reached out to Malissa. I've been obsessed with Animal Crossing and sent her a few pictures of my character and a few of my favorite villagers and OMG she knocked it out of the park. I opened the box and yes. I cried. :) They were AMAZING! She made my birthday so special and happy, I didn't want to eat them they were so cute. But I totally did because they were too yummy not to. I couldn't resist. I'll be back. Getting in line for holiday gifts for friends! Thank you so much for making a day I dread super special. :)
-
![]()
Kaylee on Oct 8, 2020
5 out of 5 starsbeyond satisfied with my purchase! cookies came SUPER quick, and the seller was so communicative. I love the personalization and how customizable they are. i will always buy my cookies from here ♥️
-
![]()
Megan on Sep 26, 2020
5 out of 5 starsMy husband loved these cookies! They were so well packaged for both freshness and to eliminate breakage. All the cookies arrived in perfect shape! Thank you so much!
-
![]()
Tammy on Sep 10, 2020
5 out of 5 starsEtsy should really allow for more stars. :) The exceptionally yummy cookies absolutely made the birthday special. My husband took pictures of his Gundam cookies and sent them to friends and family. I think this was the best birthday ever. Thank you so much for working with me and my weird request and making it turn out WAY better than I could have ever expected. I'll be back for sure!
About TheCookieBugShop
Custom Cookies
We are a custom, boutique bakery specializing in delicious handmade cookies. Each cookie is made from the finest ingredients, all products purchased from our local merchants whenever possible.
Cookies are made to order at the time of your purchase to ensure freshness. We begin with prepping, baking then cooling. Decorating is next and drying times vary. Color customization is available. Your cookies will be carefully packed and shipped via USPS Priority Mail to ensure the safest possible delivery.
Thank you for choosing the Cookie Bug.
Shop members
-
Malissa Sanfilippo
Owner, Designer, Maker
The CookieBug was launched in 2010 by Malissa Sanfilippo, a graduate of the University of Southern California in Fine Art. Malissa then decided to combine her passion for art with her love of baking and her career as a cake and cookie decorator began
Shop policies
Shipping
Payment options
Returns & exchanges
I don't accept returns, exchanges, or cancellations
I accept returns I do not accept returns
I accept exchanges I do not accept exchanges
I accept cancellations I do not accept cancellations
Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:
Privacy policy
More information
Frequently asked questions
Sizing details
Regular cookies are 3-4" in size. Mini's are 2-3".
Care instructions
Cookies should be eaten within 10 days. If you need them to last longer, please put them in the freezer for use within 3 months. Let them thaw fully before you eat them.
Gift wrapping and packaging
Cookies come individually wrapped in heat sealed cello wrap, then they are bubble wrapped for shipping. We then place them in a baker's box with tissue, wrap the box with a bow, then put that box into a shipping box with air pillows. Breakage is rare but if you receive broken cookies, you may file a claim with the carrier.
Wholesale availability
For wholesale availability, please call the shop manager Maria at 619-455-5594 or email malissa@thecookiebug.net
Custom Cookies
All of our cookies are custom made. We begin making them when you order. The pictures you see on our Etsy shop are some examples. Please let us know what you would like, your theme and ideas. Pictures are welcome. Thank you!
Gift wrapping and packaging
Since each order is custom made we do not begin working on them until the order is placed. From that point, there is a process of baking, cooling, painting and drying. This process can take awhile depending upon how many colors are going into your cookies. For this reason we tell our customers that processing time before shipping can take up to 7-14 days. If you need your cookies sooner, give us a call (619-455-5594 or malissa@thecookiebug.net) and we will try and get them out when you need them. Thank you for your understanding.