Illustrated cards, stationery, gift wrap and fun things

Berkeley, California

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

ThePaperPonyCo is taking a short break


Note from shop owner The Paper Pony fam is on a break. We'll be checking messages during this time so please get in touch if you have a question.

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Jun 6, 2021

The Paper Pony fam is on a break. We'll be checking messages during this time so please get in touch if you have a question.

Talia Gavish

Contact shop owner

Talia Gavish


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
See reviews that mention:
Quality 123 Shipping 133 Customer service 28

About ThePaperPonyCo

Sales 4,237
On Etsy since 2015

Adorably Moody Gifts & Goods

Paper Pony Co. is a line of illustrated goods made by Talia E. Gavish. Our style is inspired by the temperament of a pony: cute, whimsical, and packed with attitude! Sustainability, transparency, and mindful customer service are important values of our brand.

Our paper products are printed on FSC certified, recycled paper. We are committed to resourcing local manufacturers who uphold our standards of quality and ethics. If a product cannot be manufactured locally, we do our homework and only partner with companies who are safe, ethical, and ecological.

Most of our products are handmade or hand printed. We take pride in our craftsmanship and painstakingly choose our materials. Details are everything. We were honored and excited to be chosen as one of 36 brands to attend Etsy Open Call 2016, where we had an opportunity to pitch our line to major retailers. We have so many plans for Paper Pony's future but for now we are galloping as fast as our little legs can carry us! Your support is beyond appreciated!

Shop members

  • Talia

    Owner, Creator, Designer

    I was a designer in the NYC fashion industry before moving to the Bay Area. Working out the small details of my brand excites me, as does interacting with fellow creativepreneurs and crafters in the Etsy community.

Production partners

  • Enamel Pin Manufacturer

    Shenzhen, China

    I carefully chose this partnership for their quality manufacturing and humane working conditions. I work with them closely to produce my original designs. Each product is then inspected and hand packaged by me before shipping out to you.

  • Letterpress Shop

    CA, United States

    I partner with a small printing press for all our letterpress paper goods. I inspect and hand package each product before shipping it out to you.

  • Professional Printer

    CA, United States

    I work with an eco-friendly, local printing press for large scale products that my in-house inkjet can't handle. I inspect every product before sending it out and hand package each one myself.

Shop policies

More information

Last updated on Apr 12, 2020
Frequently asked questions
Wholesale availability

Please fill out our wholesale application if you are interested in carrying Paper Pony in your store. Consignment and drop-shipping is not available.

Gift wrapping and packaging

We do not offer gift wrapping however all orders are hand packaged with great care and aesthetic consideration. You can mark an item as a gift and write a message for the recipient which will be included on the packing slip. We never include invoices with orders.

We cannot write messages inside cards, so please do not include one in your check out notes!

Wrong Mailing Address

If there is an error in your shipping address, please contact us within 24 hours of your order with the correct information. We are no longer able to make changes to your order once it has shipped.

Customers are responsible for providing Paper Pony Co. with their correct shipping address. Please make sure all addresses are correct, we will not refund for wrong address on your part. If a package is returned or rejected, the customer will be contacted and will be required to pay for re-shipment postage.

Lost Packages After Delivery

Paper Pony Co. cannot be held responsible / liable for lost or stolen packages that have delivery confirmation to the address that was provided. The customer accepts full responsibility to file any claim(s) with carrier for damaged and/or lost shipments.

Please make sure your drop-off mail location is secure and the shipping address you've provided is correct. You will receive a confirmation email with a tracking number once your order has shipped.

If your package is insured, a claim for refund can be filed with the USPS. Please upgrade to Priority or Express Mail delivery if you would like your package insured.

How long does shipping take?

All orders ship USPS from California (Pacific Time Zone.) Domestic orders take 3-5 business days, International 10-14 business days. This is AFTER your order is processed - which can take anywhere from 1-3 business days. If you need your order to arrive faster, please purchase Priority Mail (1-3 days) or Express Mail (1 day) at checkout. Paper Pony cannot guarantee shipping dates.

Custom and personalized orders

We are unable to make custom or personalized orders. All artwork is as is. We will not be able to modify it for you. Please note there are no exceptions to this!!