Unique Catholic and custom gifts

3709 Sales


Unique Catholic and custom gifts

3709 Sales On Etsy since 2011

5 out of 5 stars

Shop owner




Contact shop owner


View all 29 items


Average item review
5 out of 5 stars
Amber Livingston

Amber Livingston on May 7, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

Amazing yet again! One of my necklaces broke ( totally my fault) and she let me reorder the piece I needed even while her shop was closed. Andrea went above and beyond for me! Will definitely keep ordering from her!

Jenna Crown

Jenna Crown on May 7, 2018

5 out of 5 stars

Always the best product and fast shipping. This is my fourth time purchasing from here and I have never been disappointed. It’s always the most special gift at the party.

View all 982 reviews


Affordable and Beautiful Catholic Items, personal and meaningful gifts

I have been making jewelry as a hobby for many years. My sister-in-law was the one who told me about Etsy. When I was in the market for a Sacred Heart of Jesus necklace, I noticed all kinds of supplies for making such a necklace. I had been interested in buying one, but I realized that I could start making Catholic jewelry to sell on Etsy. I quickly realized that I could buy almost all of my supplies here too! Eureka! And so it began. I opened my Etsy store in September of 2011.
I hope that the items I make, either personalized custom items like keychains and cufflinks, or Catholic items like rosary cases, bring people happiness, and are long lasting and reasonably priced.
My store has now also begun to bring financial support to my family. I am a stay at home (homeschooling) mom. My Etsy store has made it easier to support our family. It has also given me a way to express my faith.
Thank you so much for your visit here! Peace, Andrea

Around the web

Shop members

  • Andrea

    Owner, Maker, Designer

    I am a stay-at-home, homeschooling, mother of six. It is a wonderful job that I am privileged to have. Everyday is different and I get a front row seat to life's sweeping sagas: for there is nothing small with kids except onesies. : )

Shop policies

Last updated on January 9, 2015
Thank you for visiting Two Hearted Ranch! I love to hear from my customers! Please send all communication through the store using the contact shop owner buttons. This ensures that I will receive your message.

Accepted payment methods

  • Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept returns, exchanges, and cancellations
Contact me within: 14 days of delivery
Ship items back within: 30 days of delivery
Request a cancellation: before item has shipped
The following items can't be returned or exchanged
Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:
  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Perishable products (like food or flowers)
  • Digital downloads
  • Intimate items (for health/hygiene reasons)
Questions about your order?
Please if you have any problems with your order.
I want you to be pleased with your order and with your dealings with my shop.
Please contact me with any question or complaint. I truly want my customers to be happy and I will work on a case by case basis to ensure this.

If an item arrives damaged, please contact me through the store so we can try to work something out. If the damage is a result of shipping, refund or replacement is usually possible. Please also send me a photo of the damage.

Items that are incorrect or defective will be replaced or fully refunded. If you change your mind about an item, it can be refunded within 5 days of delivery. Customer will be responsible for all shipping charges, and refund will be withheld until item is received back in purchased condition.

I cannot offer refunds or exchanges on custom items, unless it is defective.

Please contact me with any question or complaint. I truly want my customers to be happy and I will work on a case by case basis to ensure this.
I accept these forms of payment: credit card (through Etsy's Direct Checkout) and credit card (through PayPal).

Orders ship within 3 business days. In case a complication arises, I will send you a message, at which point you can choose to cancel your order, or wait until I can resolve the issue.


For custom made items, such as photo necklaces or children's art projects, I ask for 5 business days, although most can be shipped within 3 business days.

****Please note that custom projects require more communication between the customer and myself. If you do not respond to questions or concerns that I have, it may also delay the processing of your order.****


I cannot be responsible for items that are lost or damaged in the mail. I do my best to package things securely so they are safe, but if you want to purchase insurance for your items (only $.80 for up to $100 worth of merchandise), send me a convo through the store, and I can add it to your bill. Every order ships with a tracking number for your protection. In the event that an item arrives and is damaged, please contact me through the store and we will work something out. I truly want my customers to be happy and I will work on a case by case basis to ensure this.


International orders are welcome! I do not have international shipping listed. Please contact me through the store with your postal code and city name and I will send a shipping quote. As far as I know, international shipping does not have a tracking number.
Additional policies and FAQs
I do my best to provide my customers with high quality, beautifully made items. Please send me a message through the store if you have any questions or concerns.

I do not include a receipt with the packages, in order to conserve paper, and also to keep my prices lower. You will receive a receipt via email. Thank you!

If you'd like a gift note for no charge, just leave the message in the message to seller box. Thanks!

Thank you so much for visiting Two Hearted Ranch!