unrepeatables. hand painted. nail polish. jewelry.

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

Unrepeatables is taking a short break


Note from shop owner Hello Sparkly Beauties! I'm away from my studio right now and can't wait to get back to work. In the meantime stay safe and think glittery thoughts.

See you soon!

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Apr 24, 2020

Hello Sparkly Beauties! I'm away from my studio right now and can't wait to get back to work. In the meantime stay safe and think glittery thoughts.

See you soon!

Erin Sheehy-Norton

Contact shop owner

Erin Sheehy-Norton


No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:
Quality 5 Shipping 15 Customer service 9

About Unrepeatables

Sales 152
On Etsy since 2010

Something, something, nail polish.

Nearly a dozen years of jewelry design history would be boring for you to read in story form so I'll cover the bullet points:

theater degree
prop and set designer
until: two babies under age 2
at-home-mom gets restless
jewelry catalog ordered
five million beads later
2010 365 day jewelry project
bead burn-out

nail polish addiction

and so here we are now, where to keep myself in nail polish (I'm at 500+ bottles now!) I came up with a way to use it in jewelry. I'm not the only one, but my very unique style comes through loud and clear, you won't mistake me for any other jewelry with nail polish maker.

I am inspired by the colors I use and the women who wear my work, each piece and each wearer is 100% unrepeatable.

Shop members

  • Erin Sheehy-Norton

    Owner, Maker, Designer, Chief Cook And Bottle Washer.

    Theater, travel and music. Color, texture and art. Two fantastic children, one amazing husband, one really great dog, one rambunctious puppy. Nail polish, jewelry, drinks made with champagne. These are a few of my favorite things.

Shop policies

Last updated on February 9, 2013
Every piece is made one at a time, by hand and no two are ever going to be the same. (hence "unrepeatables") if you see something you *love*, you should get it because once it's gone- it's gone! If you missed out on a piece or have found something in the SOLD section that you like, let me know, I might be able to do something similar, but I might not- so don't be mad!

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
I create this jewelry to make women feel a little more sparkly, if your piece doesn't wow you, you can send it back within a reasonable amount of time (30 days) and I'll refund your payment in the form in which you sent it.
Unrepeatables accepts Paypal, checks and money orders. If your check is returned you will incur many fees, so- don't do that, I'm pretty relaxed as far as deadlines are concerned but if you commit to purchase an item let me know within 24 hours how you're paying for it. Payment will be expected within 7-10 days or the item will be relisted. If you're having difficulty paying- let me know, if it's a technical PayPal thing there is probably something I can do! If it's a bank account thing, then I know to be patient!
Packages shipped within the United States will all go first class with delivery confirmation. I will ship anywhere in the world, so just let me know where it's going and I'll send you a shipping quote! If you'd like your item faster, I can upgrade you to Priority for an additional fee, just let me know at time of purchase.

oh, and I won't ship until the check clears- providing you've paid by check. This can take up to 7 days, so if you want it fast (and who doesn't?) Paypal is the way to go!
Additional policies and FAQs
Add Unrepeatables to your favorites list and check back regularly because we will be adding pieces all the time!! My goal is to make you happy so that you'll come back, and tell your friends, and spread the sparkly, Unrepeatables, love!