Dog ID Tags Handmade Polymer Clay Pet Tags Cat Tags

Damascus, Maryland

Top shop for gifts.

Buyers bought gifts from this shop and gave them 5-star reviews!

whatthepup is taking a short break


Note from shop owner The shop is on vacation temporarily.

Note from shop owner

Last updated on Aug 25, 2014

The shop is on vacation temporarily.

Kristen Rabs

Contact shop owner

Kristen Rabs


No reviews in the last year
See reviews that mention:
Quality 3 Shipping 12 Customer service 10

About whatthepup

Sales 268
On Etsy since 2011

What the Mutt Happened?!

I am a web designer by day so I needed a creative outlet actually using my hands. After working at a bakery, I found that I loved making the 3D characters out of fondant.

My love of animals is one of my biggest priorities. So I thought, how can I combinf this passion with the enjoyment of sculpting?

What the Mutt?! Dog tags was perfect!

Shop members

  • Kristen Rabs


Shop policies

Last updated on December 11, 2013

Accepted payment methods

Paypal Mastercard Visa American Express Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Returns and exchanges
We want to ensure that every customer is 100% satisfied! If for any reason you are not satisfied with your tag, please e-mail us at contact [!at] wtpup.com within 7 days of receiving your order so we can work with you to resolve the situation. Items must be returned in the same condition as received within 30 days of receipt. Your order will be refunded when we receive the tag. We do not reimburse shipping charges. For your protection, we suggest that you send your return with insurance and delivery confirmation for tracking purposes. Please allow 3-7 days for us to process your refund upon receipt of package.

If you would like an exchange for a different size or style, please follow the above instructions. We do not reimburse for return shipping costs. When the tag is received by us, we will refund your original purchase and you may place a new order for the desired item.

All sale items are final sale and cannot be exchanged or returned.

Custom orders will be refunded or exchanged on a case by case basis.
I accept Paypal payment method. You do not have to have a Paypal account to just pay with your Debit/Credit card. Payment is due upon checkout.

If you need to cancel your order, please convo me ASAP. As long as your (non-custom) item has not been shipped already, I can cancel your order and refund your payment.
Most pet charms are on stock and ready to ship next day. Customized pet ID tags generally take less than 3 days to ship. We make every effort to ship your tag out as soon as possible. You will receive an email confirmation on the day that your tag is mailed out.

Domestic orders are shipped First Class Mail via USPS. Delivery Confirmation is included in shipping. If you wish to upgrade to Priority Mail shipping, please let me know before you purchase so I can adjust the listing.

International orders are shipped First Class International. Registered Mail Tracking can be added onto the order for an additional $12. If you wish to upgrade to Priority Mail shipping, please let me know before you purchase so I can adjust the listing.

All orders are securely packaged in a bubble mailer. Items are gift wrapped in a handmade box with tissue paper and ribbon. A custom gift tag can be included if you are sending this directly to someone else.
Additional policies and FAQs
WILL ________________ FIT ON MY TAG?

Each size and shaped tag will fit slightly different text on it. If you have a question about your tag, simply e-mail your request to contact [!at] wtpup.com.


Some tags can fit your address on the back. This will be noted in the product description. Your address will be hand carved into the back of your tag.


Insert your dog's name above.... Absolutely! I love custom requests like this. Your dog's tag can basically be made to look like anything. Please view the Gallery to see other custom orders I have done to get further inspiration.


Polymer clay is a PVC plastic-based modeling material that is non-toxic to both humans and animals. It is extremely durable, scratch-resistant and waterproof. It holds up just as well in the weather as your ordinary metal tag, but it looks MUCH CUTER!


Yes! All tags are waterproof, so just a little soap and water will take any dirt off.


First of all, the tag is non-toxic. Certainly, like any other type of dog tag you do not want your pet to eat it. If that happens though, it should pass through your dog's system just like any other small object they may ingest. Check their feces in a day or two and you may see a colorful tag! Of course, if you are at all concerned, please take your pet immediately to the vet.