
Announcement
***SHOP UPDATE: Dear beloved customers, after 12 amazing years, we have decided to close Whimsy and Spice. We would like to thank each and every one of you who have ordered from our business over the past 12 years. Your support has meant the world to us and made our humble dreams of becoming small business owners, a reality. We owe you our success and gratitude. For more on our closure, please read our statement on our blog: https://www.sweetfineday.com/life/a-farewell-of-sorts-and-an-end-to-an-era/
Stay well and safe, friends!***
------
Brooklyn based bakery specializing in gourmet cookies, marshmallows, hot chocolate mixes, and food gift boxes. We are a licensed LLC company and make all our products by hand in small batches in Brooklyn, New York.
Select Press Mentions: The New York Times, Food & Wine, Martha Stewart, The Wall Street Journal, Food Network, Cooking Channel, Time Out New York, New York Magazine, Real Simple.
Announcement
***SHOP UPDATE: Dear beloved customers, after 12 amazing years, we have decided to close Whimsy and Spice. We would like to thank each and every one of you who have ordered from our business over the past 12 years. Your support has meant the world to us and made our humble dreams of becoming small business owners, a reality. We owe you our success and gratitude. For more on our closure, please read our statement on our blog: https://www.sweetfineday.com/life/a-farewell-of-sorts-and-an-end-to-an-era/
Stay well and safe, friends!***
------
Brooklyn based bakery specializing in gourmet cookies, marshmallows, hot chocolate mixes, and food gift boxes. We are a licensed LLC company and make all our products by hand in small batches in Brooklyn, New York.
Select Press Mentions: The New York Times, Food & Wine, Martha Stewart, The Wall Street Journal, Food Network, Cooking Channel, Time Out New York, New York Magazine, Real Simple.
Items

All Items
Reviews
-
-
-
Allison on Mar 31, 2020
5 out of 5 starsThese were the perfect addition to my boyfriends whiskey themed birthday basket. So delicious he didn’t want to share!
-
Judi on Mar 27, 2020
5 out of 5 starsPERFECT!! I have ordered this kit many times for us and presents. Delicious homemade grahams and rich chocolate and of course the flavorful mallows. YUM!!
-
-
-
Rachel on Mar 23, 2020
5 out of 5 starsThese cookies where great with a cup of tea and not to sweet.
-
Rachel on Mar 23, 2020
5 out of 5 starsThese where my favorite item I ordered. They have a very rich chocolate flavor mixes with a lovely early gray.
-
-
Rachel on Mar 23, 2020
5 out of 5 starsEverything was delicious. I loved how there where hazelnuts in every bite.
About whimsyandspice
-
All of our products are hand rolled, hand cut, baked and packaged in our kitchen in Sunset Park, Brooklyn.
-
Thousands of cookies are often lined up for baking on busy production days.
-
Our Pink Peppercorn Sandwich cookies are filled with a red currant chocolate filling.
-
Each of our Hazelnut Whisky Sandwich Cookies begin as little balls of dough, rolled by hand.
-
Black Pepper and Rose Thumbprints come out of the oven and onto cooling racks.
Former NYC Pastry Chef starts a family business
Whimsy & Spice was launched at the first ever Brooklyn Flea in Ft Greene in April, 2008. Our story is one of those recession stories where an unexpected lay off from a new job resulted in an opportunity to start a business. We had 2 short months to develop our product line, design our packaging and branding, and photograph our products. We handled everything ourselves, but quickly realized that between the two of us, our 14 years of experience in our respective fields as a Pastry Chef and a designer made us ideal partners in business. We launched with 3 shortbreads, 2 marshmallows, 2 biscotti, a brownie, and a sampler gift box. Three weeks later we opened up our Etsy shop and began shipping our products beyond the NYC area.
Now in business for more than 7 years, we have nearly 30 products in rotation and have shipped to every state in the US. We've been featured on national television on the Martha Stewart Show, The Rachel Ray Show, and the Cooking Channel, and covered by the The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, New York Magazine, Real Simple, Bon Appetit, Saveur, and Time Out New York. You can find our products in Dean & Deluca, Foragers Market, and the Ace Hotel, among other retailers in NYC.
We've seen the local Brooklyn food scene as well as other small independent food producers on Etsy grow exponentially since we were one of the first few food businesses on the scene. While our business has grown over the past 7 years, some things haven't changed - we still roll, bake, and package all of our products by hand, and you'll often see us behind the table at weekend markets. Our relationship to our customers–whether in person or online–is a personal one. From day one, packaging and design have always been an integral role in our business and we take as much care in the presentation of our products as we do in creating interesting flavor combinations in our sweets. Whimsy & Spice is still very much a family owned business in the spirit of when we founded the company in 2008.
Shop members
-
Mark Sopchak
Owner, Maker
Mark is a Pastry Chef with 14 years of experience in the kitchens of some of NYC's most popular restaurants. In 2008 he left the restaurant industry to form Whimsy & Spice.
-
Jenna Park
Owner, Creative Director
Jenna is an art director, designer and photographer. Her discerning palate and distinct eye for elegant and clean design leads all of the company's branding and creative efforts.
Shop policies
Whimsy & Spice is an insured LLC business located in a licensed commercial kitchen in Sunset Park, Brooklyn. Pastry Chef, Mark Sopchak, has a food handler's license and over 14 years experience working in the restaurant industry in NYC, 8 of those years as a Pastry Chef. All of our products are hand-made and hand-packaged in Brooklyn, NY.
* PLEASE NOTE: Our products are made in a facility that processes foods that contain wheat (gluten), milk, eggs, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, seeds, and chocolate. While some cookies may not contain all of these products, trace amounts of them may be found in our products.
Accepted payment methods
Returns and exchanges
I gladly accept returns
I don't accept exchanges or cancellations
The following items can't be returned or exchanged
- Custom or personalized orders
- Perishable products (like food or flowers)
- Digital downloads
- Intimate items (for health/hygiene reasons)
Returns and exchange details
Payment
If you would like an invoice included in your shipped order, please let us know, otherwise all packages will go out without printed invoices in an effort to save paper.
Shipping
We are now offering shipping on some of our items to Canada. Canadian orders are mailed first class, but due to the perishable nature of our products, we do not ship to countries outside of the US and Canada.
If there is an overage in calculation on shipping charges, we will refund extra costs.
Whimsy & Spice is not responsible for delayed, unclaimed, or returned orders due to incorrect or undeliverable addresses; packages that are not received, but are marked as "delivered" by USPS, Fed Ex or UPS tracking; or delays caused by mail carriers due to weather or other causes that are beyond our control. We will, however, work with our customers to try and resolve shipping issues.
It is possible to arrange local pickup in the NYC area. We are at Smorgasburg in Prospect Park on Sundays, April through October.