Salemates for Success Critque’s Away - Need help with your shop?

Who can join?

Salemates for Success is a moderated team with the following requirements:

We are looking for members to be active in promoting themselves AND each other. Shops should have clean, clear and crisp photos of items so that they are showcased well in treasuries along with at least ONE FULL page of items for variety.

Lets Sail Away for SUCCESS together!

Report this team to Etsy

Please type a brief note explaining why you are reporting this team:

Report a post

Thank you for taking time to help Etsy! Please note that you will not receive a personal response about this report. We will review this post privately...

Why are you reporting this post?

Any additional comments?

Edit Post

Edit your post below. After editing, the post will be marked as edited and the date & time of the last edit displayed.


What is this?

Admin may choose to highlight awesome community posts that are friendly, answer questions, and offer informative links.

What does it do?

Highlighted posts are placed at the top of each page in a thread for greater visibility.

Sign in to participate in this discussion.


Sara says

I would love a critique of my new banner if you guys have time. I just had it made & I'm not sure if it's a keeper. I'm not used to having a banner at all but figured it would be more professional this way...

Thanks in advance :)

Posted at 5:01 am Jun 30, 2012 EDT

I was wondering if you could critique my shop... please go very tough on me, I can take criticism and I would love having some other people's input. You can email me @ , or just message me. Thanks! Anyone critiquing me will work, I don't mind who as long as they are serious about it.

Posted at 5:28 am Jun 30, 2012 EDT

Ilona from Nonoluna says

Hi Cutezy,

I took a look and, as always, my eye is from the perspective of the treasury maker and your photos. That's also the way your customers experience your product so it's importance can't be underestimated.

Even though it takes time and is a real pain, I strongly suggest redoing your pictures. A neutral background is generally preferred although you can do creative things if you want. There is a website link that you'll find in previous critiques for fotofuze which will allow you to get a pure white background to your pictures. Try to get the pictures under great natural light. This gives a look that flash and general room lighting can't give. Lastly, I really liked the clip set up you had on this picture.

I didn't go further in depth than that. I do suggest reading through previous critiques. There's a lot that can be done with tags, names, descriptions, etc.

Happy Sales!

Posted at 6:53 am Jun 30, 2012 EDT

Someone please critique my shop!
Message me with critiques, don't post them on this thread please. Thanks!

Posted at 12:58 am Jul 1, 2012 EDT

Hello everybody! I am new here and I would be glad to hear your opinion about my shop. I haven't yet many views and I'm trying to understand what is going wrong!

Posted at 6:19 pm Jul 17, 2012 EDT

Alexianna, I think the main thing is you simply need more listings...the more you list, the more often you are seen :)

Posted at 6:23 pm Jul 17, 2012 EDT

I could use a critique also. This shop is so slow. I know my pics need help but anything else?

Posted at 1:26 pm Jul 28, 2012 EDT

All right Sandy, I hope this doesn't come across as brutal, only as honest. Ready?

First off, you're absolutely correct - you need to redo all of your photos. Some are too dark, some are on different makes your shop lack cohesiveness. From a tip on here I started using white poster board as my backdrops and to make them dazzling white. I take my photos outside in the bright sunshine (it's a great reason to go outside and perfect lighting). Find a good, sunny spot inside or out, take an afternoon, and have a photo shoot.

During that photo shoot, a few photos that I think you're missing from your items (and I speak purely as someone who sells coasters & magnets herself): the backs and sides. Show a picture of the backs of the magnets. Show the bottom of the coasters. For pictures we have to virtually simulate a customer coming to our booth, picking it up, and turning it over in their hands. People want to see what the magnet & coaster feet look like. Show the magnets hanging on a fridge. Prove to them how awesome your products are!

Now, while uploading your pretty new photos, take a look at your titles and descriptions. I'm still trying to put my finger on it, but I find your descriptions...lacking. For your titles I suggest another trick I learned on here - more keywords! When someone searches for an item within Etsy, it looks at the titles first, the actual keywords we add are looked at second. I find it weird, too, but we as sellers simply need to work the system. For your kitty adoption magnets, I would suggest 'Adopt a rescue cat magnets set of 3 handmade kitty spay neuter black cat adoption animals'

I know, it looks bizarre, but it works. Now, the descriptions; you mention in them where you got your images. Don't. People are going to look at that and say 'oh, she didn't really make it herself, she got it from someone else'. My magnet images have come from shops here on Etsy as well, and the purchase includes the rights to make other items with them. Consider it your trade secret as to where the lovely images came from.

Now, your prices...believe me that I say this as a fellow crafter and seller who only wants you to succeed - I would never pay $6 for a single coaster, especially one that was simply decoupaged. (I'm referencing the dragonfly coaster). Personally, I think you need to revisit your prices if you can. I charge $6 for a set of 4 tile coasters and I'm still making profit. Your hand painted ones obviously involve more time & effort than layering on modge podge so those should be priced more than the others. Honestly, I would also suggest making all of your coasters in sets of at least 2. As a consumer, I've never wanted to buy just one coaster.

Please, feel free to poke around my shop to see how I've set things up and described them. I hope I've helped - you've had 27 sales, so obviously you're off to a great start!

Posted at 3:55 pm Jul 29, 2012 EDT

I got feedback today in my shop and here is what they wrote:

"The beads were bought to use as spacers for a mala. They look good but I an still waiting for a focal bead to complete it. But they are nice."

This person did not order a focal bead from me and never even asked me about one. This makes it sound like I didn't send the focal bead to complete the mala. She did give me 5 stars.

My question is what should I do about this if anything at all?

Thanks for your help.


Posted at 10:13 am May 7, 2014 EDT

Cari A. says

HI Leann, since she gave you 5 stars, I wouldn't worry, I don't think people read everyone's feedback, especially if it's 5 stars. If its 3 or less they might. Did you try contacting her to see if she would amend what she wrote.

Posted at 6:29 am May 13, 2014 EDT

Unfollow username?

Are you sure you want to stop following this person?