Cathy, your titles might be confusing the algorithym. For example, the first on in your shop is entitled: "Journal Vintage Look II Handmade Spiral Bound"
It might be more effectively searched if you changed it to "Vintage Style Journal Handmade Spiral Bound"
I'm guessing that most people are going to be searching for a vintage style journal.
Also, your tags are: Paper Goods, Journal, journal, vintage, spiral bound, tags, treasures, lists, writing pad, drawing pad, envelopes, kits, hard cover, diary, journalling
Perhaps you could add: Notebook, vintage style, ephemera, graphics, memories
Also, I didn't see a list of the materials. That can help with being found in the search too, so add paper, spiral, notebook, treasures, tags, etc to your materials list.
I hope this helps get you seen!