This topic has been closed.

Does race matter in selling online?

Default avatar
Inactive Etsy Member 8:05pm Feb 22, 2012 EST edited
Apparently it CAN.


The Visible Hand
06/01/2010 | 11:00 am

Let’s say you were in the market for an iPod and wanted to find a bargain, so you searched in a local online market like Craigslist to find one.? Would it matter to you whether, in the photograph of the unopened iPod, the person holding the iPod (all you can see is their hand and wrist) was black or white?? What if the hand holding the iPod had a visible tattoo?
I suspect that most people would say that the skin color of the iPod holder wouldn’t matter to them.? More people likely would say the tattoo might keep them from responding to the ad.
Economists have never liked to rely on what people say, however.? We believe that actions speak louder than words.? And actions certainly do speak loudly in some new research carried out by economists Jennifer Doleac and Luke Stein.? Over the course of a year, they placed hundreds of ads in local online markets, randomly altering whether the hand holding an iPod for sale was black, white, or white with a big tattoo.? Here is what they found:
Black sellers do worse than white sellers on a variety of market outcome measures: they receive 13% fewer responses and 17% fewer offers. These effects are strongest in the Northeast, and are similar in magnitude to those associated with the display of a wrist tattoo. Conditional on receiving at least one offer, black sellers also receive 2-4% lower offers, despite the selfselected-and presumably less biased-pool of buyers. In addition, buyers corresponding with black sellers exhibit lower trust: they are 17% less likely to include their name in e-mails, 44% less likely to accept delivery by mail, and 56% more likely to express concern about making a long-distance payment. We find evidence that black sellers suffer particularly poor outcomes in thin markets; it appears that discrimination may not “survive” in the presence of significant competition among buyers. Furthermore, black sellers do worst in the most racially isolated markets and markets with high property crime rates, suggesting a role for statistical discrimination in explaining the disparity.
So what can you conclude from this study?? The clearest result is that if you want to sell something online, whether you are black or white, find someone white to put in the picture.? I suppose you could say that advertisers figured this out long ago, and actually go one step further, making sure the white person is also a good looking blond woman.
It is much harder, in this sort of setting, to figure out why buyers treat black and white sellers differently. As the authors note, there are two leading theories of discrimination: animus and statistical discrimination.? By animus, economists mean that buyers don’t want to buy from a black seller, even if the outcome of the transaction will be identical.? Buyers wouldn’t like black sellers, even if black sellers provided exactly the same quality as white sellers.? With statistical discrimination, on the other hand, the black hand is serving as a proxy for some sort of negative: a higher likelihood of being ripped off, a good more likely to have been stolen, or maybe a seller who lives very far away so that it will be too much trouble to meet in person to do the deal.
The most impressive part of this paper by Doleac and Stein is their attempt to distinguish between these two competing explanations: animus versus statistical discrimination.? How do they do it?? One thing they do is to vary the quality of the advertisement.? If the ad is really high quality, the authors conjecture, maybe that provides a signal that could trump the statistical discrimination motive for not buying from the black seller.? It turns out that ad quality does not matter much for the racial outcomes, but possibly this is because the quality difference across the ads isn’t great enough to matter. The authors also explore the impact of living in an area with more or less concentrated markets, and also across places with high and low property crime.? Black sellers do especially bad in high crime cities, which the authors interpret as evidence that it is statistical discrimination at work.
I really like this research a lot.? It is an example of what economists call a “natural field experiment,” which has the best of what lab experiments have to offer (true randomization) but with the realism that comes from observing people in actual markets, and with the research subjects unaware they are being analyzed.

526 Responses

Interesting that they did a study.... unfortunately I'm not surprised though.
Default avatar
Inactive Etsy Member 8:08pm Feb 22, 2012 EST
I think I'm going to buy me some wood model hands. Though I don't remember if I ever showed my hand when selling on eBay. Nor does the study look at atsy. I would love to know if they show similar results on etsy. Maybe or maybe not.

Anyway color me not shocked at these results.
Default avatar
Inactive Etsy Member 8:11pm Feb 22, 2012 EST
that's upsetting.
well, they mentioned it was Craigslist.

and that's not a very trusted environment, and perhaps perused by a different set of buyers.

For me, and others, race is not important -- for selling: neat, clean-looking, and average-or-better appearance, literate descriptions mean the most.
This study just makes me sad. But I have to admit, if someone had tons of tattoos in a picture, that might make me pause a little bit, just because I'm not a huge tattoo fan. But then I would get over it. Because I'm grown-up enough to do that!
Default avatar
Inactive Etsy Member 8:12pm Feb 22, 2012 EST
I have to admit - I think about this a lot. Because we are a multiracial family (Black, Asian, Native amer. & White) I know I'm pretty sensitive to the people in ad images.

For example - you will NEVER see a Black child in an ad with anything but a big poofy afro. Never with braids, cornrows, flat twists or beads. My youngest child is Black and if we go out on a free hair day White people always comment on how much they love her big hair. I don't know why but there just is that divide in my experience.

I tend to frequent shops and retailers who have significant minority staff and advertising. Just my preference.
Interesting.....and disgusting. You would really think that we would be past racism crap, sexism crap and all the other ridiculous biases that many deal with everyday of lives.

Thanks for sharing the article.....but it made my head explooOOOOOde! ;-)
wood hands are creepy. clean hands and nails are the best.

Unfollow username?

Are you sure you want to stop following this person?

Report a post

Thank you for taking time to help Etsy! Please note that you will not receive a personal response about this report. We will review this post privately.

Why are you reporting this post?

Any additional comments?

Edit Post

Edit your post below. After editing, the post will be marked as edited and the date & time of the last edit displayed.

Edit Reply

Edit your post below. After editing, the post will be marked as edited and the date & time of the last edit displayed.

Enter at least 15 characters. 400 remaining.


What is this?

Admin may choose to highlight awesome community posts that are friendly, answer questions, and offer informative links.

What does it do?

Highlighted posts are placed at the top of each page in a thread for greater visibility.