Is Ron Kalin ever going to address these huge, kept under wraps, changes?

Report a post

Thank you for taking time to help Etsy! Please note that you will not receive a personal response about this report. We will review this post privately...

Why are you reporting this post?

Any additional comments?

Edit Post

Edit your post below. After editing, the post will be marked as edited and the date & time of the last edit displayed.

Close

What is this?

Admin may choose to highlight awesome community posts that are friendly, answer questions, and offer informative links.

What does it do?

Highlighted posts are placed at the top of each page in a thread for greater visibility.

This topic has been closed.

Original Post

rtisan says

If he was going to, now would be a good time to do so.

Don't think we need a "cooling off" period before it's addressed again

Etsy, you have thousands of unhappy etsians, twittering, writing blog posts about the situation, etc. Many are thinking of leaving. Very low morale around here.

If the medi gets wind, they will take off running with all this new info--an example: "Premiere handmade site, thrid in line behind Ebay and Aamazon, has now made changed in their "qualifications of handmade." Esty's allwance of Collectives to be only etsy, which if you look up in a dictiontary, have changed their defintion. It seems small factories are possibly allowed.

This means a lot to those of you who seek handmade goods. It seems it's not going to be as easy to find the real Mccoy.

Etsy touts "homemade" (plus vintage and supplies to make handmade) and customers buy into it.

Buyer beware! There are no guarantees you will be able to purchase a handmade item any longer.

This country was propelled into to the limelight by the hard work of sellers, pimping and promoting the site thru' their own ads paid out of thier own pockets, word of mouth, even passing out flyers, a promo at a very basic level.

Much of etsy' success and profits are due to the hard work of these impassioned sellers who donate an incredible amount of their time pushing etsy.

Etsy doesn't believe in main stream advertising and instead, apply grassroots word of mouth. But it's 250 sellers are the real mouthpieces that have brought etsy the success it sees today.

Today, there are a bunch of unhappy sellers who feel they were deceived since the mission statement changed midstream without them being alerted to this fact. They found info by bits and pieces and put all the pieces together.

The future oe etsy:

Can esty continue without the help of its community? I think almost all have thrown in the towel and will not help police any longer. They were deceived and disrespected.

I suppose etsy can hire a lot of new staff. Their vision hs changed, so hndmade "by you" no longer applies. There will be single shop owners who will continue to sell "handmade by them" items. But look out for the coming of factories (disguised as "collectives"( who will have no hand in the making of these "handmade goods".

Etsy has a good thing and could actually stand up against ebay and amazon because they had something no other big site has--handmade goods made by the shop owner. Now no more.

Posted at 6:55pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT

Responses

rtisan says

sorry for typos!

Posted at 6:56pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT

marking, ty

Posted at 6:56pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT

aosLeather says

fyi - it's Rob, not Ron

;-)

Posted at 6:59pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT

Marking.

Posted at 7:00pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT

rtisan says

ah, a gazillions typos. I meant to say 250,000 sellers not 250.

Posted at 7:01pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT

agree with you rtsian that it's important to maintain the integrity of the site and the handmade label...just don't want to see the response go too far in the opposite direction and have the Etsy police in my craft room watching me individually hand make each item that I list in my shop.

Posted at 7:01pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT

rtisan... please don't be upset when your post gets moved... this is not a site help post.

Posted at 7:02pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT

rtisan says

Ahh should I rewrite it? So many TYPOS!

Posted at 7:02pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT

Juanitas says

You don't have to re-type. I get what you're saying...I didn't know there was such an uproar about this...then again I'm not on Facebook or Twitter.

Posted at 7:03pm Jul 22, 2010 EDT