Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript.

ThatCustomShop

Knoxville, Tennessee

1.2k
 Sales

10 years
on Etsy

1.2k
 sales

10 years
on Etsy

Following Follow

1.2k
 Sales

10 years
on Etsy

1.2k
 sales

10 years
on Etsy

Request Custom Order

Contact shop owner

1169 Sales

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Featured items

Custom Neoprene Can Coolers | Personalized Party Favors, Event Giveaways, Wedding Guests

Custom Neoprene Can Coolers | Personalized Party Favors, Event Giveaways, Wedding Guests

$70.98

FREE shipping

Custom Slim Can Coolers | Personalized Party Favors, Wedding Bulk Gifts

Custom Slim Can Coolers | Personalized Party Favors, Wedding Bulk Gifts

$64.94

FREE shipping

Custom Full Color Can Coolers | Personalized Party Favors, Event Giveaways, Wedding Bulk

Custom Full Color Can Coolers | Personalized Party Favors, Event Giveaways, Wedding Bulk

$72.98

FREE shipping

Custom Slim Can Coolers | Full Color Party Favors, Wedding Gifts, Event Giveaways

Custom Slim Can Coolers | Full Color Party Favors, Wedding Gifts, Event Giveaways

$69.94

FREE shipping

All items

Enchanted Wedding Can Coolers, Fairytale Reception | Happily Ever After | Fits 12 oz, Personalized Favors

Enchanted Wedding Can Coolers, Fairytale Reception | Happily Ever After | Fits 12 oz, Personalized Favors

$60.98

FREE shipping

Fairytale Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Happily Ever After Skinny Can Holders, Personalized

Fairytale Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Happily Ever After Skinny Can Holders, Personalized

$54.94

FREE shipping

Fairytale Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Love Laughter and Happily Ever After, Personalized

Fairytale Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Love Laughter and Happily Ever After, Personalized

$54.94

FREE shipping

Fairytale Wedding, Storybook Can Coolers | Happily Ever After, Personalized, Fits 12 oz Cans

Fairytale Wedding, Storybook Can Coolers | Happily Ever After, Personalized, Fits 12 oz Cans

$60.98

FREE shipping

Fairytale Bridal Shower Slim Can Coolers, Happily Ever After Engagement Party Favors, Personalized

Fairytale Bridal Shower Slim Can Coolers, Happily Ever After Engagement Party Favors, Personalized

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Fairytale Wedding Can Coolers, Romantic Reception Favors, 12 oz Foam or Neoprene

Personalized Fairytale Wedding Can Coolers, Romantic Reception Favors, 12 oz Foam or Neoprene

$60.98

FREE shipping

Whimsical Garden Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Love Laughter and Happily Ever After, Personalized

Whimsical Garden Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Love Laughter and Happily Ever After, Personalized

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Fairytale Wedding Can Coolers, Romantic Happily Ever After Favors, Foam or Neoprene

Personalized Fairytale Wedding Can Coolers, Romantic Happily Ever After Favors, Foam or Neoprene

$60.98

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have To Hold Drink Holders, Foam or Neoprene

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have To Hold Drink Holders, Foam or Neoprene

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have & To Hold Drink Holders, Foam or Neoprene

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have & To Hold Drink Holders, Foam or Neoprene

$60.98

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold, Beer Holders

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold, Beer Holders

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have & Hold Beer Holders, Foam or Neoprene Favors

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have & Hold Beer Holders, Foam or Neoprene Favors

$60.98

FREE shipping

Personalized Bridal Shower Slim Can Coolers, To Have & Hold Wedding Favors, Foam or Neoprene

Personalized Bridal Shower Slim Can Coolers, To Have & Hold Wedding Favors, Foam or Neoprene

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Cooler, Bridal Shower Favor, To Have & Hold Drink Sleeve

Personalized Wedding Can Cooler, Bridal Shower Favor, To Have & Hold Drink Sleeve

$60.98

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Rehearsal Dinner Favors, To Have To Hold Beer Holders

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Rehearsal Dinner Favors, To Have To Hold Beer Holders

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, Rehearsal Dinner Favors, Custom Keepsake Beer Design

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, Rehearsal Dinner Favors, Custom Keepsake Beer Design

$60.98

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have To Hold Drink Holders, Foam or Neoprene

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have To Hold Drink Holders, Foam or Neoprene

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold, Foam or Neoprene Drink Holders

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold, Foam or Neoprene Drink Holders

$60.98

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold Design, Foam or Neoprene

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold Design, Foam or Neoprene

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold, 12 oz Beer Holders

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold, 12 oz Beer Holders

$60.98

FREE shipping

Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Personalized Drink Holders, To Have and To Hold Design

Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Personalized Drink Holders, To Have and To Hold Design

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have & To Hold, Drink Holder Bulk Favors

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have & To Hold, Drink Holder Bulk Favors

$60.98

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold, Beer Keepsakes

Personalized Wedding Slim Can Coolers, To Have and To Hold, Beer Keepsakes

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have & To Hold Beer Favors, Custom Keepsakes

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, To Have & To Hold Beer Favors, Custom Keepsakes

$60.98

FREE shipping

Destination Wedding Slim Can Coolers, The Adventure Begins Travel Favors, Personalized

Destination Wedding Slim Can Coolers, The Adventure Begins Travel Favors, Personalized

$54.94

FREE shipping

Destination Wedding, Tropical Coolers | The Adventure Begins | Personalized, Foam or Neoprene | Fits 12 oz Cans

Destination Wedding, Tropical Coolers | The Adventure Begins | Personalized, Foam or Neoprene | Fits 12 oz Cans

$60.98

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, 12 oz Foam or Neoprene, Personalized Favors

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, 12 oz Foam or Neoprene, Personalized Favors

$60.98

FREE shipping

Elegant Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Thank You for Celebrating With Us, Personalized Favors

Elegant Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Thank You for Celebrating With Us, Personalized Favors

$54.94

FREE shipping

Barn Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Let's Party Til the Cows Come Home, Personalized Favors

Barn Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Let's Party Til the Cows Come Home, Personalized Favors

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Barn Wedding Can Coolers, Rustic Farm Party Favors, Let's PartyTil The Cows Come Home

Personalized Barn Wedding Can Coolers, Rustic Farm Party Favors, Let's PartyTil The Cows Come Home

$60.98

FREE shipping

Rustic Ranch Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Let's Party Til the Cows Come Home, Personalized

Rustic Ranch Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Let's Party Til the Cows Come Home, Personalized

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, Rustic Ranch Barn Reception Favors, Til The Cows Come Home

Personalized Wedding Can Coolers, Rustic Ranch Barn Reception Favors, Til The Cows Come Home

$60.98

FREE shipping

Country Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Let's Party Til the Cows Come Home, Personalized

Country Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Let's Party Til the Cows Come Home, Personalized

$54.94

FREE shipping

Personalized Country Wedding Can Coolers, Farmhouse Party Favors, Til The Cows Come Home

Personalized Country Wedding Can Coolers, Farmhouse Party Favors, Til The Cows Come Home

$60.98

FREE shipping

Golf Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Here for the Par-Tee Country Club Favors, Personalized

Golf Wedding Slim Can Coolers, Here for the Par-Tee Country Club Favors, Personalized

$54.94

FREE shipping

3 people have this in their cart

Personalized Golf Wedding Can Coolers, Country Club, Fits 12 oz Cans and Bottles

Personalized Golf Wedding Can Coolers, Country Club, Fits 12 oz Cans and Bottles

$60.98

FREE shipping

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

That Custom Shop

Contact shop owner

That Custom Shop

Reviews

2.0 (164)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Loading

Destiney on Aug 23, 2026

1 out of 5 stars

I was supposed to have my order delivered by August 17th it is now August 23rd and they haven’t even shipped my order and my event is in a couple of days and they have not messaged me back. When I went to look at previous reviews other people hadn’t received their order as well. DO NOT order from this company!

Golf Wedding Slim Can Coolers for Country Club Weddings — Here For The Par-Tee Golf Course Wedding Favors for Guests in Bulk

Golf Wedding Slim Can Coolers for Country Club Weddings — Here For The Par-Tee Golf Course Wedding Favors for Guests in Bulk
Felicia on Sep 1, 2026

1 out of 5 stars

never received..

Casino-Themed Wedding Can Coolers Las Vegas Wedding Favors for Guests in Bulk — Lucky in Love

Casino-Themed Wedding Can Coolers Las Vegas Wedding Favors for Guests in Bulk — Lucky in Love
Elvia on Aug 21, 2026

1 out of 5 stars

I never received my order, even after communicating with them. It was promised to arrive by July 27 but my order was never processed or shipped. And today is August 21. I do not suggest this company.

Custom Slim Can Coolers Personalized Party Favors | Neoprene Slim Can Coolers Event Trade Show Giveaways | Wedding Favors for Guests in Bulk

Custom Slim Can Coolers Personalized Party Favors | Neoprene Slim Can Coolers Event Trade Show Giveaways | Wedding Favors for Guests in Bulk
Etsy buyer on Jun 17, 2021

1 out of 5 stars

Not sure what cups these are supposed to fit but I bought them for 16oz cups, as the description states they’re for, but they don’t fit at all. Bummed.

Lids For Personalized 12oz | 16oz | 22oz Plastic Stadium Cups (Pack of 25)

Lids For Personalized 12oz | 16oz | 22oz Plastic Stadium Cups (Pack of 25)
Frances on Mar 8, 2021

2 out of 5 stars

Options for size ordering very unclear and ended up with wrong size. Having to return

Lids For Personalized 12oz | 16oz | 22oz Plastic Stadium Cups (Pack of 25)

Lids For Personalized 12oz | 16oz | 22oz Plastic Stadium Cups (Pack of 25)
Rachel on Jan 2, 2022

5 out of 5 stars

Easy to work with and loved the result!

Personalized Can Coolers For Guests & Events Party Favors Bulk Promotional Items One Color Print Foam or Neoprene Your Custom Design or Logo

Personalized Can Coolers For Guests & Events Party Favors Bulk Promotional Items One Color Print Foam or Neoprene Your Custom Design or Logo
Leila on Nov 9, 2021

5 out of 5 stars

had to have some design assistance 🤣 they were very helpful and delivery was about a week ahead of schedule!

Stadium Cups Personalized Promo Items One Color Print Custom Party Favors Plastic Cups | Your Design or Logo | 12oz | 16oz | 22oz | 32oz

Stadium Cups Personalized Promo Items One Color Print Custom Party Favors Plastic Cups | Your Design or Logo | 12oz | 16oz | 22oz | 32oz
Melissa on Oct 6, 2021

5 out of 5 stars

I ordered these koozies for wedding favors and I give the shop a 10/10! I messaged back and forth with the shop a few times about what I was looking for and they were so responsive and provided proofs along the way with my design ideas. They shipped incredibly fast too. All in all an excellent experience!

Personalized Can Coolers For Guests & Events Party Favors Bulk Promotional Items One Color Print Foam or Neoprene Your Custom Design or Logo

Personalized Can Coolers For Guests & Events Party Favors Bulk Promotional Items One Color Print Foam or Neoprene Your Custom Design or Logo
Katie on Aug 12, 2021

5 out of 5 stars

The BEST to work with. They helped me change the design until it was perfect and I received the coozies earlier than expected. So, so happy with the customer service and, most importantly, the product.

One Color Print Hard Foam Can Coolers For Guests & Events Beer Bottle Insulators Party Favors Gifts Promotional Items | Your Design or Logo

One Color Print Hard Foam Can Coolers For Guests & Events Beer Bottle Insulators Party Favors Gifts Promotional Items | Your Design or Logo
Kat on Aug 5, 2021

5 out of 5 stars

The cups turned out just perfect and were delivered fast!

One Color Print Stadium Cups Personalized Promo Items Custom Party Favors Plastic Cups | Your Design or Logo | 12oz | 16oz | 22oz | 32oz

One Color Print Stadium Cups Personalized Promo Items Custom Party Favors Plastic Cups | Your Design or Logo | 12oz | 16oz | 22oz | 32oz

About ThatCustomShop

Custom Promotional Items and Party Favors for any Event

Sales 1,169

On Etsy since 2015

Custom Promotional Items and Party Favors for any Event

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Seller details

View shop registration details