Tooth Fairy Pillows

(3,756 Results)

There's so much more for you to discover

Review spotlight

Here is a selection of four-star and five-star reviews from customers who were delighted with the products they found in this category.

diem5290

5 out of 5 stars

"The fairy pillow is so cute. My niece is going to love it. Excellent customer service."

Gold Tooth Fairy Pillow, Girls Pink Tooth Fairy Pillow, Tooth Pillow, Girl Tooth Fairy Pillow, Birthday Gift, Personalized Tooth Pillow
Ashlie

5 out of 5 stars

"The tooth fairy pillow is adorable and arrived quickly!"

Custom Tooth Fairy Pillow Pal in Double-Sided Wool Felt, in the color of your choice, with name embroidery
Karen

5 out of 5 stars

"The tooth fairy tooth pillow is adorable. Both my kids love it and I think it'll make it much easier for the tooth fairy to get it off of the door then under the pillow. Seems to be good quality. My kids love them."

Personalized Adorable Tooth Fairy Pillow Handmade Custom Keepsake Boy Girl
Laura Dincer

5 out of 5 stars

"Love these pillows :) Previously purchased for my oldest son and came back to order more for my twins! Thank you so much!"

Navy and Green Personalized Tooth Fairy Pillow
Kayla

5 out of 5 stars

"This creator is wonderful! She communicates about design and the product is gorgeous. This is definitely the best way I’ve heard for easy tooth fairy exchange. Thank you!"

Bubblegum Pink, Purple, Turquoise Personalized Tooth Fairy Pillow
Noel Maillet

5 out of 5 stars

"A very cute tooth pillow. My little girl loves it."

Personalized Tooth Fairy Pillow with New Style Face, Tutu and Magic Wand. Great Gift Idea girl or boy

Related to Tooth Fairy Pillows

Learn More About Tooth Fairy Pillows

A tooth fairy pillow is a small cushion with space to place a child’s lost tooth and tuck it safely under their pillow, ready for the Tooth Fairy to find and exchange for cash. Tooth fairy pillows come in all shapes and sizes to help little ones through one of life’s notable transitions. Whether you’re looking for a modern tooth-shaped pillow, a vintage design that you loved in your childhood, or a customizable pattern to make your own, Etsy sellers offer the perfect pouch for a magical visit from the Tooth Fairy.

As early as the 13th century, the Northern European tradition of “tand-fé”( or tooth fee) was paid when a child lost their first tooth. Ancient Norse culture mentions children’s teeth as magical good luck charms, sometimes worn during battle. While these early myths have long since vanished and turned into the modern lore of the Tooth Fairy, the basic principle remains. Losing teeth can be an anxiety-inducing event for some kids, and the promise of a reward for bravery is a time-honored tradition in households worldwide. Around the 1950s, tooth fairy pillows became a popular and beloved accessory for keeping the teeth tucked safely under the pillow during this enchanting exchange.

Tooth fairy pillows are filled with whimsy, wonder, and nostalgia that lasts a lifetime. When choosing a tooth fairy pillow, think about the child who will use it. Consider a sports-themed tooth fairy pillow for your little leaguer. Or opt for a crocheted tooth fairy pillow in their favorite color. Some Etsy sellers can even make you a special personalized tooth fairy pillow with their name on it to comfort them through the night.

The Tooth Fairy and tooth fairy pillows have the power to unleash the uninhibited imagination of children. Whichever design you choose, they can give children the gift of magic, endless possibility, and belief in something more than what they see.

Tooth Fairy Pillows