Types of cookie sheets

The most common cookie sheet size for home kitchens is a half sheet, which fits easily in most standard ovens. Whether you're making your mom's chocolate chip cookies or the new macaron recipe from your favorite food blogger, you'll want the right type of cookie sheet for the job: Traditional: A traditional aluminum cookie sheet is thin and has a large, flat surface area. These cookie sheets don't come with a nonstick coating, so they’re best for cookies that lift off easily. Nonstick: A good choice for novice bakers, nonstick cookie sheets are coated with a smooth finish to prevent sticking. Nonstick aluminum and stainless steel cookie sheets are darker in color and work best for crunchy and crispy cookies.

Cookie sheet accessories

Pair your new cookie sheets with accessories that’ll take your treats from so-so to scrumptious: Cookie cutters: Cookie cutters exist for every fandom and aesthetic, making it easy to add a personal touch to your baked goods. From cartoon classics to vintage favorites, cookie cutters help your finished product look uniform for a photo-worthy baking session. Silicone baking mats: Silicone cookie sheet mats create a nonstick surface and help distribute heat more evenly while baking. A modern replacement for parchment paper, silicone mats are washable and reusable. Rolling pins: Every baker searches for that one perfect rolling pin . Whether you’re looking for a vintage rolling pin like your grandma’s or want a modern rolling pin with measurement guides, shops on Etsy have a great selection to choose from. Platters: Once the baking is done and the oven is cooled, grab a platter to display your cookies. From personalized plates to retro designs, a unique backdrop for your confections sets them apart. Organizers: Cookie sheet organizers bring a sense of order to your sheet pan cabinet. Sellers on Etsy have created unique storage systems to make storing your sheet pans easier than ever.

Cookie Sheets

(235 Results)

There's so much more for you to discover

Review spotlight

Here is a selection of four-star and five-star reviews from customers who were delighted with the products they found in this category.

Stefanie Lew

5 out of 5 stars

"Timely communication and extremely accommodating of our event date deadline. You can tell she takes great pride in ensuring a positive overall customer experience. We were very satisfied with the quality of the cookie toppers!"

Personalized Premium Edible Cupcake or Cookie Toppers. Multiple Sizes, add Any Image or Text.
Emily Bohan

5 out of 5 stars

"Thank you for the cookie sheet spacers"

baking sheet dividers baking sheet organizer baking gifts tray stacker gift for cookie baker baking sheet cookie
mikichanbully666

5 out of 5 stars

"FANTASTIC craftsmanship and design by Larry & Diana. Very easy to communicate with great customer service. Forever grateful for the amazing pieces we got. This cookie sheet pan is stellar at even cooking. For Thanksgiving I put my dinner rolls on it and the best rolls I've ever had came from this. We also had a pu.pkin pie that we set on it and came out wonderfully! I ended up buying 3. One for me and two for gifts. The patina comes out beautifully after each use, Bright pinks and oranges with a touch of purple. Definetely would like to display it rather then hide it away. Thank you for all the wonderful items we purchased this year, Larry & Diana. S"

SOLID COPPER Baking Sheets Two-Piece Set Metal USA Handmade Wedding Gift 7th Anniversary Gift By West Tinworks
laserwife

5 out of 5 stars

"I make marshmallows in massive batches, and I end up with trays of powdered sugar covered marshmallows on every flat surface while I wait overnight for them to dry so I can cut them up and bag them. THANK YOU, now I have ONE spot on my counter for all FOUR trays and that is just so wonderful! Fits my half sheet trays, my quarter sheet trays, and even my 13x9 deep trays (with my quarter sheet trays in the same stack!). Just so stable and easy. And when I want to pull out the bottom one? Lift the top three, and the stands stay in place - and they don't fall off into the powdered sugar - so I can set the stack down, remove the stands, and then get to work cutting up those Amaretto marshmallows. Yipppee!!"

Baking Sheet Dividers Set

Learn More About Cookie Sheets

A traditional cookie sheet is thin and flat, often with an angled lip on one side for easy gripping. Standard baking pans are usually thicker and have a round-edge rim on all sides. A baking pan can replace a cookie sheet, but a cookie sheet isn’t meant for foods that might drip or slide off the flat surface while cooking.

The most common cookie sheet size for home kitchens is a half sheet, which fits easily in most standard ovens. Whether you're making your mom's chocolate chip cookies or the new macaron recipe from your favorite food blogger, you'll want the right type of cookie sheet for the job:

Traditional: A traditional aluminum cookie sheet is thin and has a large, flat surface area. These cookie sheets don't come with a nonstick coating, so they’re best for cookies that lift off easily.
Nonstick: A good choice for novice bakers, nonstick cookie sheets are coated with a smooth finish to prevent sticking. Nonstick aluminum and stainless steel cookie sheets are darker in color and work best for crunchy and crispy cookies.

Pair your new cookie sheets with accessories that’ll take your treats from so-so to scrumptious:

Cookie cutters: Cookie cutters exist for every fandom and aesthetic, making it easy to add a personal touch to your baked goods. From cartoon classics to vintage favorites, cookie cutters help your finished product look uniform for a photo-worthy baking session.
Silicone baking mats: Silicone cookie sheet mats create a nonstick surface and help distribute heat more evenly while baking. A modern replacement for parchment paper, silicone mats are washable and reusable.
Rolling pins: Every baker searches for that one perfect rolling pin. Whether you’re looking for a vintage rolling pin like your grandma’s or want a modern rolling pin with measurement guides, shops on Etsy have a great selection to choose from.
Platters: Once the baking is done and the oven is cooled, grab a platter to display your cookies. From personalized plates to retro designs, a unique backdrop for your confections sets them apart.
Organizers: Cookie sheet organizers bring a sense of order to your sheet pan cabinet. Sellers on Etsy have created unique storage systems to make storing your sheet pans easier than ever.

Cookie Sheets

Stainless Steel Baking Sheet engraved with a Handwritten recipe, Heirloom pan, Grandma's recipe, non toxic and healthy, sheet tray

Stainless Steel Baking Sheet etched with Custom Saying or Artwork, Non Toxic and healthy, Cookie sheet, Sheet tray

Personalized Baking Cookie Sheet, Baking Sheet, Large Aluminum Baking Sheet, 13" x 18"

Engraved Cookie Sheet, Personalized Aluminum Baking Sheet, Engraved Sheet Pan, Custom Cookie Pan, Sheet Tray, Oven Baking Pan, Baker Gift

Personalized Cookie Sheet, Small Engraved Aluminum Baking Sheet, 9.5" x 12.5"

SOLID COPPER Baking Sheets Two-Piece Set Metal USA Handmade Wedding Gift 7th Anniversary Gift By West Tinworks

Wear Ever Airbake Insulated Small Cookie Sheet 9.5" x 14"

Vintage Bake King Silver Baking Pan / Baking Sheet / Farmhouse Kitchen / Pure Aluminum Baking Sheet

Daddy's Grilling Tray Stainless Steel Baking Sheet, Non Toxic and healthy, Cookie sheet, Sheet tray, Father's Day Gift

Engraved Cookie Sheet, Personalized Aluminum Baking Sheet, Engraved Sheet Pan, Custom Cookie Pan, Sheet Tray, Oven Baking Pan, Baker Gift

Engraved Cookie Sheet, Personalized Aluminum Baking Sheet, Engraved Sheet Pan, Custom Cookie Pan, Sheet Tray, Oven Baking Pan, Baker Gift

Vintage PY-O-MY Pastry Mix Free 49 Cent Sheet Pan with Purchase Give a Way

Baking Sheet SOLID COPPER USA Handmade Wedding Gift Housewarming Gift By West Tinworks

Haeger Baking Sheet Natural Stone Premium Bakeware USA

Vintage Mirro #5485 Aluminum Baking Pan/Cookie Sheet 14" X 10" Inch

Toaster Oven Baking Sheet SOLID COPPER Handmade In the USA By West Tinworks

Vintage AirBake Cookie Sheet Baking Pan 14x9 Insulated Aluminum One Edge

Vintage Wear-Ever 14 x 9 Cookie Sheet, # 2814, Aluminum, Collectible, Kitchen, Baking

Personalized Aluminum Baking Sheet, Cookie Sheet, Small

Vintage Revereware Baking Sheet #2515 - 15.25 * 10.5 * 1 - Heavy Stainless Steel

Grilled to Perfection Grill Tray Stainless Steel Baking Sheet, Non Toxic and healthy, Cookie sheet, Sheet tray, Father's Day Gift

5 Vollrath Wearever 13 x 9.5 Aluminum 1/4 Sheet Pan USA 5220 Jelly Roll Cookies

T-FAL Signature Non-Stick Rectangle Medium Cookie Sheet Pan 10 x 15

Two Vintage Star Shaped Cookie Sheets made In W. Germany, Vintage Star Cookie Sheet, Vintage Cookie Sheet, Vintage Star Baking Pan

Pyrex England 12" Baking Tray, Cookie Sheet, Grid Square Pattern, Glass Tray, No Stovetop or Broiler, Used

Back Yard Brew and BBQ Grilling Tray Stainless Steel Baking Sheet, Non Toxic and healthy, Cookie sheet, Sheet tray, Father's Day Gift

Back Yard Grill and Chill Grilling Tray Stainless Steel Baking Sheet, Non Toxic and healthy, Cookie sheet, Sheet tray, Father's Day Gift

World's Best Dad Stainless Steel Baking Sheet, Non Toxic and healthy, Cookie sheet, Sheet tray

Vintage Wear-Ever Baking Sheets Aluminum Baking Sheets L2

Vintage Wear-Ever Baking Sheets Aluminum Baking Sheets L3

Vintage Baking Sheets Wear-Ever Aluminum Baking Sheets L1

Macaron Baking Sheet Set of 2 - Silicone Cookie Sheets with 25 Small Ridges and Filling Marks - Dishwasher Safe, Heat Resistant

Cook With Color Cookie Sheet 4 Piece Backing Pan Set Brand New

PYREX England 9 x 12 checkered glass baking sheet

Wilton Easter Egg Box Kit Complete Cookie Pan Gift Sticker Sheet Reusable

Vintage White Enamelware Rectangular Cake Pan Black Trim Porcelain Farmhouse Kitchen Graniteware 12" x 7.5" x 2.25" Cobbler Brownies Salad

Christmas cookie jar angel red by SS Sarna ceramic holiday cookies jar 8"high x 5.5"diameter

Vintage penguin ceramic cookie jar made in Italy 11.5" base 7"x6" black and white

Wilton Snowman Cookie Mold, Snowman Cookie Sheet, Christmas Cookie Mold, Children's Cookie Mold, Character Cookie Mold, Gift for Baker

Chicago Metallic Madeleine Christmas Cookie Baking Pan Non-Stick Never Used

Vintage The Pampered Chef Stoneware Large Bar Pan Family Heritage

Vtg 1993 Wilton Barney Cake Pan

1983 Kitty Cat Brown Bag Art /Recipe Book Hill Design -Cookie Clay Mold

Set of 2 Nestle’s Tollhouse Cookie Kids Baking Pan Cookie Sheet, Gingerbread Cookies

Brown Bag Cokkie Art Cookie Stamp Checking It Twice #44

Vintage Pampered Chef Stoneware “Seasons of The Heart” Cookie Mold- 1997

Brown Bag Cookie Art Heart Shape Cookie Mold, Pennsylvania Dutch Tulips, 5.75", Hill Design, 1986, Baking, Crafts, Country Kitchen Decor

Vintage Dutch cookie mold - Llama Lama Alpaca animal hand carved wood wooden Biscuit / Speculaas baking - Vintage Kitchen Folk Art Antique

Brown Bag Cookie Art Heart Shape Cookie Mold, Tulips Spring Flower Bouquet, 5.5", Hill Design, 1989, Baking, Crafts, Country Kitchen Decor

Madeline Cookie Mold, Baking Pan, Cookie Sheet, French Patisserie, Pastry Chef, Gourmet Cookie Pan, Non Stick, Coated Stainless Steel

2 Vintage Madeleine Cookie Trays (sold as pair)

Vintage 1940's mini Madeleine French tea cakes baking tin 20 pieces long baking pan

Vintage Brown Bag cow cookie/shortbread mold

2000 Pampered Chef Anniversary Heart Cookie Mold Family Heritage Stoneware

Glass cookie jar full of vintage metal cookie cutters 22 cutters included variety of seasons

Pampered Chef Bear Cookie Press and Brown Bag Cookie Art Cookie Press Cutter Decorate

Heart Shaped Cookie Mold Brown Bag Cookie Art 1988 Hill Design

Pillsbury Crescent Moon Dough Boy Cookie Cutter, Vintage 1980s

Brown Bag Cookie Art Heart Shape Cookie Mold, 6", Hill Design, (c)1988, Baking, Crafts, Country Kitchen Decor

The Pampered Chef Family Heritage Stoneware Classics Collection Pan

New Nordic Ware Snowflake Shortbread Cast Aluminum Cake Pan Bake Bakeware ~ Made in USA

Handmade Blue Pottery Casserole Dish

Vintage White Enamelware Rectangular Cake Pan Black Trim Porcelain Farmhouse Kitchen Graniteware 16.25" x 10" x 2.25" Cobbler Brownies Salad

WILTON CHRISTMAS COOKIE Pan - 12 Cavity Cookie Pan - All Different Designs - Up to 3" - 16 1/2" x 11 1/4" Cookie Pan -

There's so much more for you to discover

Learn More About Cookie Sheets

Cookie sheets vs. baking pans

Types of cookie sheets

Cookie sheet accessories