AlwaysExtraHandmade

North Dakota, United States

1.1k
 Sales

5.0 (192)

5 years
on Etsy

5.0 (192)

1.1k
 sales

5 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

1.1k
 Sales

5.0 (192)

5 years
on Etsy

5.0 (192)

1.1k
 sales

5 years
on Etsy

All 7
Candles 5
Candle Subscription Box 1

Contact shop owner

1109 Sales

203 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Sep 13, 2025

✨ Welcome to Always Extra Handmade ✨

Our soy candles go beyond fragrance — they’re luxury art pieces for your home.

Every "Extra" candle is a one-of-a-kind piece of art, hand decorated with pressed flowers, greenery, rhinestones, and more. All candles are created by a single artist — the only candles of their kind. They make unforgettable gifts and are guaranteed to be a conversation starter in any space.

Hand-poured in small batches with 100% natural soy wax, cotton wicks, and premium fragrance oils. Always paraffin-free, non-toxic, and phthalate-free for a cleaner, safer burn.

✨ Free shipping on orders $35+ ✨

Thank you for supporting handmade artistry!

Contact shop owner

Mattie Olson

Reviews

5.0 (192)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Etsy buyer on Dec 15, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Beautiful candles as always, beautiful scent.

Extra Soy Candles (Decorated), Luxury Scented Candle, Non Toxic Phthalate Free, Christmas Holiday Candle Scents, Christmas Gift Idea

Extra Soy Candles (Decorated), Luxury Scented Candle, Non Toxic Phthalate Free, Christmas Holiday Candle Scents, Christmas Gift Idea
Bethany on Dec 14, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

The scent of Birch Please is so lovely - we had a few of these candles lit around our wedding venue and got compliments on the scent all day!

Set of 3 4oz Customizable Soy Candle Wedding Favors, Bridal Shower Favors, Baby Shower Favors, Bridesmaid Gift, Wedding Party Gifts Favor

Set of 3 4oz Customizable Soy Candle Wedding Favors, Bridal Shower Favors, Baby Shower Favors, Bridesmaid Gift, Wedding Party Gifts Favor
Bethany on Dec 14, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Absolutely love these candles - this is my second time ordering them!! We gave them out as gifts for our wedding! ☺️

Set of 3 4oz Customizable Soy Candle Wedding Favors, Bridal Shower Favors, Baby Shower Favors, Bridesmaid Gift, Wedding Party Gifts Favor

Set of 3 4oz Customizable Soy Candle Wedding Favors, Bridal Shower Favors, Baby Shower Favors, Bridesmaid Gift, Wedding Party Gifts Favor
Etsy buyer on Dec 11, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

I love these candles, they make excellent gifts!

Extra Soy Candles (Decorated), Luxury Scented Candle, Non Toxic Phthalate Free, Christmas Holiday Candle Scents, Christmas Gift Idea

Extra Soy Candles (Decorated), Luxury Scented Candle, Non Toxic Phthalate Free, Christmas Holiday Candle Scents, Christmas Gift Idea
Steph on Nov 30, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Yummy. My most favorite candles ever!!

Twin Flame Bundle Deal - One to Burn, One to Display - Luxury Soy Candle Gift Set - Candle Set

Twin Flame Bundle Deal - One to Burn, One to Display - Luxury Soy Candle Gift Set - Candle Set
Kalli on Nov 26, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Best non toxic candles ever!!!

Basic (plain) Soy Candle, Non Toxic Soy Candle, Phthalate Free Long Burn Candle, Handmade Candle, Fall Candle Scents, Clean Burning Candle

Basic (plain) Soy Candle, Non Toxic Soy Candle, Phthalate Free Long Burn Candle, Handmade Candle, Fall Candle Scents, Clean Burning Candle
Hannah on Nov 20, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Packaged beautifully, first of all! Secondly, these will always be my favorite candles!!!

Basic (plain) Soy Candle, Non Toxic Soy Candle, Phthalate Free Long Burn Candle, Handmade Candle, Fall Candle Scents, Clean Burning Candle

Basic (plain) Soy Candle, Non Toxic Soy Candle, Phthalate Free Long Burn Candle, Handmade Candle, Fall Candle Scents, Clean Burning Candle
cheryl on Oct 21, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Beautifully crafted candle with quality ingredients. Got this for a gift for my out of town daughter and she absolutely loved it .

Candle of the Month Subscription Box, Large Soy Candle Subscription, Monthly Candle Club, Unique Gift Idea, Surprise Gifts Included

Candle of the Month Subscription Box, Large Soy Candle Subscription, Monthly Candle Club, Unique Gift Idea, Surprise Gifts Included
Rhonda on Sep 23, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Love these items! Excellent quality.

Decorated Soy Candle, Luxury Scented Candle, Soy Candle with Flowers, Winter Candles, Birthday Gift Candle, Gift for Her, Fall Scents

Decorated Soy Candle, Luxury Scented Candle, Soy Candle with Flowers, Winter Candles, Birthday Gift Candle, Gift for Her, Fall Scents
Rhonda on Apr 25, 2025

5 out of 5 stars

Love these candles! Exceptional quality!

Decorated Soy Candle, Luxury Scented Candle, Soy Candle with Flowers, Winter Candles, Birthday Gift Candle, Gift for Her

Decorated Soy Candle, Luxury Scented Candle, Soy Candle with Flowers, Winter Candles, Birthday Gift Candle, Gift for Her

About AlwaysExtraHandmade

Luxury Soy Candles - Non-Toxic & Phthalate Free

Sales 1,109

On Etsy since 2021

Luxury Soy Candles - Non-Toxic & Phthalate Free

Shop policies

Last updated on

Accepted payment methods

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

AlwaysExtraHandmade

Featured items

Candle of the Month Subscription Box, Large Soy Candle Subscription, Monthly Candle Club, Unique Gift Idea, Surprise Gifts Included

All items

Extra Soy Candles (Decorated), Luxury Scented Candle, Non Toxic Phthalate Free, Christmas Holiday Fragrance, Christmas Gift Idea

Basic Soy Candles (Plain), Non Toxic Phthalate Free Soy Candle, Long Burn Candle, Christmas Holiday Candle Scents, Christmas Gift Idea

Personalized Bridal Candle Gift, Wedding Party Candle Gift, Bridesmaid Gift, Maid of Honor Gift, Bridal Shower Gift, Wedding Candle Gift

Pet Memorial Candle, In Memory of Candle, Keepsake Gift, Loss of Pet Gift, Mourning Pet Death

Fruit Loops Soy Candle, Cereal Candle, Cool Candle Gift, Gift Idea

Candle of the Month Subscription Box, Large Soy Candle Subscription, Monthly Candle Club, Unique Gift Idea, Surprise Gifts Included

Memorial Candle, In Loving Memory Candle Gift, Soy Candle, Candle Keepsake Gift, Loss of a Loved One, Mourning, Rest In Peace

Announcement

Reviews

Report this review

About AlwaysExtraHandmade

Shop policies

Returns & exchanges