PaperAndPrayerIA

Des Moines, Iowa

14.5k
 Sales

5.0 (3.6k)

10 years
on Etsy

5.0 (3.6k)

14.5k
 sales

10 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

14.5k
 Sales

5.0 (3.6k)

10 years
on Etsy

5.0 (3.6k)

14.5k
 sales

10 years
on Etsy

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Mar 23, 2026

This is Paper and Prayer — stickers made to grow your faith and spark conversations about Jesus.

I'm Stephanie, a full-time church graphic designer and sticker maker who believes the best evangelism tool might just be a really good sticker. ✝️

I design every product to help women dig into God's Word, stay consistent in their Bible reading, and boldly share their faith with the world around them.

Bestsellers loved by thousands of women:
📖 Bible Reading Tracker Stickers
📚 Bible Bookshelf Tracker
✏️ Bible Study Journaling Stickers
🎁 Bible Study Gift Sets

Star Seller | 14,000+ orders | 5-star rated

Every purchase supports a woman-owned, faith-driven small business. Thank you for being here — now go be a light! ☀️

Contact shop owner

Stephanie Mathis

Reviews

5.0 (3635)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Arianna on Mar 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Love it so cute :)

New Girl TV Show Stickers: Funny Sitcom Quotes

New Girl TV Show Stickers: Funny Sitcom Quotes
Carrie on Mar 17, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Super cute and fast shipping!

New Girl TV Show Stickers: Funny Sitcom Quotes

New Girl TV Show Stickers: Funny Sitcom Quotes
Sarah on Mar 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Fast shipping. Just like described.

Yemen Sticker, Friends TV Show Sticker, Gift

Yemen Sticker, Friends TV Show Sticker, Gift
Karen on Jan 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

This is a great sticker for any Friends lover!!

Yemen Sticker, Friends TV Show Sticker, Gift

Yemen Sticker, Friends TV Show Sticker, Gift
emily on Mar 28, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Lovely sticker, great quality, arrived safely and packed well

Christmas Snow Globe Sticker, Gift

Christmas Snow Globe Sticker, Gift
R on Mar 22, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Exactly as depicted. Great sticker for my bottle.

Change the Ending Sticker: Motivational Vinyl Decal

Change the Ending Sticker: Motivational Vinyl Decal
Kelly on Mar 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Thank you! This was perfect size and color for my laptop!

In Omnia Paratus Umbrella Sticker - Gilmore Girls Waterproof Decal

In Omnia Paratus Umbrella Sticker - Gilmore Girls Waterproof Decal
Lisa on Mar 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Perfect! Image quality is great and so far seems to be holding up well to some abuse on a water bottle 🤣

Overstimulated Mom Sticker: Neutral Waterproof Vinyl Decal

Overstimulated Mom Sticker: Neutral Waterproof Vinyl Decal
Lisa on Mar 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

These were perfect! The image quality was spot on and the variety was great.

Schitts Creek Sticker Set: David Rose, Alexis, and Quotes

Schitts Creek Sticker Set: David Rose, Alexis, and Quotes
Rachel on Mar 19, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Love my sticker, so cute and fun!

Prison Mike Sticker: The Office TV Show, High-Gloss Vinyl

Prison Mike Sticker: The Office TV Show, High-Gloss Vinyl

About PaperAndPrayerIA

Faith Based Sticker Maker and Illustrator

Sales 14,470

On Etsy since 2015

Faith Based Sticker Maker and Illustrator

HEY BESTIE!

This girl loves Jesus and stickers!
Hi! I'm so happy you're here! I have made a business by making stickers based on life. I also like to think I'm pretty funny. I draw stickers on my iPad that relate to life! Most importantly, I love Jesus. I am a full time graphic designer for a church and I make my stickers to spread the Word and get more people excited about Jesus.

Shop members

Stephanie Mathis

Owner, Designer, Maker

Designer, Illustrator, Maker, Netflix Binge Watcher

Production partners

Gelato

United States

Print on Demand Company that prints and fulfills specific orders on my shop.
Print on Demand

United States

Print on Demand service

More production partners

Prints of Love

Salt Lake, UT

Prints of Love is a printing and shipping company that aids in printing posters and cards and shipping them out for my shop. Prints of Love offers high quality printing, fast US shipping and free envelopes!

Shop policies

Last updated on Oct 26, 2018

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Digital downloads

Instant downloads

Your files will be available to download once payment is confirmed. Here's how.

Payment options

Secure options

Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits

Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 24 hours of purchase

PaperAndPrayerIA

Featured items

Bible Reading Tracker, Books of the Bible Reading Plan

Transparent Bible Study Stickers: Doodle Style Journaling Stickers

Evergreen Bible Bookshelf Tracker Stickers: Reading Guide

Bible Study Set: Tracker, Tabs & Journaling Stickers

All items

Catholic Bible Bookshelf Tracker Sticker Set, Reading Plan

Books of the Bible Bookmark

His Mercies Are New Every Morning Bookmark

Pink Bow Ribbon Bookmark

Bible Reading Tracker, Books of the Bible Reading Plan, Patriotic theme

Pickle Coffee Cup, 15oz Ceramic Mug

School Teacher Coffee Cup, 15oz Ceramic Mug

Yes Lord White 15oz Ceramic Mug

Eat Pray Slay 15oz Ceramic Mug

Bible Reading Tracker Sticker

Per My Last Email Sticker, Sarcastic Sticker

Surviving Motherhood Sticker, Iced Coffee Mom Sticker

Ask Me About My Starter Sticker, Sourdough Sticker Gift

Disco Ball Sticker

Mompreneur Sticker: Chasing Dreams While Chasing Babies

God's Silliest Goose Sticker, Silly Goose Decal

Cherry Sticker, Cherries Decal

Consider the Wildflowers Sticker, Christian Sticker Gift

I Can't I'm Booked Sticker, Book Lover Sticker Gift

Bit of a Mess While Doing My Best Sticker, Relatable Mental Health Sticker

This is Fine Dumpster Fire Sticker, Funny Relatable Gift

I'd Rather Be Reading Sticker, Book Lover Sticker

Neuro Spicy Sticker, Relatable Neurodivergent Sticker

Hot Girls Have Tummy Problems Sticker, Funny Relatable Sticker

Bible Study Set: Tracker, Tabs & Journaling Stickers

Bible Study Tracker Stickers: Bookshelf Reading Guide

Bible Study Tracker Stickers: Bookshelf Reading Guide

Pastel Bible Bookshelf Tracker Stickers: Reading Guide

Evergreen Bible Bookshelf Tracker Stickers: Reading Guide

Transparent Bible Study Stickers: Doodle Style Journaling Stickers

Bible Reading Tracker, Books of the Bible Reading Plan

Go On with your Grad Self Graduation Card, hand painted funny greeting card

Days Since Last Nonsense sticker, Vinyl TV Show Sticker, Office TV Show Gift, Gift, The Office Sticker

WWJD Bracelet Sticker - Christian Vinyl Decal

Won't He Do It Sticker: Christian Vinyl Decal, Bible Gift

Too Good to Not Believe Sticker: Waterproof Vinyl Christian Decal

Announcement

Reviews

About PaperAndPrayerIA

Shop members

Stephanie Mathis

Production partners

Shop policies

Shipping

Customs and import taxes

Digital downloads

Payment options

Returns & exchanges

Cancellations