SandDStitches

Lockport, Illinois

10.8k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (1.9k)
15 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (1.9k)
10.8k
sales
15 years
on Etsy
10.8k
Sales
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (1.9k)
15 years
on Etsy
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0 (1.9k)
10.8k
sales
15 years
on Etsy
Request Custom Order
Contact shop owner
10786 Sales
1877 Admirers
Report this shop to Etsy

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

 

Featured items

All items

May include: A white pillow with a floral pattern and a gold embroidered letter H and the name "Harper". A white felt tooth with a pink and blue smiling face is on the pillow. The pillow has a pink ribbon handle.

Tooth fairy pillow for girls personalized with Tooth Chart Option

$38.50

5 people have this in their cart
May include: A blue pillow with a green letter J and the name "James" embroidered in red. The pillow also features a white tooth with a smiling face and red cheeks. The background of the pillow is covered in colorful lizards.

Tooth Fairy Pillow for Boys Lizards Reptiles - Boys Room Decor - Tooth Chart - Reptile Decor - Keepsake - Kids Birthday Gift

$38.50

May include: A blue and white pillow with a space-themed print. The pillow has a large blue letter "R" with the name "Ryan" embroidered in white. There is a white tooth with a red smile and red cheeks on the pillow.

Space Themed Tooth Fairy Pillow for Boys Personalized

$38.50

May include: White burp cloth with red and blue embroidery that reads "The Cowboys Make Me Puke" and a brown football with red stripes. Below the football is red embroidery that reads "Go Giants".

New York Giants Baby Burp cloth Baseball Baby Shower Personalized Gift New Baby Gift Baby New Baby Gift

$25.00

4 people have this in their cart
May include: A white rectangular kitchen towel featuring embroidered text in orange and black thread that reads The Packers Make Me Puke Go Bears. Below the text is an embroidered football in orange, black, and white thread with stitching details.

Chicago Bears Baby Gift - Burp cloth - Football - Baby Shower Personalized Gift - New Baby Gift - Baby Boy - New Baby Gift

$25.00

12 people have this in their cart
May include: A pink and white pillow with a floral pattern. The pillow has a large pink letter E with the name "Ellie" embroidered in blue. There is a white tooth with a smiling face embroidered on the pillow.

Tooth fairy pillow for girls personalized with Tooth Chart Option

$38.50

3 people have this in their cart
May include: White burp cloth with the text "The Red Sox Make Me Puke" in black and gray lettering. A red and white baseball is embroidered below the text.

Yankees Baby- Burp cloth - Baseball - Baby Shower Personalized Gift - New Baby Gift - Baby Boy - Yankees Fan - New Baby Gift

$25.00

4 people have this in their cart
May include: A brown and tan pillow with a football pattern. The pillow has a large blue letter "R" with the name "Reid" embroidered in green. There is a white tooth with a smiling face and green eyes on the pillow.

Tooth Fairy Pillow Personalized

$37.00

May include: White baseball-themed towel with the embroidered text "The Yankees Make Me Puke" in red and navy blue. A baseball with red stitching is embroidered below the text.

Red Sox Baby Burp cloth Baseball Baby Shower Personalized Gift New Baby Gift Baby New Baby Gift Boston

$25.00

5 people have this in their cart
May include: Red pillow with blue trim and a white tooth with a smiling face, two crossed hockey sticks, a black puck, and the name "Darin" embroidered in blue.

Tooth Fairy Pillow Hockey Theme Personalized

$37.00

May include: A blue pillow with a white tooth and orange letter J. The pillow has a green and orange lizard pattern. The letter J is embroidered with the name "Jack".

Tooth Fairy Pillow Boys

$38.50

May include: A black and blue pillow with a space theme. The pillow has a large blue letter "I" with the name "Ian" embroidered in orange. A white tooth with a smiling face is also embroidered on the pillow.

Boys Tooth Fairy Pillow Tooth Chart Space Moon Planets Galaxy

$38.50

May include: A blue pillow with a white tooth and the name "Chase" embroidered in red. The pillow has a shark pattern.

Tooth Fairy Pillow Boys Personalized - Ocean - Fish - Shark - Tooth Chart - Kids Gift - Birthday - Milestone - Baby Gift - Ring Bearer

$37.00

May include: White burp cloth with black embroidery that reads "The Cubs Make Me Puke" with a black and white baseball graphic and the name "Ella" embroidered below.

White Sox Baby - Baby Shower Gift - New Baby Gift - Baseball baby

$25.00

May include: A white kitchen towel featuring embroidered text that reads The Cowboys Make Me Puke and Go 49ers, accompanied by an embroidered football graphic with red and black stitching details.

San Francisco 49ers fan Baby gift

$25.00

May include: A rectangular fabric pillow with a dusty pink ribbon handle and bow. The pillow features a floral print, a large embroidered pink letter H, the name Harper in green script, and a white tooth applique with a smiling face.

Tooth fairy pillow for girls personalized with Tooth Chart Option

$38.50

May include: A small rectangular pillow with a light blue and white gingham pattern featuring a red cherry print. It has a red ribbon handle and bow, a large red polka-dot letter H, the name Harper in yellow script, and a white tooth applique.

Tooth fairy pillow for girls personalized with Tooth Chart Option

$38.50

May include: A white pillow with a gray embroidered letter J and the name Jack in blue embroidery. The pillow has a white tooth with a smiling face and red cheeks. The background is a white fabric with a pattern of superheroes, including Iron Man, Captain America, Hulk, and Thor.

Superhero Tooth Fairy Pillow with Tooth Chart Option

$37.00

May include: A black and blue pillow with a space theme. The pillow has a large orange S with the name "Spencer" embroidered in white. There is a white tooth with a smiling face and red cheeks on the right side of the pillow.

Tooth Fairy Pillow for Boys Personalized Custom Made Space Moon and Stars - Tooth Chart - Boys Gift - Ring Bearer

$36.50

May include: Purple pillow with white polka dots, a white tooth with a pink smiling face, and the name "Ashley" embroidered in white. The pillow has a purple handle.

Girls Tooth Fairy Pillow, Personalized, Tooth Chart, Baby Girl, Baby Shower Gift, Personalized Gift Girls, Keepsake for Kids, Flower Gilt

$38.50

May include: A rainbow-colored pillow with white polka dots and a pink embroidered letter L. The pillow has the name "Lenna Joy" embroidered on it and a white felt tooth with a smiling face. The pillow has a pink ribbon loop for hanging.

Tooth fairy pillow for girls personalized with Tooth Chart Option

$38.50

Green Bay Packers Baby Gift - Burp cloth - Football - Baby Shower Personalized Gift - New Baby Gift - Baby Boy - Packers Fan - New Baby Gift

Green Bay Packers Baby Gift - Burp cloth - Football - Baby Shower Personalized Gift - New Baby Gift - Baby Boy - Packers Fan - New Baby Gift

$25.00

May include: A blue and red pillow with a superhero theme. The pillow has a large blue letter E with the name Ethan embroidered in red. There is a white tooth with a red smiling face on the pillow.

Superhero Tooth Pillow

$37.00

May include: A brown and tan football-themed tooth fairy pillow with the name "Alex" embroidered in green on a yellow letter "A". A smiling tooth applique is on the right side. A green ribbon is attached for hanging.

Tooth Fairy Pillow - Personalized - Football - Christmas Gift - Birthday Gift - Baby Gift

$37.00

May include: Blue pillow with white embroidery of the name "Shane" and two hockey sticks. A white tooth with a smiling face and blue eyes is embroidered on the right side of the pillow.

Tooth Fairy Pillow - Personalized - Hockey

$37.00

May include: A pink pillow with a white handle and bow. The pillow has a large pink letter "H" with the name "Harper" embroidered in blue. A white tooth with a smiling face is on the right side of the pillow.

Tooth fairy pillow for girls personalized with Tooth Chart Option

$38.50

May include: White burp cloth with red embroidered text that reads "The Raiders Make Me Puke" and a brown football with red stitching. Below the football is red embroidered text that reads "Go Chiefs".

Chiefs Baby Burp Cloth

$25.00

May include: Red pillow with blue and white embroidery. The pillow features a large blue letter J and the name Joshua. A white tooth with a smiling face is embroidered on the right side of the pillow. The text "S&D Stitches" is embroidered in the top right corner.

Tooth Fairy Pillow for Boys Personalized Tooth Chart Christmas Gift Birthday Gift Baby Gift Ring Bearer Gift Easter

$38.50

May include: White baseball-themed hand towel with embroidered text: "The Yankees Make Me Puke" in black and orange. A baseball graphic is below the text, and the name "Remi" is embroidered in orange.

Yankees Baby- Burp cloth - Baseball - Baby Shower Personalized Gift - New Baby Gift - Baby Boy - Yankees Fan - New Baby Gift

$25.00

May include: White fabric burp cloth with red and gold embroidery. The text reads "The Seahawks Make Me Puke" and "Go Niners!" with a brown and gold football graphic.

49ers - Burp cloth - Football - Baby Shower Personalized Gift - New Baby Gift - Baby Boy - New Baby Gift

$25.00

May include: White baby blanket with blue and red embroidered text that reads "The Cubs Make Me Puke" and a baseball graphic. The baseball is blue with red stitching.

Cleveland Indians Baby- Burp cloth - Baseball - Baby Shower Personalized Gift - New Baby Gift - Baby Boy - Cleveland Fan - New Baby Gift

$25.00

May include: A brown and tan pillow with a football pattern. The pillow has a large blue letter K with the name "Kellan" embroidered in orange. A white tooth with a smiling face and orange cheeks is on the right side of the pillow.

Tooth Fairy Pillow Personalized Chicago Bears Colors

$37.00

May include: A red and white pillow with a baseball pattern. The pillow has a large red letter "J" with black stitching and the name "Jack" stitched in black. There is a white tooth with a smiling face and red cheeks stitched on the pillow. The pillow has the text "S&D Stitches" stitched on the bottom.

Tooth Fairy Pillow Personalized - Baseball Theme - Tooth Chart

$37.00

May include: A blue and red pillow with white polka dots. The pillow has the name "Jack" embroidered in red with a white outline. A white tooth with a red smiling face is embroidered on the right side of the pillow. The pillow has a red and white ribbon loop for hanging. The text "S&D Stitches" is embroidered in the bottom right corner.

Tooth Fairy Pillow for Boys - Personalized - Christmas Gift - Birthday Gift - Baby Gift - Ring Bearer Gift

$38.50

May include: A tan pillow with a baseball print. The pillow has a red embroidered name "Gavin" and a white embroidered tooth with a smiling face and red cheeks.

Tooth Fairy Pillow Personalized Baseball Theme

$34.75

May include: A green camouflage pillow with a brown embroidered letter N and the name "Nate" in orange. A white tooth with a smiling face and brown cheeks is embroidered on the right side of the pillow. The text "S&D Stitches" is embroidered in orange at the bottom of the pillow.

Tooth Fairy Pillow Boy Personalized Camouflage Camo - Christmas Gift - Birthday Gift - Baby Gift - Ring Bearer - Camo Birthday - Hunting

$38.50

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Jun 17, 2023
Denise

Contact shop owner

Denise

Contact shop owner

Reviews

5.0 (1877)
Average item review
We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

About SandDStitches

Tooth Fairy Pillows for boys and girls 🌸 Personalized

Sales 10,786
On Etsy since 2011

Tooth Fairy Pillows for boys and girls 🌸 Personalized

I love creating special keepsakes for thousands of children around the world!!

Shop members

  • shop-member-photo
    Denise

    Owner, Designer

Shop policies

Last updated on Feb 25, 2021

Shipping

See item details for estimated arrival times.

Customs and import taxes

For US deliveries, Etsy policy requires that import duties and fees are included in the checkout price. Non-US buyers may need to pay these fees upon delivery. You can message me to confirm how these fees will be paid for your order. I'm not responsible for any customs-related delays.

Payment options

Secure options
Paypal Visa Mastercard Discover Apple Pay Klarna Giftcard
Accepts Etsy Gift Cards and Etsy Credits
Etsy keeps your payment information secure. Etsy shops never receive your credit card information.

Returns & exchanges

See item details for return and exchange eligibility.

Cancellations

Cancellations: accepted

Request a cancellation: within 4 hours of purchase

More information

Last updated on Dec 17, 2025

Frequently asked questions

What if I added incorrect address to my order?

If orders are returned due to incorrect shipping address, buyer will be responsible for shipping charges to resend the order. Please verify your shipping address is correct on order.

Custom and personalized orders

I am happy to work with you to design a pillow in a fabric of your choice. Please message me with what you have in mind and we can work together to create a custom listing.

What are the options available for the tooth pocket?

There are 4 options to choose from: make the tooth a pocket on the front, a plain pocket made of matching material on the back, a pocket on back with wording on it (ex: My Tooth), or a pocket on the back with a tooth chart where you can log the date of each lost tooth.