Etsy’s Picks are hand selected by our style experts to highlight items from shops that have shown quality, reliability and style.

Discover More

  • May include: A set of keys with a hand-forged, dark gray metal keychain. The keychain has a series of etched lines and is attached to a gold-colored ring. The keys are silver and gold-toned, resting on a wooden surface.
  • May include: Three metal keychains with bronze-colored key rings. Each keychain is a rectangular shape with a series of etched tally marks and a single vertical line. The keychains are made of a dark, textured metal.
  • May include: A blacksmith forges a piece of red-hot metal with a hammer and stamp. The text "Hand forged and stamped" is displayed. The image shows the process of metalworking, highlighting the heat and force involved in the craft.
  • May include: A collection of personalized metal keychains with bronze-colored key rings. Each rectangular keychain is engraved with dates, initials, and the phrase "I ❤️ YOU". The keychains are arranged on a wooden surface.
  • May include: Close-up of several metal keychains with engraved text and dates. The keychains are attached to brass-colored key rings. The text includes initials, dates, and a heart symbol. The keychains are made of a dark gray metal.
  • May include: Several metal keychains with stamped text and dates, including "I LOVE YOU" and "6TH". The keychains are silver-colored and attached to brass-colored key rings. The background is a wooden surface with tools.
  • May include: A collection of personalized metal keychains with stamped text and dates. The keychains are rectangular with rounded edges and attached to bronze-colored key rings. The text includes names, initials, dates, and heart symbols.
  • May include: A hand-forged metal keychain with a brass ring. The rectangular tag features etched tally marks, indicating a count of 11. The metal has a dark, textured finish, and the keychain is held in an open palm.
  • May include: A copper-colored metal plate with various symbols and characters stamped into it. Symbols include an infinity sign, paw print, cross, clover, anchor, heart, ampersand, star, lightning bolt, and mathematical symbols.
  • May include: A set of keys with a hand-forged, dark gray metal keychain. The keychain has a series of etched lines and is attached to a gold-colored ring. The keys are silver and gold-toned, resting on a wooden surface.
  • Product video
  • May include: Three metal keychains with bronze-colored key rings. Each keychain is a rectangular shape with a series of etched tally marks and a single vertical line. The keychains are made of a dark, textured metal.
  • May include: A blacksmith forges a piece of red-hot metal with a hammer and stamp. The text "Hand forged and stamped" is displayed. The image shows the process of metalworking, highlighting the heat and force involved in the craft.
  • May include: A collection of personalized metal keychains with bronze-colored key rings. Each rectangular keychain is engraved with dates, initials, and the phrase "I ❤️ YOU". The keychains are arranged on a wooden surface.
  • May include: Close-up of several metal keychains with engraved text and dates. The keychains are attached to brass-colored key rings. The text includes initials, dates, and a heart symbol. The keychains are made of a dark gray metal.
  • May include: Several metal keychains with stamped text and dates, including "I LOVE YOU" and "6TH". The keychains are silver-colored and attached to brass-colored key rings. The background is a wooden surface with tools.
  • May include: A collection of personalized metal keychains with stamped text and dates. The keychains are rectangular with rounded edges and attached to bronze-colored key rings. The text includes names, initials, dates, and heart symbols.
  • May include: A hand-forged metal keychain with a brass ring. The rectangular tag features etched tally marks, indicating a count of 11. The metal has a dark, textured finish, and the keychain is held in an open palm.
  • May include: A copper-colored metal plate with various symbols and characters stamped into it. Symbols include an infinity sign, paw print, cross, clover, anchor, heart, ampersand, star, lightning bolt, and mathematical symbols.
Report this item to Etsy

11 Tally Marks Steel Anniversary Key Chain Gift. Personalized 11th anniversary

AdirondackIron  
5 out of 5 stars

Item highlights

  • Materials: mild steel
  • Dimensions: Length: 2.25 Inches
  • Made to order

Seller's description

This is a blacksmith hand-forged key chain made from 3/8" mild steel. It will have the 11 tally marks on the front with the option for personalization on the back. These are made and stamped with antique blacksmithing tools! Because of that, each key chain is one of a kind and shows all the hammer marks that come with being hand hammered. Each line is marked individually and wont be exactly even. They have a wonderful feel in the hand, unlike anything you can buy in the store! These make a great 11th (steel) anniversary gift. Many people like to include a name or their anniversary date.

These are about 2.25 inches long by 3/8" square. The brass ring is 1 inch outer diameter. The finish is a light coat of linseed oil.

This will have 11 tally marks on the front with the option of purchasing 8 characters of personalization on the back. If you want to include periods "." or slashes "/" they do not count towards the 8. This way you can do ♥11TH♥, ♥H&H♥, I LOVE YOU, I STILL DO, A+B=♥, HOGAN B., 10.12.2012 , 12/12/2012, EST. 2014, etc. I can do some other symbols too, just check out the last listing image. Please send me a quick message with the "Message Hogan" button if this is unclear.

Thanks for looking!

View more

Item review

Why this review appears

All reviews are from verified buyers. This review is shown automatically based on factors like recency, whether it includes comments, your chosen language, and whether the rating reflects the typical experience with the shop.

Summarized by AI

Great quality Fast shipping Perfect gift Love it As described Looks great Helpful seller

“Such an amazing gift for my husband for our 11th wedding anniversary he loved it”

Marsha

3 days ago

View all

In 10 carts

Price:$28.00+

Please select an option

  • If you purchase personalization for the back of the keychain please enter exactly what you would like stamped. I do capital letters, numbers, and some common symbols. 8 characters or fewer please. Send me a message if you have any questions!

    0/500

You can only make an offer when buying a single item

Shipping & return policies
  • Get it by
    Oct 28-Nov 2
  • Returns & exchanges
    Accepted within 7 days
  • Cost to ship
    $5.48 to United States, 43215.

    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

Reviews for this item

What buyers say, summarized by AI: Great quality Fast shipping Perfect gift Love it As described Looks great Helpful seller

5.0

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

(194 reviews)

5.0 Item quality
5.0 Shipping
5.0 Customer service
100% Buyers recommend
Filter by category
5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Marsha Oct 20, 2026

Such an amazing gift for my husband for our 11th wedding anniversary he loved it

Marsha Oct 20, 2026

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Jacqueline Oct 6, 2026

Beautiful piece, am excited to gift it ! Keychain artwork :)

Jacqueline Oct 6, 2026

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Mercedes Sep 1, 2026

Great handmade unique piece perfect for an anniversary! Exactly as described. Fast shipping.

Mercedes Sep 1, 2026

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Cassie Aug 30, 2026

the key chain shipped quick and as expected!

Cassie Aug 30, 2026

Photos from reviews

Seller's description

Specifications

May include: A set of keys with a hand-forged, dark gray metal keychain. The keychain has a series of etched lines and is attached to a gold-colored ring. The keys are silver and gold-toned, resting on a wooden surface.

This is a blacksmith hand-forged key chain made from 3/8" mild steel. It will have the 11 tally marks on the front with the option for personalization on the back. These are made and stamped with antique blacksmithing tools! Because of that, each key chain is one of a kind and shows all the hammer marks that come with being hand hammered. Each line is marked individually and wont be exactly even. They have a wonderful feel in the hand, unlike anything you can buy in the store! These make a great 11th (steel) anniversary gift. Many people like to include a name or their anniversary date.

These are about 2.25 inches long by 3/8" square. The brass ring is 1 inch outer diameter. The finish is a light coat of linseed oil.

This will have 11 tally marks on the front with the option of purchasing 8 characters of personalization on the back. If you want to include periods "." or slashes "/" they do not count towards the 8. This way you can do ♥11TH♥, ♥H&H♥, I LOVE YOU, I STILL DO, A+B=♥, HOGAN B., 10.12.2012 , 12/12/2012, EST. 2014, etc. I can do some other symbols too, just check out the last listing image. Please send me a quick message with the "Message Hogan" button if this is unclear.

Thanks for looking!

Delivery details and policies

  • Get it by
    Oct 28-Nov 2
  • Returns and exchanges
    Accepted within 7 days.
  • Ships from
    Moira, NY
  • Cost to ship
    $5.48 to United States, 43215

    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

    There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Shop with confidence
Star Seller

This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped orders on time, and replied quickly to messages.

Etsy Purchase Protection

If something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back on all eligible purchases. View program terms

Climate investments

Etsy supports climate solutions, from electric delivery trucks to carbon offsets for every delivery. View how

Meet your seller

AdirondackIron
Hogan Baker
AdirondackIron ·

Moira, New York

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 5.0
·
20.8k sales
·
9 years on Etsy
Hogan
1 shop member

Usually responds in a few hours

Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.

View shop registration details

You may also like

Shoppers with similar taste loved these

Show more
Show more
Assortment of wedding items that are available on EtsyAssortment of wedding items that are available on EtsyAssortment of wedding items that are available on Etsy

Get personalized picks for your big day!

Wedding date
No date yet? Explore wedding ideasOpens a new tab

Top wedding searches to shop

Bridesmaid gifts

Groomsmen gifts

Wedding gifts

Engagement gifts

Explore related searches

Steel Key Chain

11 Year Wedding Anniversary Gift

11th Anniversary Gift for Him

Boss Anniversary

Steel Gifts for Women

Steel Anniversary Gifts for Her

Personalized Anniversary Gift

11 Year Keychain

11th Anniversary Traditional

Listed on Oct 21, 2026
782 favorites
Homepage Accessories Keychains & Lanyards Keychains

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy