• May include: A silver-toned metal keychain featuring a circular split ring, a small silver cross charm, and a copper-colored penny charm. The penny is stamped with the black text "Drive Safe" followed by a small heart symbol.
  • May include: A silver-toned metal keychain featuring a copper-colored United States penny coin. The coin is stamped with the text IN GOD WE TRUST and LIBERTY, and features a black engraved heart outline containing the number 26 on the front.
  • May include: A copper-colored penny keychain featuring the stamped text "Drive Safe" and a small heart outline next to the year "2022". The coin is attached to a circular silver-toned metal split ring by a small jump ring, creating a functional accessory.
  • Drive Safe sweet 16 Hand Stamped Genuine US Penny Keychain with or without Cross 16th Birthday Gift Christian Gift stocking stuffer image 4
  • May include: A light blue organza drawstring pouch featuring a multicolored gradient branch pattern in shades of red, orange, and blue. Inside the semi-transparent bag, a silver metal keychain is visible along with a white card with printed text.
  • May include: A white informational graphic with black text titled Helpful Tips for ordering. It lists instructions regarding item descriptions, custom requests, adding charms or pennies to keychains, stamping limitations, gift packaging, and address verification.
  • May include: A white background featuring black and teal text that reads: Rustic Midwest Charm, Personalized Hand Stamped Gifts, My passion for crafting meaningful keepsakes stems from a deep appreciation for the little moments that make life beautiful. Whether it's a milestone anniversary, a memorable vacation, or a heartfelt message to a loved one, my penny keychains serve as a tangible reminder of the moments that matter most. It is often a belief that our passed loved ones will leave pennies or other coins in unusual places along our paths as a sign that they are watching over us. Message me with any questions you may have.
  • May include: A metal stamping kit featuring multiple sets of steel letter and design stamps organized in colorful plastic trays, a brass-headed hammer, metal pliers, a steel bench block, and a small business card labeled Basic Midwest Charms.
  • May include: A workspace featuring a blue plastic bin filled with copper coins and silver key rings, a clear container of silver rings, a rack of metal stamping tools, purple-handled pliers, a roll of fragile tape, and a small informational card.
  • May include: A silver-toned metal keychain featuring a circular split ring, a small silver cross charm, and a copper-colored penny charm. The penny is stamped with the black text "Drive Safe" followed by a small heart symbol.
  • Product video
  • May include: A silver-toned metal keychain featuring a copper-colored United States penny coin. The coin is stamped with the text IN GOD WE TRUST and LIBERTY, and features a black engraved heart outline containing the number 26 on the front.
  • May include: A copper-colored penny keychain featuring the stamped text "Drive Safe" and a small heart outline next to the year "2022". The coin is attached to a circular silver-toned metal split ring by a small jump ring, creating a functional accessory.
  • Drive Safe sweet 16 Hand Stamped Genuine US Penny Keychain with or without Cross 16th Birthday Gift Christian Gift stocking stuffer image 4
  • May include: A light blue organza drawstring pouch featuring a multicolored gradient branch pattern in shades of red, orange, and blue. Inside the semi-transparent bag, a silver metal keychain is visible along with a white card with printed text.
  • May include: A white informational graphic with black text titled Helpful Tips for ordering. It lists instructions regarding item descriptions, custom requests, adding charms or pennies to keychains, stamping limitations, gift packaging, and address verification.
  • May include: A white background featuring black and teal text that reads: Rustic Midwest Charm, Personalized Hand Stamped Gifts, My passion for crafting meaningful keepsakes stems from a deep appreciation for the little moments that make life beautiful. Whether it's a milestone anniversary, a memorable vacation, or a heartfelt message to a loved one, my penny keychains serve as a tangible reminder of the moments that matter most. It is often a belief that our passed loved ones will leave pennies or other coins in unusual places along our paths as a sign that they are watching over us. Message me with any questions you may have.
  • May include: A metal stamping kit featuring multiple sets of steel letter and design stamps organized in colorful plastic trays, a brass-headed hammer, metal pliers, a steel bench block, and a small business card labeled Basic Midwest Charms.
  • May include: A workspace featuring a blue plastic bin filled with copper coins and silver key rings, a clear container of silver rings, a rack of metal stamping tools, purple-handled pliers, a roll of fragile tape, and a small informational card.
View buyer photos
Report this item to Etsy

Drive Safe sweet 16 Hand Stamped Genuine US Penny Keychain with or without Cross 16th Birthday Gift Christian Gift stocking stuffer

RusticMidwestCharm  
5 out of 5 stars

Item highlights

  • Materials: Copper, Enamel, Stainless steel
  • Made to order

Seller's description

Custom Personalized Teen, Husband, Boyfriend, Son, Daughter Gift for reminding your loved one to "Drive Safe".
Drive Safe Penny with optional silver Cross Keychain, Gift for 16th Birthday, New Car, New Driver, Gifts for Christians, Daughter , Son, Grandson, Granddaughter gifts for safe driving, good luck charm

They'll Carry their lucky penny with them everywhere 🪙🔑

This Listing includes a genuine US Hand Stamped Penny, "Drive Safe" and heart around year, optional silver cross charm, on a sturdy silver key ring in an organza drawstring bag, ready for gift giving!

TO Order;
Choose to add cross or No cross
Leave me year for your penny in the personalization area **if year is not left, I'll use current year**
(2026 and all future years will be hand stamped years as shown in listing photo, please scroll through all photos)
If you'd like a name instead of drive safe please leave me exact stamping instructions

add item to cart
complete checkout

Hand stamping is a process where each letter is individually stamped into the metal. Each letter may not line up perfectly and some letters may be deeper than the others. This is not to be considered a defect and adds to the charm of each piece. This process is much deeper than engraving.

Each piece is shipped in an organza drawstring bag and mailed in a bubble mailer to arrive safely from my studio to your door!

Thank you for shopping Rustic Midwest Charm, and have a wonderful day!
ONLY AUTHENTIC U.S. Pennies are Used for listings with Pennies.

View more

6 views in the last 24 hours

Price:$11.37+

Original Price: $17.50+

35% off

•

Limited time sale

Please select an option

  • Leave year for penny here please; (if you'd like to have name stamped instead of drive safe let me know here as well)

    0/256

You can only make an offer when buying a single item

Shipping & return policies
  • Get it by
    Nov 16-20
  • Cost to ship
    $5.89 to United States, 43215.

    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

Reviews for this item

What buyers say, summarized by AI: Perfect gift Love it Looks great Fast shipping As described Great quality Helpful seller

5.0

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

(151 reviews)

4.9 Item quality
5.0 Shipping
5.0 Customer service
98% Buyers recommend
Filter by category
5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

April Oct 19, 2026

Perfect gift for my daughter turning 16. She loved it

April Oct 19, 2026

Response from Rustic Midwest Charm

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave your wonderful review 🫶

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Evelyn Oct 3, 2026

My son loved it and put it on his keys right away!

Evelyn Oct 3, 2026

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Sue Sep 16, 2026

Beautifully done! Made a great sweet 16 gift!

Sue Sep 16, 2026

Response from Rustic Midwest Charm

Sue, I'm so grateful for your purchase and kind review. My mended heart thanks you do very much❤️‍🩹🫶 Each and every order helps my son and I now, to afford to survive, as my shop is my only income since my surgery and chronic complications. Thank you

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Pamela Sep 9, 2026

gift for grandson, new driver

Pamela Sep 9, 2026

Photos from reviews

Seller's description

Specifications

May include: A silver-toned metal keychain featuring a circular split ring, a small silver cross charm, and a copper-colored penny charm. The penny is stamped with the black text "Drive Safe" followed by a small heart symbol.

Custom Personalized Teen, Husband, Boyfriend, Son, Daughter Gift for reminding your loved one to "Drive Safe".
Drive Safe Penny with optional silver Cross Keychain, Gift for 16th Birthday, New Car, New Driver, Gifts for Christians, Daughter , Son, Grandson, Granddaughter gifts for safe driving, good luck charm

They'll Carry their lucky penny with them everywhere 🪙🔑

This Listing includes a genuine US Hand Stamped Penny, "Drive Safe" and heart around year, optional silver cross charm, on a sturdy silver key ring in an organza drawstring bag, ready for gift giving!

TO Order;
Choose to add cross or No cross
Leave me year for your penny in the personalization area **if year is not left, I'll use current year**
(2026 and all future years will be hand stamped years as shown in listing photo, please scroll through all photos)
If you'd like a name instead of drive safe please leave me exact stamping instructions

add item to cart
complete checkout

Hand stamping is a process where each letter is individually stamped into the metal. Each letter may not line up perfectly and some letters may be deeper than the others. This is not to be considered a defect and adds to the charm of each piece. This process is much deeper than engraving.

Each piece is shipped in an organza drawstring bag and mailed in a bubble mailer to arrive safely from my studio to your door!

Thank you for shopping Rustic Midwest Charm, and have a wonderful day!
ONLY AUTHENTIC U.S. Pennies are Used for listings with Pennies.

  • Made by
    RusticMidwestCharm
  • Materials
    Copper, enamel, stainless steel
  • Material features
    Upcycled

Delivery details and policies

  • Get it by
    Nov 16-20
  • Returns and exchanges
    Not accepted.
  • Ships from
    Janesville, WI
  • Cost to ship
    $5.89 to United States, 43215

    Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.

    There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Shop with confidence
Star Seller

This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped orders on time, and replied quickly to messages.

Etsy Purchase Protection

If something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back on all eligible purchases. View program terms

Climate investments

Etsy supports climate solutions, from electric delivery trucks to carbon offsets for every delivery. View how

Meet your seller

RusticMidwestCharm
Rustic Midwest Charm
RusticMidwestCharm ·

McHenry, Illinois

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9
·
51.6k sales
·
10 years on Etsy
Kimberly E, Designer, Photographer, Social Media, Advertising, Packing, Shipping, most importantly; Mom & heart valve surgery warrior! Luna
2 shop members

Usually responds in a few hours

Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.

You may also like

Shoppers with similar taste loved these

Show more
Show more
Listed on Nov 10, 2026
968 favorites
Homepage Accessories Keychains & Lanyards Keychains

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy