*Machine wash at a low heat. *Wash garments inside-out, with similar colors. *Do not use fabric softeners. *Tumble dry on a low cycle. Hang-dry for longer life. *Cool iron inside-out. Do not iron directly on the print/embroidery. *Do not dry clean.

Please see individual listings for sizing details. All clothing is unisex, if you like the oversize look size up 1-2 sizes :)

Wholesale availability

Please message me for wholesale availability.

Report this item to Etsy

In 9 carts

Price:$2.70+

Original Price: $3.00+

10% off

•

Limited time sale

Mystery Shirt - Small Defects/Holes/Production Stains - Comfort Colors Mystery Shirts, Short Sleeve or Long Sleeve

Name: Mystery Shirt - Small Defects/Holes/Production Stains - Comfort Colors Mystery Shirts, Short Sleeve or Long Sleeve
Brand: SugarPearlCo
SKU: 1498941823
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.9 (4513 reviews)

SugarPearlCo

Arrives soon! Get it by Jun 17-23 if you order today

Size

Please select an option

Quantity

You can only make an offer when buying a single item

Star Seller. This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped on time, and replied quickly to any messages they received.

Highlights

Made by SugarPearlCo
Gift wrapping available
See details

✨ MYSTERY SHIRT – Surprise Yourself! ✨

Love a good surprise? Our Mystery Shirt is the perfect way to snag a cute, embroidered piece at a discounted price! Every item is hand-selected and completely random, making it extra fun to open 💖

Each mystery shirt may include a variety of brands such as Comfort Colors, Gildan, Chicka D, Bella Canvas, and more. Styles, colors, and fits will vary depending on what’s available.

💡 What to Expect:

A completely random embroidered shirt
May feature designs not currently listed in my shop
Could include custom or one-of-a-kind designs
Variety of shirt brands, colors, and styles

⚠️ Please Note:

Items may have minor imperfections such as a small stain, tiny hole, or slight embroidery flaw
All items are still fully wearable and functional
You may receive duplicates if ordering more than one
Mama/mom designs are included

This is a final sale item due to the mystery nature, but that’s part of the fun! 🎁

Thank you so much for supporting my small business! 💕

Order today to get by Jun 17-23
Returns & exchanges not accepted
Cost to ship: $5.00
Ships from: Hesperia, CA

There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Country

Zip code

Please enter a valid zip code.

Etsy Purchase Protection
Shop confidently on Etsy knowing if something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases — see program terms

Etsy invests in climate solutions like electric trucks and carbon offsets for every delivery. See how

Alexis

Owner of SugarPearlCo

Following Follow shop

Message Alexis

This seller usually responds within a few hours.

View shop registration details

Reviews for this item

What buyers say, summarized by AI: Love it Looks great Great quality Helpful seller Comfortable Fast shipping Soft

5.0

(110 reviews)

5.0 Item quality

5.0 Shipping

5.0 Customer service

98% Buyers recommend

5 This item

Gabrielle May 30, 2026

Shirts were perfect. Loved the muted colors I received

Gabrielle May 30, 2026

5 This item

Sarah May 26, 2026

this is such a fun idea & will buy again!

Sarah May 26, 2026

5 This item

Alex May 19, 2026

there was a mix-up with orders, so there was a delay, but the seller was quick to remedy the situation and my shirt arrived quickly afterwards! i love my mystery shirt and it’s super cute!

Alex May 19, 2026

5 This item

Alex May 13, 2026

we ended up receiving someone else’s order, but the seller was quick to remedy it! my spouse ended up with a love is love shirt and they have been needing a new pride shirt. it is super cute and i highly recommend ordering from this shop. i think this was our third time ordering and i promise you won’t be disappointed! we love ordering the mystery items!!

Alex May 13, 2026