What is Blind Date with a Book?

Experience the charm of a blind date with a book where preconceptions are set aside, and the magic of discovery takes center stage! All you need to do is pick the genre and we'll thoughtfully handpick a book for you, keeping its title and author a delightful mystery until you unwrap it. Our surprise books are beautifully wrapped in eco-friendly brown paper and adorned with enchanting eclectic, cottage core and dark academia style stickers and stamps.

Can I choose a specific book?

No, the fun of Blind Date with a Book is the element of surprise. You won't know the exact title or author until you unwrap the book. However, you can select the genre that interests you, and we'll match you with a book from that category. Alternatively, you have the option to leave it as a delightful surprise and allow us to choose the genre for you.

How do I know I will get a “good” book?

Rest assured that we prioritize quality when selecting books for our collection. To ensure a "good" book, we rely on Goodreads ratings as our guiding criteria. We handpick books that have received a rating of 3.5/5 or higher on Goodreads, accompanied by a substantial number of reviews from fellow readers. This ensures that you receive a book that has been well-received by the reading community.

What condition are the books in?

We offer preloved and remainder books. In the case of a preloved book, you can expect it to be gently used, with minimal wear and tear but no significant damage or missing pages. Remainder books are copies of brand new titles that have a small mark or dot on the edge. These books are typically surplus or excess stock from publishers. While they may exhibit minor shelf wear, they are generally in excellent condition. Every book in our collection is meticulously handpicked to guarantee its overall excellent condition.

Will I receive a book that is in the middle of a series?

It is possible that you will receive a book that is part of a series, however, we will only ever send the first book in a series.

Can I return or exchange the book if I don't like it?

Blind Date with a Book purchases are final and non-refundable. We believe in embracing the surprise and unpredictability of the reading experience. However, if you encounter any issues with the condition or quality of the book, please reach out to us, and we'll be happy to assist you.

How can I avoid getting a book I've already read?

While we strive to offer a wide variety of titles, there is a chance you may receive a book you've read before. However, at checkout we provide a personalization section where you can leave a note about your order, ensuring it meets your preferences. After selecting your desired book genre, you can inform us of any authors or titles you would prefer us to avoid sending. Additionally, if you have any triggers or sensitive topics that you'd like us to be aware of, kindly let us know, and we'll take them into consideration when selecting your book. Your satisfaction is our priority, and we strive to accommodate your preferences as best we can to create a tailored reading experience.

Is Blind Date with a Book suitable for gifts?

Definitely! Blind Date with a Book makes for a unique and memorable gift. You can surprise your loved ones with an intriguing book selection, allowing them to embark on their own literary adventure. We’re also happy to include a gift note! Just use the personalization section when checking out to leave your gift note.

Report this item to Etsy

Blind Date With a Book – Historical Fiction Novel - Surprise, Mystery Book & Bookish Gifts

Name: Blind Date With a Book – Historical Fiction Novel - Surprise, Mystery Book & Bookish Gifts
Brand: UnexpectedBookshelf
SKU: 1647892410
Price: 27.16 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 5.0 (3 reviews)

NowPrice:$27.16+

Original Price: $31.95+

15% off

•

Sale ends in 1 day

By Stacey

UnexpectedBookshelf ·

Saint Paul, Minnesota

4.9 (136)

Arrives soon! Get it by Oct 3-13 if you order today

Subgenre

Please select an option

With or Without Goodies

Please select an option

You can only make an offer when buying a single item

Embark on a captivating journey through history with our blind date with a historical novel – perfect for those who love to explore bygone eras and delve into rich narratives! Choose from ancient history, medieval tales, 19th-century dramas, 20th-century sagas, World War I epics, World War II stories, or opt to be surprised and discover something new.

Your handpicked historical novel will arrive wrapped in eco-friendly brown paper and twine, adorned with charming eclectic, cottagecore, and dark academia style stickers, stamps and other ephemera.

Not sure what remainder books are? They are new and unread books usually sold when publishers overprint. They may have a small mark on the edge and/or minor shelf wear, but are still in excellent to new condition. Buying these books is not only environmentally friendly, as it helps reduce waste, but it also supports small businesses like mine. Plus, you might discover hidden gems you wouldn't have come across otherwise, including lesser-known finds that may not be prominently featured in mainstream bookstores. Feel good about your purchase, knowing you're contributing to sustainability and helping indie sellers thrive.

You can choose "Book Only" to receive just the book or "Book With Goodies" for an extra treat! If you go for "Book With Goodies," your package will include a curated selection of bookish goodies to enhance your reading experience. Along with your journey through history, you'll get a bookmark, a cute keychain, a book-themed pin, an assortment of stickers, a mini notebook, and a stylish pen.

To ensure a great read, we rely on the historical fiction community’s trusted guide – Goodreads ratings. Every historical novel we select has a rating of 3.5/5 or higher, endorsed by readers who appreciate stories that bring the past to life.

Step into the past with our curated selection of historical fiction! Immerse yourself in diverse eras and compelling narratives that transport you across centuries. Your next immersive and enlightening read awaits!

*Gift messages will be handwritten, not printed unless requested.

Order today to get by Oct 3-13
Returns & exchanges not accepted
Cost to ship: $6.03

Enjoy free shipping to the US when you spend $35+ at this shop.
Ships from: Rosemount, MN

There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Country

Zip code

Please enter a valid zip code.

Etsy Purchase Protection
Shop confidently on Etsy knowing if something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back for all eligible purchases — see program terms

Etsy invests in climate solutions like electric trucks and carbon offsets for every delivery. See how

Stacey

Owner of UnexpectedBookshelf

Following Follow shop

Message Stacey

This seller usually responds within 24 hours.

Reviews for this item

5.0

(3 reviews)

5.0 Item quality

5.0 Shipping

5.0 Customer service

100% Buyers recommend

5 This item

Lisa Dec 20, 2025

The books were so beautifully packaged!

Lisa Dec 20, 2025

5 This item

CARRIE Aug 25, 2025

Gorgeous wrapping and loved the little packet of goodies, one which is an instant staple in my purse.. Can't wait to read to book! It's about a period that you don't find that many stores set in. I love that!

CARRIE Aug 25, 2025