This item has had a high sales volume over the past 6 months.
  • May include: A dark metal horseshoe with a tan leather cord and a light wood plaque featuring the text Bless This Home with much love & happiness Aly & Tim Est 2024 and a white ribbon bow, presented in a box with paper filler and an informational card.
  • May include: A collection of U-shaped metal horseshoes with varying degrees of rust and oxidation, layered together. The text "From this..." is overlaid in large, light-colored sans-serif font across the center of the metal objects.
  • May include: A rustic metal horseshoe with a leather hanging strap, featuring a white wooden tag inscribed with "Bless This Home 2025" and a white ribbon bow. The horseshoe rests on a card with printed text, all contained within a box.
  • May include: A silver-colored metal horseshoe decorated with a white ribbon bow and wrapped with thin black and tan cord, resting on a printed card with the text With No Personalization, all contained within a square box filled with brown paper.
  • May include: A silver-toned metal horseshoe nail with a flat, textured head and a tapered point. The nail is positioned diagonally over a printed text background that reads, Includes a horseshoe nail for hanging, The Legend of the.
  • May include: A silver-painted metal horseshoe featuring a brown leather cord threaded through the top holes for hanging. A rectangular wooden plaque is attached to the bottom, inscribed with the text Dustin & Sabrina 9-26-2026, accented by a white ribbon.
  • The finished packaging of the horseshoe gift in a white box with rustic hemp string tied in a bow around it.
  • Personalized horseshoe with leather strap, featuring a wooden plaque engraved with couple's names and wedding date.
  • May include: A silver-colored metal horseshoe with a brown leather hanging cord and a white ribbon bow. A rectangular wooden plaque is attached to the front, featuring the wood-burned text "Justin & Kelly 2024" in a dark, handwritten font style.
  • May include: A dark brown, weathered metal horseshoe featuring a light-colored rectangular wooden plaque engraved with the text "Scott & Nikki." A thin white ribbon is tied in a bow at the bottom, and a thin leather cord is threaded through the top.
  • Personalized horseshoe with leather strap, featuring a wooden plaque engraved with couple's names and wedding date.
  • May include: A silver-painted metal horseshoe with a brown leather hanging cord and a light wood tag featuring the text First Home Est. 2025, tied with a white ribbon. The horseshoe rests on a card detailing The Legend of the Lucky Horseshoe.
  • May include: A silver-painted metal horseshoe featuring a tan leather cord threaded through the top holes. A rectangular wooden plaque is attached to the front, engraved with the text "The Heareth Cabin 2026," accented by a white ribbon bow.
  • May include: A dark brown metal horseshoe with a tan leather cord and a wooden rectangular tag featuring the text Bless This Ranch With Much Love & Happiness Randy & April Est. 2026, accented with a white satin ribbon bow, nestled in shredded craft paper.
  • May include: A silver-painted metal horseshoe with brown leather cords tied through the top holes. A rectangular wooden plaque is attached to the front, engraved with "Mr & Mrs Prather Est. 2026" and decorated with a small white satin ribbon bow.
  • May include: A light-colored wooden plaque with the wood-burned text "Scott & Taylor 2024" nestled among white accordion-folded paper strips. Beneath the plaque lies a cream-colored card with black text and horseshoe illustrations, tied with a white ribbon.
  • An explanation of the Legend of the Lucky Horseshoe.
  • May include: A cream-colored sign with black text that reads: These are made by a real Texas horsewoman (me) with real, used horseshoes worn by actual horses (ours and friends) so each one will be slightly different. All are sealed to prevent rust.
  • May include: A dark metal horseshoe with a tan leather cord and a light wood plaque featuring the text Bless This Home with much love & happiness Aly & Tim Est 2024 and a white ribbon bow, presented in a box with paper filler and an informational card.
  • Product video
  • May include: A collection of U-shaped metal horseshoes with varying degrees of rust and oxidation, layered together. The text "From this..." is overlaid in large, light-colored sans-serif font across the center of the metal objects.
  • May include: A rustic metal horseshoe with a leather hanging strap, featuring a white wooden tag inscribed with "Bless This Home 2025" and a white ribbon bow. The horseshoe rests on a card with printed text, all contained within a box.
  • May include: A silver-colored metal horseshoe decorated with a white ribbon bow and wrapped with thin black and tan cord, resting on a printed card with the text With No Personalization, all contained within a square box filled with brown paper.
  • May include: A silver-toned metal horseshoe nail with a flat, textured head and a tapered point. The nail is positioned diagonally over a printed text background that reads, Includes a horseshoe nail for hanging, The Legend of the.
  • May include: A silver-painted metal horseshoe featuring a brown leather cord threaded through the top holes for hanging. A rectangular wooden plaque is attached to the bottom, inscribed with the text Dustin & Sabrina 9-26-2026, accented by a white ribbon.
  • The finished packaging of the horseshoe gift in a white box with rustic hemp string tied in a bow around it.
  • Personalized horseshoe with leather strap, featuring a wooden plaque engraved with couple's names and wedding date.
  • May include: A silver-colored metal horseshoe with a brown leather hanging cord and a white ribbon bow. A rectangular wooden plaque is attached to the front, featuring the wood-burned text "Justin & Kelly 2024" in a dark, handwritten font style.
  • May include: A dark brown, weathered metal horseshoe featuring a light-colored rectangular wooden plaque engraved with the text "Scott & Nikki." A thin white ribbon is tied in a bow at the bottom, and a thin leather cord is threaded through the top.
  • Personalized horseshoe with leather strap, featuring a wooden plaque engraved with couple's names and wedding date.
  • May include: A silver-painted metal horseshoe with a brown leather hanging cord and a light wood tag featuring the text First Home Est. 2025, tied with a white ribbon. The horseshoe rests on a card detailing The Legend of the Lucky Horseshoe.
  • May include: A silver-painted metal horseshoe featuring a tan leather cord threaded through the top holes. A rectangular wooden plaque is attached to the front, engraved with the text "The Heareth Cabin 2026," accented by a white ribbon bow.
  • May include: A dark brown metal horseshoe with a tan leather cord and a wooden rectangular tag featuring the text Bless This Ranch With Much Love & Happiness Randy & April Est. 2026, accented with a white satin ribbon bow, nestled in shredded craft paper.
  • May include: A silver-painted metal horseshoe with brown leather cords tied through the top holes. A rectangular wooden plaque is attached to the front, engraved with "Mr & Mrs Prather Est. 2026" and decorated with a small white satin ribbon bow.
  • May include: A light-colored wooden plaque with the wood-burned text "Scott & Taylor 2024" nestled among white accordion-folded paper strips. Beneath the plaque lies a cream-colored card with black text and horseshoe illustrations, tied with a white ribbon.
  • An explanation of the Legend of the Lucky Horseshoe.
  • May include: A cream-colored sign with black text that reads: These are made by a real Texas horsewoman (me) with real, used horseshoes worn by actual horses (ours and friends) so each one will be slightly different. All are sealed to prevent rust.
  • Product video
Report this item to Etsy

Lucky Horseshoe Gift Good Luck Decor New Home Housewarming Wedding Gift Home Decor Real Estate Closing Gift Horse Lover Gift Anniversary

HoofandHilarity  
5 out of 5 stars

Item highlights

  • Materials: Hemp
  • Dimensions: Width: 5 Inches; Height: 5 Inches; Depth: .5 Inches
  • Made to order

Seller's description

This beautifully crafted horseshoe is designed as a memorable keepsake for Newlyweds, First Home or First Apartment Together, Anniversary Gift, a Memorial for your Horse or Decorate Your Tack Room with it's Rustic Charm.
Featuring a sturdy leather strap for easy hanging, horseshoe nail included!,and a custom wood plaque engraved with the couple’s names and wedding date, family name, or horse name. Lucky Horseshoes make ideal lucky charm gifts and who doesn't need a little extra luck? Super Unique gift that Brings Luck!
A Note on Handmade: I use real wood and recycled horseshoes, so every piece is one-of-a-kind. Natural variations in wood grain and color are part of the charm!

Returns: Because these are made-to-order, I don't offer refunds. However, if you are truly unhappy with your piece, you may ship it back to me at your expense. Once the item is received in its original condition, a refund (minus original shipping) will be issued. I do not offer "keep the item" refunds under any circumstances.

View more

18 views in the last 24 hours

Price:$35.99

Please select a color

  • Be aware that the more letters/words you want, the smaller the printing will be in order to fit on the plaque.

    0/230

You can only make an offer when buying a single item

Shipping & return policies
  • Get it by
    Nov 14-19
  • Cost to ship
    $7.46 to United States, 43215.

Reviews for this item

What buyers say, summarized by AI: Perfect gift Love it Well packaged Looks great Helpful seller Fast shipping Great quality

4.9

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

(49 reviews)

4.7 Item quality
4.8 Shipping
4.9 Customer service
97% Buyers recommend
Filter by category
5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Dottie Nov 2, 2026

delivered on time and well received

Dottie Nov 2, 2026

Response from Carla McGuinness

Thank you Dottie! I'm so glad you love it and I've earned 5🌟s from you! It was a pleasure working with you! 😀

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Matt Oct 7, 2026

Great!!! Answered all my questions and was very helpful. 👍

Matt Oct 7, 2026

Response from Carla McGuinness

Thanks Matt! It was pleasure helping you! 🎉

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Kristi Sep 16, 2026

The horseshoe was absolutely beautiful and can't wait to give it to the person.

Kristi Sep 16, 2026

Response from Carla McGuinness

Thank you so much, Kristi! I'm very happy to hear you love my work and are excited to gift it! They're going to love it! :)

5 out of 5 stars 5 This item

Etsy buyer Sep 16, 2026

Product arrived gift ready; very cute packaging. Product as described, well done!

Etsy buyer Sep 16, 2026

Response from Carla McGuinness

Thank you so much! I put a lot of thought into how I would like to receive it and what would be the best gifting experience too!

Photos from reviews

Seller's description

Specifications

May include: A dark metal horseshoe with a tan leather cord and a light wood plaque featuring the text Bless This Home with much love & happiness Aly & Tim Est 2024 and a white ribbon bow, presented in a box with paper filler and an informational card.

This beautifully crafted horseshoe is designed as a memorable keepsake for Newlyweds, First Home or First Apartment Together, Anniversary Gift, a Memorial for your Horse or Decorate Your Tack Room with it's Rustic Charm.
Featuring a sturdy leather strap for easy hanging, horseshoe nail included!,and a custom wood plaque engraved with the couple’s names and wedding date, family name, or horse name. Lucky Horseshoes make ideal lucky charm gifts and who doesn't need a little extra luck? Super Unique gift that Brings Luck!
A Note on Handmade: I use real wood and recycled horseshoes, so every piece is one-of-a-kind. Natural variations in wood grain and color are part of the charm!

Returns: Because these are made-to-order, I don't offer refunds. However, if you are truly unhappy with your piece, you may ship it back to me at your expense. Once the item is received in its original condition, a refund (minus original shipping) will be issued. I do not offer "keep the item" refunds under any circumstances.

  • Made by
    HoofandHilarity
  • Materials
    Hemp
  • Material features
    Upcycled
  • Width
    5 Inches
  • Height
    5 Inches
  • Depth
    .5 Inches

Delivery details and policies

  • Get it by
    Nov 14-19
  • Returns and exchanges
    Not accepted.
  • Ships from
    Friendswood, TX
  • Cost to ship
    $7.46 to United States, 43215

    There was a problem calculating your shipping. Please try again.

Shop with confidence
Star Seller

This seller consistently earned 5-star reviews, shipped orders on time, and replied quickly to messages.

Etsy Purchase Protection

If something goes wrong with an order, we've got your back on all eligible purchases. View program terms

Climate investments

Etsy supports climate solutions, from electric delivery trucks to carbon offsets for every delivery. View how

Meet your seller

HoofandHilarity
Carla McGuinness
HoofandHilarity ·

Friendswood, Texas

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience. 4.9
·
350 sales
·
3 years on Etsy
Carla
1 shop member

Usually responds in a few hours

Smooth shipping Has a history of shipping on time with tracking.

Speedy replies Has a history of replying to messages quickly.

Rave reviews Average review rating is 4.8 or higher.

You may also like

Shoppers with similar taste loved these

Show more
Show more
Assortment of wedding items that are available on EtsyAssortment of wedding items that are available on EtsyAssortment of wedding items that are available on Etsy

Get personalized picks for your big day!

Wedding date
No date yet? Explore wedding ideasOpens a new tab

Top wedding searches to shop

Bridesmaid gifts

Groomsmen gifts

Wedding gifts

Engagement gifts

Explore related searches

6th Wedding Anniversary Gift

Horse Shoe

Western Wedding Gift

Lucky Horseshoe

Personalized Horseshoe

Housewarming Gift Ideas

Engraved Horseshoe

Small Engraved Horseshoe

Real Horseshoes Engraved

Horseshoe New Home

Horseshoe Housewarming Gift

Listed on Nov 9, 2026
395 favorites
Homepage Home & Living Home Decor Wall Decor

Looking for more? Find it on Etsy